Ian Anstice

Public librarian since 1994, user of public libraries since my first memories ... and a keen advocate of public libraries and chronicler of the UK public libraries scene. Library manager since 1998, winner of Information Professional of the Year 2011 and Winsford Customer Service "Oscar" 2012 and 2014, honorary CILIP fellow 2015, CILIP Wales Library Champion of the Year 2016.

Homepage: https://www.publiclibrariesnews.com


Posts by Ian Anstice

Suffolk branch manager quits over plans

Comment 

Things are not starting well for the experiment that is the Suffolk Libraries Industrial and Provident Society (IPS).  Readers will recall that Suffolk have decided to pass all of their libraries to this social enterprise initially run by an unelected board.  The manager of Aldeburgh Library has resigned at the policies of this board, the chair of which is heavily involved in his branch.  The policies in question include gaining more than half of the income of the library from self-generated income such as increasing charges and fines.  The chair of the IPS, Clive Fox, appears to have tried to present this resignation as a retirement.  This is not the first worrying thing done by Mr Fox. He had, according to previous reports, called library campaigners “rent a mob”. Hmm Suffolk Libraries IPS? That acronym of SLIPS seems strangely accurate.
399 libraries (309 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Commuters face peak rush hour rail fare rises – Telegraph.   “Other changes could see libraries, post offices and supermarkets selling train tickets as hundreds of ticket offices are closed. According to Department for Transport officials this could see ticket selling machines being installed at outlets across the country, where staff would also be given special training in servicing rail passengers.”
  • Out of the toy cupboard – New Statesman.   Article by Michael Rosen: “children’s authors are rarely asked for their opinion on how to get children reading. Why not? We know far more than politicians.” …”One moment they’ve tried to control the selection, the next the pedagogy about it, the next its removal – whether by replacing it with barking at letters (phonics), an explosion of worksheets and tests based on excerpts (not whole books) or by closing libraries. This has gone on even as minister after minister has unconvincingly blethered on about this or that great author they once read or wished they had.”
  • Ultimate library: online archive aims to collect a physical copy of every book in existence – Mail. “Mr Kahle is worried that as volumes are increasingly digitised their paper versions are being thrown out, raising the prospect that one day the originals will be unavailable. And if the digital copies are somehow corrupted, the knowledge those books hold could be lost forever.” … “Every week, 20,000 new volumes arrive to be archived, many of them donated by libraries and universities who no longer have space to store material that is, in any case, often easily found online.” … “Mr Kahle’s archive stores books in specially adapted 40ft shipping containers. Each holds around 40,000 books in a carefully controlled environment to stop them from spoiling.”

Local News

  • Barnet – Union which defeated outsourcing tells its story – Barnet Today.  “At Barnet Unison’s annual general meeting last Thursday John Stevenson, president of the Edinburgh branch, told members how they successfully lobbied councillors to reject the proposals, breaking a coalition council in the process.”Barnet Unison secretary John Burgess told The Press the meeting proved it was never too late for councillors to change their minds. “The danger here is it’s so ideological,” he said. “There seems to be no room or scope to even listen.””
  • Brent – Fresh hope for campaign to save Kensal Rise Library – Brent & Kilburn Times.   “The Oxford University college which donated a library to the community closed by Brent Council has said it would be happy to let residents run it. Kensal Rise Library, in Bathurst Gardens, was a gift by All Souls College, and was opened by American author Mark Twain, 111 years ago. However, Brent Council closed the Victorian reading room in October last year. But this week a spokesman from the college wrote to the Friends of Kensal Rise Library and said: “All Souls College has contacted the council via its solicitor to inform them that the college would be happy to consider the library being kept open as proposed in the business plan prepared by the Friends of Kensal Rise Library.’ The ball is now in Brent Council’s court.”
  • Brighton and Hove – New Woodingdean library plans up for discussion – Argus.   “Brighton and Hove City Council and the NHS plan to create a modern facility at the centre of the community on the site of the current 1950s library in Warren Road. It will also include a new GP surgery for Dr Sagar and Partners, which will be relocated from The Ridgway in Woodingdean. If approved, the plans will expand the library space to 269sq m, almost double the current size, with extra facilities such as a computer suite.”
  • Camden – Alan Bennett says proposal to put Rio statue on Primrose Hill is a “foolish idea” – Camden New Journal.   “The diarist and playwright was speaking at “An Evening with Alan Bennett” – a £10 benefit for the Primrose Hill library campaign, which sold out [400 tickets] in just 10 days.”

“So far, £543,000 has been pledged for the library by 403 people, and 156 have said they will give up their time to run the newly refurbished library. Two weeks ago it was announced that the group would be given a 20-year lease from the council with the first six guaranteed rent-free.”

  • City of London pressed to sign Heath Library deal – Camden New Journal. “The City of London has been told to “get on with it” and sign a deal with a voluntary group fighting to keep Heath Library open. A letter sent by Camden Council leisure chief Labour councillor Tulip Siddiq has asked the City to back the plans, adding that the Town Hall is willing to hand over a cash pot worth £124,000 to make the scheme viable.”

“The City, the richest local authority in the UK with trust funds and assets worth billions, is reportedly delaying signing a deal as it is unsure whether it will maximise income from the site. It has a duty to use the buildings it manages there to promote the poet’s [Keats] works.” 

  • Doncaster – Mayor vetoes extra money for the borough’s libraries – South Yorkshire Times.  
  • Dorset – Calls to help Dorset libraries at risk of closure rejected – Dorset Echo.  Members of the council’s cabinet approved the latest proposals to allow them to move forward with the handover of control but turned down a specific request for additional resources to start up the new community libraries. But they promised to leave libraries in a ‘reasonable condition’ when they hand them back over to the community.” … “The Salvation Army has played down suggestions at the meeting that it could offer an unlikely lifeline to Portland Underhill libary.”
    • Council says no to extra help for community libraries – Daily Echo.   “Mr Davies said: “We will not be spending the money on these Labour Party plans when we already have a system that works with volunteer-run services.” However, Mr Davies added that if ward councillors in Carcroft and Denaby came to him with a good case and enough volunteers he would consider re-opening libraries in those areas.” … “The amendments received 43 votes in favour, six against and three abstentions.” [But the mayor’s veto meant that they were not carried].
  • Kent – Comprehensive library survey to indicate future of the serviceNews Shopper.   “Discussions about the service in each district and how else it could be delivered will begin in the next few months, Kent County Council said, with proposals made as early as June in some areas.Individual profiles for each library have been drawn up, including the number of borrowers and the running costs, and can be viewed at kent.gov.uk/libraries.”
  • Lincolnshire – Chance to help town’s library – Market Rasen mail.  “The library is now one of several across Lincolnshire that has a donation box for residents to make financial contributions to its book fund. Lincolnshire County Council’s head of libraries and heritage Jonathan Platt said: “We already buy hundreds of new titles each year for our library network. These donation boxes allow people to make a voluntary contribution to their library, which will enable each of the participating sites to buy more books for their customers.””
  • Nottinghamshire – Mansfield Library visitor numbers double after £3.4m refurbishment –  Chad. “As we celebrate World Book Day, the attendance at our libraries and the success of Mansfield Library since January reaffirms our commitment to the library service and demonstrates how the community values its libraries. We are especially pleased with the figures at Mansfield Library and hope people are enjoying the new facilities.”

“Iain Rousham who left Aldeburgh library at the end of February says that Clive Fox, chairman of the new countywide library organisation and the Aldeburgh library Steering Group, initially wrote in the Group’s press release that Rousham was retiring.  Iain asked for this to be changed so it reflected more accurately that he had resigned. Rousham has  made it clear that he disagreed with the plans put forward by the Steering Group and its refusal to consult further with Aldeburgh people after the county council promised all libraries would stay open.” Suffolk – Library manager resigns over policy of chairman of new Suffolk libraries organisation – Suffolk Wordblog.  

    • Aldeburgh Library Manager quits due to disagreements with Clive Fox, Suffolk IPS Chair – James Hargrave’s Blog.   “This is embarrassing to both Suffolk County Council and the IPS and it appears Fox attempted to present Rousham’s departure as a “retirement” when it clearly was not.” … “To my mind the appointment of Fox as Chairman is looking more and more like a mistake and it will be interesting to see if he survives this early embarrassing incident.” 
  • South Tyneside – Friends aim to overcome library service cuts – Shields Gazette.  “Help is needed to stage fundraising efforts to support book readings, workshops, craft sessions and other community events. Council bosses have pledged that despite spending restrictions, no borough library is to close, but there are plans to reduce opening hours.”
  • Surrey – Permission transcript – High Court of Justice.   The full decision made by the judge to disallow the council’s objections and to allow the judicial review.

“To hell with this” : Doncaster Mayor won’t fund libraries as he thinks it would deter volunteers

Comment

The Mayor of Doncaster, Peter Davies, has said that his council will no longer continue to provide paid staff in fourteen libraries directly because he wants volunteers to do it instead.  He said “”If you put some paid people into libraries run by volunteers the likely scenario is the volunteers will say, ‘to hell with this, they are getting paid I am doing it for nothing, I am not sticking around”. What makes this even more tragic is that the money is available to provide staffing but Cllr Davies said that providing it would send the “wrong message” to communities if he provided it and he even overruled the majority will of Doncasters’ councillors to stick to his guns.  This is the most stark example yet of the politicisation of volunteering.  Ironically, the mayor is sending far more of a wrong message by his statement.  He is openly stating that volunteering will directly lead to people losing their jobs.  What makes the situation even worse is that local people are not exactly falling over themselves to work for nothing to do something that used to paid for by their council tax anyway.  Two branches, in the most deprived wards in Doncaster, have already closed.  They could not attract enough volunteers.  Many of the twelve others that the mayor is keen to offload onto the community are struggling to get sufficient interest.
This is hardly the rosy image that those in favour of the Big Society would seek to convey.  Of course, what the outspoken mayor is saying publicly is what many councillors around the country are thinking privately.  By doing so, they are changing the goodwill and love for a public service into a destructive force. Volunteering should be an unalloyed good for a community and, if done properly, can be of tremendous positive impact in a library.  What is happening in Doncaster and elsewhere in this country is a destructive perversion of that ideal.

It’s not going well in North Yorkshire either. This from the Private Eye (Issue no.1309 9-22 March Library News p.28):

“When North Yorkshire shelved its plans to close many of its 42 libraries last year (Eye 1279), the county council fended off a vociferous Save Our Libraries campaign by announcing it had high hopes that all the threatened branch libraries would be “saved” by local communities.

By the end of this January, library chiefs were reduced to rather frantic begging for volunteers via local press, saying that working for nothing in the library could offer young people “work experience” while also providing opportunities for anyone feeling “lonely or isolated”.

In Hunmanby, near Scarborough, the whole plan was scuppered when, despite having 25 people prepared to give up time to man the library desk, no willing volunteer coordinator could be recruited and no viable scheme had been put forward in time.  So now, instead of a library open four days a week and offering children’s activity clubs as well as books and community internet access, the village will just get a fortnightly visit from the county’s mobile library.”

399 libraries (309 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Culture, Media and Sport Committee announces final evidence session on library closuresParliament.uk – “Tuesday 13 March 2012. “Following the Comprehensive Spending Review, a number of local authorities announced plans to close one or more libraries in their areas, sparking campaigns and protests. The Committee is investigating what powers and obligations the Government has regarding these closures. For its final evidence session on library closures the Committee will take evidence from: At 10.30 am: Ed Vaizey MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Minister for Culture, Communications and Creative Industries), Department for Culture, Media and Sport.
  • How to get ahead in … library services – Guardian.  “Local library staff are being trained to show customers how to access potentially life-changing advice and information online in a pilot scheme which could create a new national library service. Sixty libraries have been recruited to eight pilot projects looking at how libraries can direct library users to quality internet advice and information about finding a job, changing career or keeping healthy.”

“Although cuts are hitting library services Taylor says staff training and development budgets for digital skills are surviving. “In my authority we still have the same budget for digital training we had two years ago. We are using the skills of colleagues who are more advanced in the field, but we still put people on external courses because we felt it represents value for money.”

made for Save Our Libraries Day, 2011.  A year old but still great to watch.

  • Returns sorter removes tedious library jobHutt News (New Zealand).  “Books, CDs, DVDs and magazines put through the library’s returns slot will have their RFID (radio frequency identification) tags ‘read” by the automated sorter, which will update the library database to show the item has been returned. The machine will be pre-programmed to sort the books into five category bins using conveyor belts.” … “At Brisbane central library there is a large glass wall and people just stand there watching the sorter.”
  • Shared service benefits at conference – Public Service.   “Personnel from local government and public libraries across the UK are expected to gain the knowledge needed to set up their own consortium – or to implement shared services or shared working on a smaller scale – when they attend a consortia conference organised by two of the largest public library consortia, the London Libraries Consortium and LibrariesWest.”

Local News

  • Bath and Northeast Somerset Recycle an ex-library book into a work of art and win a prize – This is Somerset.  “”The idea is for members to pick up one of the old books from their local library and ‘recycle’ it as a piece of art. We’ve have already had some members of staff attempt some quick pieces of their own to inspire people.”
  • Devon – Campaigners to carry on Sidmouth Health Centre fight – Sidmouth Herald.  “The Herald reported last week how county council bosses said £600,000 allocated to Sidmouth Library – seen as the catalyst for the regeneration of both amenities in Blackmore Drive – will be spent across Devon.
  • Doncaster – Volunteers could save the day for Denaby Library – South Yorkshire Times.   “At the meeting a Labour motion that 14 of the 26 libraries the council closed receive £382,000 to keep them open was passed. The decision included re-opening Denaby and Carcroft libraries. Many of the other sites have been taken over by volunteers. But yesterday Mr Davies said he would veto the spending. Under the borough’s governance procedures the mayor has the final decision on almost all policies.” … “Mr Davies said he had provided £110,000 additional funding to help libraries but Labour’s plan could send the “wrong message” leading to communities not supporting libraries.”
    • Mayor defends decision to veto £380,000 libraries investment – Yorkshire Post.  ““As I understand it, I cannot spend the money on anything else, but I am not prepared to spend it on the libraries as suggested because my policy is already successful. So the money will be placed on one side. The Labour party spent years neglecting libraries in this borough and my policy was to close two and hand 12 over to the community to save money. We plan to go to town on the other 12 and make them much more welcoming and brighter, not the run down, dowdy places they were under previous Labour administrations.”

“Mr Davies said under the elected mayoral system he had the right to spend or not spend the money as he wished and would overrule the council for the first time in three years. He said: “If you put some paid people into libraries run by volunteers the likely scenario is the volunteers will say, ‘to hell with this, they are getting paid I am doing it for nothing, I am not sticking around’.”Ms Holland said: “I am appalled by the news that the mayor will ignore this vote and refuses to wake up to the fact that Doncaster people want to see community libraries supported and closed libraries reopened.”” Mayor of Doncaster refuses to open libraries – BBC.   English Democrat Mayor overrules (Labour) majority of councillors and continues with plans to withdraw staff from 14 libraries. 

  • Durham – Inspire, include, inform: library consultation – Durham Council.   “Our proposals are: to keep open all our library buildings, but reduce the opening hours funded by the council, to revise our criteria for the communities that are served by our mobile library service, to co-locate libraries wherever possible with other services and to invest to improve their appearance and facilities, to drive down our support and management costs, to move our library services into a not-for-profit Trust.”
  • East Sussex – Give your view on libraries – Bexhill on Sea Observer.   “East Sussex County Council’s (ESCC) library and information service is looking at how it provides rural and mobile library services across the County and says it wants to ensure it is giving the best service at the best price – and in the right place at the right time. Once the survey has closed the results will be compiled and reports drawn up for councillors and senior managers. Any proposals for change will be opened to full public consultation before any decisions are made.”
  • Hertfordshire – Waltham Cross LibraryHertfordshire Council.   Self-service on Mondays and Thursdays due to other non-library staff using library.  The council cut overall opening hours in its libraries by one third last year.

“We are extremely concerned about unstaffed opening – a small, short-term access gain risks future staff cuts and volunteer-run branches. We do not believe that library services should be reduced to the book stock, a photocopier and a few self-service machines. We do not believe that Hertfordshire’s library users are getting a fair deal from this arrangement.” We Heart Libraries on Twitter.

  • Surrey – I won’t rule out standing for the leadership: that from sacked Surrey Councillor Denise Saliagopoulos – Eagle Radio.  “However, Standards Committee member Eber Kington said: “Any matter referred to the Standards Committee has to be taken seriously. “If two people have been asked to step down while that is going on, they must be issues which are probably more than just normal, ordinary concerns.” Mr Kington adds that this could be an opportunity for the council to reverse its plans to get volunteers to run some libraries: “He (David Hodge) is a very pragmatic politician. “He also listens when he realises things have gone wrong. “He will look for opportunities to make changes and I think the library one, where he could be looking at costs against the council, would be a good one to start changing.”
  • Trafford – Report attacks Old Trafford library plans – Messenger.   “a spokesman for the Hands Off Old Trafford Library (HOOT) Campaign said: “One of our biggest concerns has been that the council doesn’t seem to have done any kind of feasibility study before publishing these proposals. It fell to the community to do the hard work of analysing the plans and we discovered that the council’s sums simply don’t add up.”

500 books is a library

399 libraries (309 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

National: Lobby your MP to help public libraries, 13th March. Website: http://www.speakupforlibraries.org/  Download flyer here.

News

  • Beautiful bookshelves, in pictures – Guardian.  These are hardly for public libraries but they are, indeed, beautiful bookshelves.
  • Children’s reading group network launches in Wales – Reading Agency (press release).  The Reading Agency is delighted to announce the launch of its new Welsh Clonclyfrau/Chatterbooks network of children’s reading groups on 7 March 2012.Chatterbooks is a reading group programme for children aged four to twelve; its patron is top children’s author Dame Jacqueline Wilson. Chatterbooks groups run in libraries and schools, supporting children’s literacy development by encouraging them to have a really good time reading and talking about books.”
  • Deprofessionalization and the library blogosphere – Library Juice (USA).   “Library administrators and funding institutions have an interest in the deprofessionalization of librarianship in two ways – economic efficiency and control. Library support staff, who are being trained up to take on most responsibilities now handled by professional librarians, cost libraries less in wages.”. [Interesting piece.  Volunteers, of course, cost even less … but on the other hand, control is harder than with paid staff – Ed.]
  • Full-time school librarians linked to higher student reading scores – School Library Journal.   “According to new research from Library Research Services, which reviewed standardized test scores from Colorado schools in 2005 and 2011, reading scores statistically increased when schools retained or gained a school librarian. “There is a positive and statistically significant relationship between advanced reading levels and endorsed librarian staffing trends,” reads the report, published last month.”

“That this House recognises that public libraries are important community spaces and a vital public resource; acknowledges that many are under threat due to wide-scale budget cuts; is concerned about the impact of closures on social inclusion, social mobility and society more generally; welcomes the formation of Speak Up for Libraries, a coalition of national organisations and library campaigners that is leading a delegation of supporters from around the country to Parliament on 13 March 2012 in order to highlight the vital role that library services, run by professionally trained and qualified staff, play in the community and for individuals; and therefore calls on the Government to undertake a thorough assessment of the state of the public library service and develop a national vision for the service.”  Speak up for libraries” Early Day Motion House of Commons. Session: 2010-12 Date tabled: 05.03.2012 Primary sponsor:  Anderson, David Sponsors: Durkan, Mark, Hancock, Mike, Hepburn, Stephen, Lavery, Ian, Meale, Alan

  • Structuring and managing a volunteering programme – Creating Capacity.  A course advertised to library managers on online discussion site lis-pub-libs [which has caused some negative comments along the lines of “turkeys voting for Christmas” – Ed.]

Changes

Blackburn with Darwen Barlow Institute has 500 books, open only on Saturdays, to replace withdrawn mobile library.
Bolton Castle Hill Library closed, Heaton Library will be closed on Friday.  Replaced by books in local centres with self-service machines.
Brighton – Wifi to be installed at Jubilee Library.
Dorset – Volunteer groups have presented business plans to take over seven branches that would otherwise close, two other libraries without sufficient volunteers (Portland Underhill and Corfe Castle) likely to close.
Hertfordshire – Radlett library open self-service only Monday morning termtimes as Children’s Centre staff use library for sessions.

Local News

  • Birmingham – Four-day week plan for most of Birmingham’s community librariesBirmingham Mail.  “23 local libraries will now be open for 26 hours a week, spread over four days.” … “In another move they rubber-stamped plans to sell a series of Sutton Coldfield car parks to pay for £2.5 million of repair work to the Town Centre library which has been closed since 2010 due to asbestos.”
  • Blackburn with Darwen – Official opening for village library – Bolton News.  The library is open every Saturday from 10am to 1pm, and storytime sessions for youngsters are already proving to be a hit. There is also a cafe selling hot and cold drinks as well as snacks. The library stocks around 500 books. Volunteers hope the numbers joining will continue to grow, and there is a possibility that the library’s opening hours could be extended if there is the demand.”
  • Bolton – Third “self-service” point replaces library – Bolton News.   Castle Hill Library closed, to be “replaced” by a “collection point” at Tonge UCAN Centre.  “The new-style service enables people to borrow books via a self-service machine and computers will offer internet access.”
  • Brighton – Wifi plan for Jubilee Library in Brighton – Argus.  Brighton and Hove City Council said it hopes to boost conference business at Jubilee Library through the provision of Wi-Fi connections.A council spokeswoman said that if the pilot project proved successful Wi-Fi would be rolled out across all libraries in the city and could also be installed in other council-run locations with modifications.”
  • Doncaster – Mayor refuses to save Denaby and Carcroft Libraries – Save Doncaster Libraries.  The news on BBC Radio Sheffield this morning has revealed that Mayor Davies has refused the proposed amendment to his budget which would fund the re-opening of Denaby and Carcroft libraries, and would also fund a paid member of staff in both those libraries and the remaining 12 being thrown to vounteers to run.”
  • Dorset – Residents threatened by cuts ask to take over libraries – Dorset Echo.    “Seven communities set to lose core funding for their Libraries have submitted business plans to take on the facilities themselves. In July last year Dorset County Council agreed to withdraw funding to nine of the county’s libraries in a bid to save £800,000.” … ““Business cases could be approved on the basis that the county council will provide the agreed package of support without any additional resource support. This brings the risk that some local communities may feel that without any additional resource support from the county council, their plans to take on the responsibility for the building and for the provision of a non-core library service cannot progress.””
  • Durham – Twin campaigns to stop Durham library cuts Durham Times.  “Newton Hall and Belmont libraries, both on the outskirts of Durham, face having their weekly opening hours slashed from 43 to 20 under Durham County Council cutbacks.” … “Amanda Hopgood and Mamie Simmons, who represent Newton Hall, and Mark Wilkes, of neighbouring Framwellgate Moor, are launching an online petition against the cuts and sending out 3,000 leaflets asking residents to back their campaign.”
  • Hertfordshire – Self-service pilot scheme extends opening hours at Radlett Library – Hertfordshire Council.   Radlett Library is open on termtime Monday mornings because Children’s Centre staff use the building and so the building can be unlocked and the public can use the self-service machines.  The council reduced overall opening hours by a third last year.
  • Kent – How well do you know your local library? – Kent Council.   “Over the next few months, discussions will begin with groups in each district to talk about their local libraries and explore new ways to deliver library services. These groups will include councillors from local and county councils, and community representatives. The aim is to help these discussions by providing as much background information as possible so the groups can make informed recommendations on how their libraries could be run in the future.”.  Looking at co-location and, in some branches, voluntees running the building.
  • Surrey – Councillors forced to stand down from cabinet posts – BBC.  It’s unclear why this has happened or indeed if there is any libraries link.  It is included here as the council is facing a legal challenge over its cuts to libraries.

Rewriting the book

399 libraries (309 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

National: Lobby your MP to help public libraries, 13th March. Website: http://www.speakupforlibraries.org/ 
News
A video which may have a lot of lessons, although some of them painful
(and some may not be relevant), for libraries facing cuts in the UK.  
Ways around a crisis included job cuts, wifi, wifi,
 iphone app, email newsletter, web2.0, loaned ebooks, volunteer-run
summer classes for kids, local business partnerships
  • Join library cult – Library Cult (USA).  “Hypathia, Casanova, Mao Zedong, David Hume, John Dee, Benjamin Franklin, Giacomo Casanova, J. Edgar Hoover. Why were these people librarians? Did it have something to do with their rise to power, their worldly success?”. 
  • Public Library Standards – Good Library Blog.   Suggestions for library standards that would improve libraries are “1. Every library should have more books available than it did this time last year 2. Every library should be open longer hours than it was last year 3. Every library should be clean, with its windows washed and its light fittings working 4. Every public computer in a library should work properly 5. Every library should provide some private space for quiet study.” 
  • Rewriting the book: public libraries for a new age – Information Today.   [A piece which is unfortunately very heavy on jargon and so immediately biases me against it, for which I apologise in advance.  When translated, it appears to say, amongst other things, that public libraries will move away from the lending of books towards helping people with computers and council queries – Ed.]. 

Your help needed

Doncaster And Surrey– Help fund the legal challenges. 

Local News

  • Croydon – Upper Norwood Library – Croydon Council.  A suspiciously downbeat description of Upper Norwood Library by Croydon Council which is seeking to withdraw its funding for it.  The “consulation” link simply reloads the same page. “Upper Norwood Joint Library is jointly owned by Croydon and Lambeth Councils, situated within the borough of Lambeth. Up until recently it had been funded and managed by a joint committee of councillors from Lambeth and Croydon. The library still has its own membership procedures and circulation system and doesn’t accept Croydon or Lambeth library membership cards or accept/renew returned books or other items from Croydon or Lambeth libraries. See details below to contact the library for full details of joining/membership procedures and more information about all if its services.”.
    • Pay fines for sake of library’s future – This is Croydon Today.  “users owe the borough’s 13 libraries almost £100,000 in penalties, with more than £45,000 owed to Central Library alone. But a council spokesman this week insisted no libraries were under threat of closure. A total of 38,766 items are currently overdue with £96,307.93 owed across all libraries. The figures also show the longest overdue item is DVD Some Like It Hot which has been due back for nearly six years.”
  • Doncaster – We need your money.  And further information regarding DMBC’s true efforts – Save Doncaster Libraries.   “Edenthorpe are also realistic in their estimation regarding number of volunteers needed.  As they state Bawtry have over 70, this is close to sufficient it seems, Edenthorpe has thus far a generous estimate of one quarter of this, another threatened branch (Wheatley) has had merely 5 people come forward.  No doubt the Mayor will see this as proof of a community not wanting its library, in fact it is proof of what we at SDL have been saying all along – the majority of communities within Doncaster do not have the infrastructure to enable a library staffed by volunteers.”
  • Edinburgh – Libraries under threat, say campaigners – Ekklesia.   “Edinburgh East Save Our Services says: “Though it has been pretty much unreported in the media, there have been big cutbacks in staffing over the last few months and now there is a ‘consultation’ over opening hours – which does not appear to be all that it seems.”The consultation leaflets talk about providing ‘a library service that meets the needs of its customers’. However, says Ms Menzies, “when you look closely at the suggested new opening hours and compare them with the previous ones, they typically represent a 20% cut.”
  • Gloucestershire – Library budget cuts are double the amount admitted by GCC: letter to the press – FoGL.   “According to its own figures, Gloucestershire County Council is currently planning cuts to its Library Service of £1.8 million representing 25.7% of its budget, although £1 million of those savings were made last year (2011-12) mainly through the redundancy of qualified librarians. The council calls these savings “meeting the challenge”. This is bad enough. What the council won’t admit is that, prior to this £1.8 million cut, it has already taken a further similar amount  (£1,737,902) in cuts from the library service in the previous 3 years (2008-10). I have obtained these figures from CIPFA, the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, whose responsibility it is to compile figures on local government spending. This makes the total library cuts over £3.5 million.”
  • Isle of Man – Alan Bennett backs Isle of Man library campaign – BBC.   Campaigner says “”If we lose the libraries we are potentially going to end up with less Alan Bennetts in the future. Our libraries provide a vital link to the elderly, housebound, disabled and least privileged in Manx society, they need books and they need free books.”

“An interview I did for Camden New Journal … says all I want to say about libraries – and which applies equally to the Isle of Man as to NW1. All good wishes and with every support, Alan Bennett.” Support for saving libraries campaign – Isle of Man Today.  

  • Kent – Bereaved families in Kent suffer registrar delays – BBC.  Moving the registration of deaths into libraries has caused long delays and some distress.  “In January, Kent County Council (KCC) switched from registering deaths at register offices to local libraries, causing long waits for appointments.”.  January is the busiest month for Registrars and not all of the staff had been trained.
  • Oxfordshire – Libraries joining Ebook revolution – Oxford Times.  “Although Oxfordshire County Council’s decision has been welcomed by some, others have raised concerns libraries could suffer as a result. An array of 1,558 fiction and non-fiction titles are on offer and can be downloaded for free by library users. Oxford author Philip Pullman last night gave the scheme a cautious welcome. The His Dark Materials author said: “If it means more books are available to more people then I think that’s a good thing.” But voicing his fears about the impact of eBooks on publishing, he added: “It’s something that authors, publishers and agents are very worried about at the moment.“The whole question is very, very tangled.””
  • Surrey – Fundraising campaign to block Surrey libraries plan – BBC.   “The campaign has so far raised £5,000 and SLAM has appealed to the local community to help reach the £18,000 target within the remaining two weeks. It will be setting up stalls in towns including Weybridge, Woking, Guilford and Epsom, on 10 March. The Conservative-run council agreed in September to devolve responsibilities to groups of volunteers at 10 libraries – Bagshot, Bramley, Byfleet, Ewell Court, Lingfield, New Haw, Stoneleigh, Tattenhams, Virginia Water and Warlingham.”
  • Wokingham – Four bidders chosen as “privatisation” of libraries draws near – Henley Standard.   ““If we decide that none of the tenderers provides enough of our specification it will be a question of who has offered the nearest match to that specification.  We will look at how believable the tender is as it is not an impossibility for someone to try to do it as a loss leader. Our officers are quite good at spotting that. Cllr Baker said in the best case scenario the successful bidder would take over the service from the end of October.”

English libraries have no standards

Comment

Continuing with the complete inaction that most library campaigners would define as Mr Vaizey’s chief  characteristic, Ed has confirmed in parliament that the Government will not be reintroducing standards for public libraries.  Standards were introduced in 2001 but removed in 2009 and replaced by the now defunct MLA’s voluntary benchmarks.  Public library authorities have not needed to be measured against any standard since then, much to their detriment.  Wales have, in contrast, continued with standards that have been notably successful in embarrassing councils who fail to sufficiently fund their service.  
Expect Ed to make much of the funding that ACE are putting into libraries while at the Committee meeting.  Be sure he won’t mention though how insignificant they are compared to the funds that the MLA had at their disposal.  They went from £13m for the MLA to £3m for ACE.

Cllr David Pugh of the Isle of Wight, and whose evidence to the CMS Committee on his role in closing libraries has attracted some criticism and raised eyebrows, is to be interviewed between 12.00 & 1.00pm on Tuesday 6th March on Vectis Radio regarding library issues.  It should be an interesting for campaigners who, unfortunately, can’t phone in to question Ed Vaizey on his inaction but can phone Vectis Radio about Mr Pugh’s role from 11 to 12. Ed Vaizey is to be interviewed by the CMS Select Committee on Tuesday 13th March (an early copy of this posting said 6th March, apologies for the error).

399 libraries (309 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

National: Lobby your MP to help public libraries, 13th March. Website: http://www.speakupforlibraries.org/ 

News

“Q : Justin Tomlinson (North Swindon, Conservative)To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport what his strategy is for the future of the (a) library service and (b) standards and framework to support local delivery of library services.

A : Edward Vaizey (Parliamentary Under Secretary of State (Culture, Communications and Creative Industries), Business, Innovation and Skills; Wantage, Conservative) Arts Council England (ACE) has been given responsibility to advocate for and champion libraries’ roles and the public value they provide. ACE will capture and disseminate good practice in making efficiencies and meeting the needs of communities. Where appropriate, libraries will be eligible for ACE strategic investment funding. ACE will be leading a debate and research in 2012-13 on how libraries can respond to changing community needs and wider changes in society. ACE’s role on library development is one of providing advice and support. ACE has also launched the Libraries Development Initiative which has made grants totalling £230,000 to 13 library projects to help them explore ACE’s vision of arts and culture working together. ACE will shortly be writing to local authorities to make them aware of different ACE funding streams which can now be accessed by libraries. We do not propose to reintroduce the ‘public library service standards’. The Local Government and Public Involvement in Health Act 2007 gave local government greater flexibility in priority setting and greater discretion over how to meet them—the public library service standards were just 10 of over 1,000 indicators which authorities were no longer required to report performance against.” Hansard, 1st March.”

  • Libraries “invisible” to digital policymakers – UKauthorITy. Annie Mauger of CILIP: As well as helping many millions of UK adults who cannot read with basic literacy skills, librarians have a broad technical role helping people with both digital literacy – helping people use computers and get online – and information literacy – “helping people to understand that not everything they read on Google is true,” Mauger said librarians are well trained in these areas, and work not just in public lending libraries but in universities and schools where teaching people how to evaluate information they find online is increasingly vital, she said. However, in many cases a school librarian is treated as inferior to teachers, despite being just as highly qualified.”
  • Little Free Libraries are taking root on lawns –  USA Today.  ” hundreds of similar Little Free Libraries are popping up on lawns across the country. They’re tiny — no bigger than a dollhouse. Some look like miniature homes or barns. Others just look like a box on a post.”
  • Necessary evil?  Random House triples prices of library e-books – Techcrunch (USA).  “Random House, the world’s largest publisher of the kinds of books you and I read, has made some adjustments to the way it sells e-books to libraries. Notably, they have tripled the price of many titles. Librarians across the country are expressing their discontent.”
  • Top ten public libraries of the new age – Huffingon Post. My Top 10 selection of more recent public libraries here showcases some ideas. For starters, just like most public buildings, the library needs to become as a new hub for social life among the local community. Programatically, this has been reflected in the fact that many have become much less formal, much less guarded and much more inviting. Libraries all around are moving towards a model that encourages readers to stay and linger, instead of their original function as spaces for collecting and lending out books. Reflecting the general trend for libraries to facilitate reading as well as other functions, they are combined with halls and meeting rooms that promote social exchange between users, much like community centers.”  None of the ten are from the UK.
  • Uncorrected transcript of oral evidence – House of Commons.    Full text of second hearing of 21st February including sessions by Annie Mauger (CILIP), Alan Davey (Arts Council England), David Pugh (Leader, Isle of Wight Council), Nigel Thomas (Leicestershire Libraries) and Elizabeth Campbell (Local Government Association).

Changes
 
Peterborough Volunteers used to extend opening hours as pilot project for three months.
Stockton £2.5m new library at Billingham, combined with customer contact centre and possibly NHS.
Worcestershire – Upton library safe for c. three years, previously threatened. 

Local News

  • Birmingham – European librarians visit £189m Library of Birmingham development – Birmingham Post.  “People and politicians are saying: do we need a public library? Everything is digital, everybody has e-books. I don’t agree. I think it is very important to get a balance between the physical library and the digital library.”
  • Brent – Final chance to complain to DCMS Preston Library Campaign.  “The Department of Culture, Media & Sport (DCMS) are legally obliged to investigate or tell us why not, and if they have thousands of complaints, it is much harder for them to ignore us.”
  • Camden – Lib Dems pledge help to libraries in bid to distance themselves from Labour cuts – Ham & High.  “Liberal Democrats have pledged to halt planned cuts to library opening hours and plough extra cash into supporting volunteers to run the much-loved reading rooms, as they laid out alternative budget plans for Camden Council.” … “The Lib Dems praised residents who had stepped up to help run the libraries and pledged an extra £350,000 for Camden’s reading rooms at a full council meeting at the Town Hall on Monday (February 27).”
  • Darlington – Campaign groups thank council for budget u-turns – Advertiser.  “Darlington Borough Council made a number of u-turns on budget proposals due to the strength of public feeling during the budget process. Among the services saved for the town were lollipop patrols outside schools and Cockerton Library, which will now operate with reduced hours.”
  • Edinburgh – Future of library services: letter to Scotland on Sunday – Edinburgh Council.   “It’s ironic that a campaign against library cuts in Scotland is choosing to launch in Edinburgh in a library that will shortly see an increase in its opening hours and in a city where we are building new libraries and refurbishing existing ones.”  Also in newspaper.
  • Gloucestershire – Council attacked over libraries review cash incentives – This is Gloucestershire.   “The Friends of Gloucestershire Libraries (FOGL) launched a scathing attack on the authority after it found out it had been offering £40 supermarket vouchers to attendees at workshops over cuts to its library service.” … Up to £2800 could have been given away.
  • Isle of Wight – Campaigner resigns after libraries row – IWCP.   “Mr Fagan told the County Press he had stepped down from the council committee because he disagreed with Cllr Pugh’s evidence. Mr Fagan said: “The consultation was completely flawed. The questionnaire they put out was so biased.” Cllr Pugh hit back saying a High Court judgement over the closures had backed the council’s position proper consultation had taken place.”
  • Kirklees – Community consultation for Golcar Library – Mailout.  “All expressions of interest will then be considered and more detailed discussions with interested parties will follow.  The proposal is that Kirklees Council will provide guidance to interested community groups and individuals, including training, a regular supply of books, maintenance of public access computers and additional support to ensure the continuation of a high quality library service.”
    • Deadline for libraries – Hudderfield Daily Examiner.   “D-Day for the future of our libraries is looming ever nearer. Now people in Golcar have just six weeks to register an interest in helping to run it.”
  • Nottinghamshire – Mansfield Library sees rise in use since £3.4m revamp – BBC.   “1,381 people had joined since it reopened in January, compared to 497 new members in the same period in 2010. The refit included a new children’s area, more computers, a dedicated space for research and a larger local history section.” … “In 2011 the council reduced the opening hours of some of its smaller libraries and cut its budget for new library books by 36% in two years.”
  • Peterborough – Opening hours pilot to start at library – Evening Telegraph.   “A three-month pilot where a city library’s opening hours will be extended will start on March 19. Vivacity is running the pilot at Bretton Library, in Rightwell, Bretton which will see opening hours on Mondays extended to 6pm from the usual time of 4pm with the use of volunteers working alongside a staff member. If it is a success, it will look to extend the library’s hours on a permanent basis and consider rolling out the changes to other libraries in Peterborough.”
  • Somerset – Council to bring back 160 outsourced staff – BBC.   “Somerset County Council is to bring back 160 staff who were outsourced to the private firm, SouthWest One. The company, which employs 650 ex-council staff, was set up in 2007 and carries out administrative and back office tasks for the local authority. The decision was taken after a council review into the firm’s performance concluded it was failing to perform.”
  • Stockton £2.5m library approved for Billingham – BBC. “Stockton Council has allocated cash for the £2.5m project in Billingham. It said it would be modelled on similar centres in Thornaby and Stockton, which had led to a rise in the number of users. It plans to develop the complex on the former Billingham Art Gallery and council offices site and is looking at either refurbishment or a new building.” Buidling to be combined with customer service centre.”
  • Surrey – Sneak preview of Woking library revamp – Surrey News.  “Surrey County Council is giving Woking library in Gloucester Walk a complete overhaul to make it the most modern and user friendly branch in the county.” … “New features will include an improved children’s library, a new area for teenagers, free wi-fi, new seats, shelves, carpets, lighting and stock. Around 16,000 new books will replace old ones, ensuring a wide variety of fantastic new reads for visitors.”.  127 square metre increase, new cafe.
  • Trafford – Formal response to Trafford council’s consultation – Hands Off Old Trafford Library.   “Today, Friday 2nd March, HOOTLibrary submitted a formal response to the Council’s consultation. You can read the full report here. You can still make your own submissions to the consultation before Monday 5th. Feel free to refer to anything in this document. Indeed we’d actively encourage it!”
  • Wandsworth – Spring at York Gardens LibrarySave York Gardens.   “The librarians and the Friends group have all been busy developing the plans for how we will continue to keep the library running and make sure it is providing really useful services for the local community. In December, the library and community centre’s first Christmas Fayre raised more than £400 which will go towards keeping the library open and continuing to run activities for local people.”
  • Worcestershire – Library will not close: just yet – Malvern Gazette.”However Upton Town councillor Simon Speers told fellow members on Tuesday: “There are no plans to close the library. We do not have that in writing but I have been assured verbally that is the case for a three to five year window.” He added he did have concerns over what he described as “salami slicing” – cutting the service bit-by-bit ahead of a move for closure further down the line.”

“Inspirational Work”

400 libraries (310 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Botella lanza un programa piloto para incuir a voluntarios en las bibliotecas – El Pais (Spain, article in Spanish).  Moves to staff a couple of new buildings with volunteers are proving to be highly controversial.  Although the council states that, without volunteers, the new libraries would not open and that no existing paid staff would be replaced, the policy has, “exploded in their face”.

“Celebrating World Book Day at Eastcote Library in Hillingdon” Ed Vaizey, Twitter.   Friends of Gloucestershire Libraries comments “Mr Vaizey “celebrates World Book Day” yet does nothing when the only source of books and wider reading for many are being closed on his watch.”

“Chewed off lovely Ed Vaizey‘s ear at the @ContempArtSoc fundraiser re not closing libraries. Don’t want to British to become the Illiterati” Kathy Lette, Twitter.

  • Libraries, the community hub and service needs in the online age – Civica.   Report on a roundtable meeting, with – given that the host was Civica – a strong outsourcing bias.
  • Oceanside library outsourcing a no-go – U-T San Diego (USA).   “A proposal in Oceanside to outsource library operations to save money may be finished before it officially began, after a councilman told city administrators last week that he wasn’t interested in the idea.” … ““I don’t know, maybe they [LSSI]can save us $300,000 or $400,000, but the quality that we’ve come to know from the library even with the cuts they’ve taken already, I’m thinking that I’m just not willing to forsake that,” Feller said in an interview. “I’m still for privatization if it can save us significant money. When you’re saving money you’re going to save money by reducing the number of employees.”
  • ¿Se garantiza la Red de Bibliotecas Públicas de Castilla-La Mancha? – Iwetel list-serv (Spain, article in Spanish).  The province of Castilla-La Mancha has modified its public library act so that libraries will not be funded if the state cannot afford them.  It goes on ““the difficult situation we are facing requires to give up everything that is not strictly necessary”
  • Why a library should never close its doors to children – Mummy Rates It.  “I have a bee in my bonnet. I’m not the only one. It’s keeping me awake at night and the closer it gets to ‘decision day’ the more het-up I feel. Our local library is faced with imminent closure and it saddens, infuriates and annoys the hell out of me that the people who are making the decision to close it seem oblivious to the reasons it should stay open.”  Article about decision to close Upper Norwood but it can stand for any library.
  • World Book Day set to give away 14m tokens – Guardian.   “Brand new stories from Neil Gaiman and Anthony Horowitz, the culmination of Gruffalo author Julia Donaldson’s quest to find the UK’s best storyteller and the country’s biggest ever book show will all mark World Book Day tomorrow.”

“Prime minister David Cameron has pledged his support for World Book Day, which he said “plays an important role in helping children to develop a love of reading from an early age, supporting the inspirational work that takes place in schools and libraries up and down the country”. Citing Dr Seuss’s The Lorax as his own favourite children’s book, Cameron said that the books loved by children were “something you treasure for the rest of your life”.”

Local News

Campaigners, including the young authors, interrupted a full council meeting at Croydon Town Hall on Monday February 27. About 70 people packed into the public gallery singing Books Glorious Books to the council before hurling paper aeroplanes over the balcony.”

  • Darlington – Schoolboy’s letter to save library gets PM reply – Northern Echo.  “William Dore, a pupil at Cockerton Primary School, in Darlington, was upset when he heard that councillors were considering closing Cockerton Library, which he visits regularly with his classmates and family, as part of budget cuts.” … PM’s office thanked him for excellent letter and passed on letter to DCMS.  Cockerton has been, at least temporarily, saved from closure. 
  • Milton Keynes – Decisions on traveller’s sites, nurseries and libraries – MK News.   “Assurances have been made by councillor David Hopkins, cabinet member for libraries, that there will be no closures. Famously, residents in Stony Stratford launched a campaign to save the town’s libary after it was earmarked for closure as part of the budget set in 2011, along with Woburn Sands. But a new report detailing how almost £500,000 can be saved without the need for any closures has now been adopted.”
  • North Yorkshire – Village volunteers take over libraries – Telegraph & Argus.  Libraries in Embsay and Gargrave are to be run by volunteers following the approval of North Yorkshire County Council. Both libraries will be formally handed over to the communities on May 1 after the council approved their business plans.”
  • Somerset – Taunton Library re-opening on Mondays – Somerset County Gazette.   “Taunton Library is opening on a Monday next week for the first time in months. Somerset County Council closed it for a day a week as part of its multi-million pound cutbacks last year. But it was forced by a court ruling to reinstate full opening hours in Taunton and other libraries and to abandon plans to close other libraries completely.”

Thousands of pounds owed in fines to libraries: pros and cons of collecting it

Redbridge Council will be temporarily offering a fines amnesty before passing over debt collection to an US company called Unique Management Services.  It’s the third council to pass on its debt list to them this year.  The scale of the problem of the non-collection of late fees and lost books is examined below, taken from this website’s page on saving money without closing libraries.
All library authorities have, theoretically, thousands of pounds owing to them from users due to late fees, lost items or even stolen books.  The scale of these losses  vary.  Reading has 2,400 long overdue books and  Northamptonshire 12,300.  In terms of money owed, it is normally over a hundred thousand pounds: Cumbria £170k, Surrey £700k, York £50k, Leicestershire £238k, Kent £100k, Bracknell £105k, Northern Ireland £160k,Redbridge £167,692Bradford £174k, and Brighton and Hove £175k. Essex retrieved £648k in late fees. Please note, though,  that the wide variety of thse figures indicates differing size of councils and different practice.  Some councils wipe (effectively waiving) records of lost items after x number of years, others use y number of years while others just don’t delete fines, ever.

So, what are the pros and cons of pursuing debt recovery in these financially stringent times?

Pro – (a) Getting all this money back would make a significant impact.  This is taken very seriously in the USA. An American library service uses a collection service that generates $9k per month.

Also, (b) it encourages others to return items on times and thus improve available stock.  It even (c) encourages people to come back to use the library as the fees charges are rarely as high as people fear (although, often, those with non-returned books worry so much about late items they keep them for years, or bin them, rather than owning up to the feared scary librarian who, in reality, would be just happy to see the item back). Finally, (d) breaking the law by stealing books is an offence and offenders should be punished. 

Con – (i) It could cost a fortune to fully recover fines/items because (ii) amounts owed to libraries tend to be quite small but very numerous.  The cost of recovering these debts can be similar to, or exceeding that, of the value of items returned.  Taking legal action against a member of the public for return of items is (iii) rife with danger as it could be seen as a waste of resources being the cost of legal action would almost certainly be more than the value of the items concerned (see this article about Bromley sending a letter asking for some books back from an eight-year old – this article was then taken up by the Telegraph the next day).  Being (iv) too stringent on chasing late items would also deter genuine users from the library service.  Generally, (v) British library services see owed fines as a standard part of the service, impossible to eradicate, that they will likely largely recover over the fullness of time.  Finally, (vi) one could fall foul of the 1964 Public Libraries and Museums Act if one uses fines as a way to make money for the service rather simply as an incentive for returning material on time.  However, considering the recent poor enforcement of this Act, this is likely to be seen as only a minor problem by authorities.

Alternatively, a fines amnesty may be an effective (if counter-intuitive) way of saving money by getting items back that would otherwise stay lost forever.  I’ll close on this article with two statements from people pursuing this line, one in England and one in the USA:

“Assistant mayor Councillor Sarah Russell, who is responsible for libraries in the city, said: “A lot of time people are worried if a book has been damaged, or if they find it under a teenager’s bed when they move out of home – they decide to keep it rather than face the fines. “That’s why we hold amnesties every now and then, because it helps us as well as the library users. “It means we don’t have to spend money replacing missing items and we don’t have to spend energy chasing people up.” Leicestershire.

“You don’t want to penalize people for reading. Sometimes you’re really into a novel and it takes you a little longer to get through it. As it happens, you return a book two or three days late. It’s not a big deal. We can get over that,” Maghnieh said. “It’s a way of really rewarding our patrons for using the library.” Windsor Public Library, USA.

News

  • European librarians visit Birmingham’s £189m facility – BBC.  More than 250 senior librarians from Europe are gathering in Birmingham to discuss the future of library services. As well as meeting at the Town Hall, visitors will see progress on the £189m library being built in Centenary Square. The 10-storey development, which will have an outdoor amphitheatre, is due to open next year. The site will also include a theatre, recording studio and free access to the National Film Archive.”
  • Seven library services you might not know about – Matador life (USA).   Includes job hunting, finding a date, live music, storytelling, author feedback, legal advice, home energy audits.

Changes

Local News

“I know that some of the facts given in evidence, in oral form, were incorrect”. Keith says his resignation isn’t the end of this, “I don’t just want to resign and disappear in to the ether, I need to take this up.”

  • North Yorkshire – Milestone as libraries handed over to communities – Yorkshire Post.   “Councillors rubber-stamped final plans for the scheme this week, with the go-ahead being given for six community-run libraries in Ayton, Barlby, Bilton, Embsay, Gargrave, and Great Ayton, after volunteer groups presented detailed business plans demonstrating the feasibility of the scheme. However, Humnanby Library failed to produce a viable plan and the county council revealed the village, near Scarborough, which is one of the largest in England, would be served by a mobile library from April, although other options are currently being explored.”
    • “People power” helps ot keep village library open – Press.  “The final details of plans for the future of six libraries have now been approved. It means the library in Barlby will be run by the local parish council. It will be staffed by volunteers and will incorporate a meeting place, information and exhibition space and a parish office.”
  • Redbridge – Borough offers library fine amnesty – Guardian series.   “The borough’s libraries are owed a whopping £167,692 in fines. The figure was revealed on the day that an amnesty was announced in an attempt to persuade people to return some of the 27,846 books, DVDs and CDs which are currently overdue.”
  • Richmond – Library services in Richmond get £20kGuardian series.   “Library services have got a £20,000 boost thanks to Arts Council England. Richmond Council will use the money to take the lead on a partnership project with library and arts services in Kingston, Merton and Wandsworth. Richmond’s arts and library services will use funding to improve the quality and delivery of arts for adults and children with disabilities.”
  • Surrey – An appeal on behalf of libraries and librarians – SLAM.   “…we are now making this unashamed appeal for you to contribute to the “fighting fund”. We believe libraries and librarians are worth fighting for and have been working extremely hard to protect them and improve them. But we do need your help. It is wonderful and encouraging to have such high profile celebrity supporters such as Stephen Fry, Brian Blessed and Sue Perkins, but as you can see from our fundraising thermometer on the right of this page, we still need everybody’s help, including you!”
  • Swansea – Website winners put library top – This is South Wales.   “Clever use of websites like Facebook, Twitter and YouTube means Swansea Library Service has been named the best of its kind in Wales. Swansea Council’s Library Service came first in the social media category of the Welsh Libraries Marketing Innovation Awards 2012.”

Kent charging for children’s library cards

Comment

Kent, fresh from ending their school library service, have decided to (sort of) charge schools for joining up schoolchildren into the Library.  Amongst a whole package of glitzy sounding proposals (Ooh! Core Package Platinum!) there’s this…
Yes, indeed, Kent will charge schools for the privilege of getting their kids to join the library.  

It’s not illegal. They’re entitled to do it. They may feel under such gigantic pressure that they have to do it. This is a council that last year considered closing an awful lot of of their branches. It’s, after all, a great service to visit the school and get it all done. It’s also, of course, the start of a slippery slide into unequal services and the end of a free public library service. Expect more of these money-making ideas from councils around the country. Unless the Secretary of State starts making difficult decisions himself, rather than doing nothing at all.


400 libraries (310 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

National: Lobby your MP to help public libraries, 13th March. Website: http://www.speakupforlibraries.org/ 
Twitter: https://twitter.com/#!/speakup4libs, #librarieslobby, twibbon.
LinkedIn: http://linkd.in/z8U3mM 
 
News

Dan Jarvis (Barnsley Central, Labour)

To ask the Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport whether his Department plans to bring forward legislative proposals to amend or annul the Libraries Act 1964; if so, when; and if he will make a statement.

Edward Vaizey (Parliamentary Under Secretary of State (Culture, Communications and Creative Industries), Business, Innovation and Skills; Wantage, Conservative)

This Department has no plans at present to amend or annul the Libraries and Museums Act 1964. 

Hansard via They Work For You.
  •  Harry Potter ebooks to be distributed to public and school libraries through Overdrive – Marketwire.  ” Pottermore, the online experience and home of the Harry Potter eBooks created by J.K. Rowling and partnered by Sony, announced today it has entered into an exclusive worldwide eBook and digital audiobook distribution agreement with OverDrive for public and school libraries.”
  • Libraries segment – Live with Gabby, Channel Five, 41:30 to 50.  Concentrates on Kensal Rise library, [including a cameo from myself at the beginning, so best to skip to 42:50 at the start – Ed.], with interview by Margaret Bailey and with local library users, including a “pop-up” library. Authort Kathy Lette says  “Britain is famous for its’s writers and to cut off that lifeline … it makes you stupid if you can’t read”.  Gabby Roslin
  • Saving our Libraries – Big Issue.  Lauren Smith writes in the “Our Issues” column on the threats facing libraries and why campaigning is so important.

Local News

“Originally homework centres in libraries were set up with time-limited funding from the National Lottery. When this funding ended, the majority of such arrangements across the county had to be discontinued. We were able to avoid this in Harlow and in Greenstead by means of a one year grant from the Essex County Council study support budget. Unfortunately, this too will no longer be available after March.”

  • Gloucestershire – Multi-million pound businesses Tesco and Sainsbury to benefit from brutal library cuts … at our expense – FoGL.  “It has been brought to our attention that Gloucestershire County Council are running “library workshops”as part of the libraries consultation and are paying attendees £40 each in shopping vouchers to be spent at Tesco and Sainsbury as detailed in this invite Invite – workshops BME (this was sent to us by a FoGL member, we have not been notified by GCC, nor have we been asked to circulate the invite. We have no idea who this invite has been sent to). The invite states that the library review is happening due to “limited resources”. We are disgusted that Gloucestershire County Council sees fit to place tax-payers money into the pockets of retail giants like Tesco and Sainsbury when they claim they do not have the money to run basic public services?”
    • County Council approves £29 million cuts package – Stroud News & Journal.   “Proposals to invest £1 million to help keep the county’s libraries open over the next two years were rejected as Gloucestershire County Council approved cuts totalling £29 million last week.” … “The opposition group wanted to use money from the authority’s £106 million reserves to fund a further £2.2 million worth of road repairs, a £3 million investment in infrastructure, a £1 million contribution to assist the county’s libraries and a £600,000 spend on youth work.”
  • Harrow – Children win a librarian for a day – Harrow Times.   “Three schools in Harrow won a librarian for a day, in celebration of World Book Day.  Pupils at St Bernadettes, in Clifton Road; Longfield, in Dukes Avenue, and Stag Lane, in Collier Drive, won the librarians after they entered an open competition run by Harrow’s library service.”
  • Isle of Man – Save our libraries: petition launched – Isle of Man Today.  “Two have launched a petition against the closure of the Department of Education and Children’s family and mobile libraries. In just two days Michael Synnott, aged 11, and his classmate Robert Moore, collected about 50 signatures.” 
  • Kent – Edukent Packaged Services – Kent Council.   Charges for school staff to use public libraries after the recent withdrawal of the school library service there.

“A visit to the library and a session with library staff to set up individual library tickets for children and regular book exchange visits to library. The school will manage future sessions”

  • Somerset – Councillors reject library safeguards – This is Somerset.   “Somerset Liberal Democrats hoped to persuade Somerset County Council to agree that no library should have funding withdrawn without a consultation based on residents’ needs. They also sought to promote libraries as “community hubs” and “public space.””
  • Wiltshire – “Yes” to council budget, “no” to free car parking plan – Wiltshire Times.  “On libraries, Jane Scott says: “Unlike other local authorities we have opened a new library in Pewsey [where they sacked the manager on the same day it opened – Ed.] and work on our new Trowbridge library is well under way. We have kept all of our libraries open withthe help of over 600 volunteers.”
  • Wokingham – Private library firms shortlisted – BBC.   “The Conservative-led council currently pays out about £2.1m a year to run its library service but said it believed it could pay firms less to take them on. However, a report to councillors said there could be an “increase in staff turnover” and “loss of influence” over the service.”

The Last Ten Years. Good and bad in libraryland.

It’s often difficult to find simple and straightforward figures for national library usage, especially those over any length of time.  The following will, I hope, therefore be of use for those interested in the subject.
They show good news and bad news.  For the doomsayers, we can see that overall visits and adult borrowing has indeed declined, although perhaps not at the catastrophic pace that some seem to believe.  This decline is mirrored in the reduction of the number of libraries and mobiles available and in the number of books available for lending.  
For good news, we can see that child usage has stayed the same and has indeed slightly increased recently.  A strange trend for a supposedly outmoded service.

Tim Coates, who kindly provided these charts, argued in a final slide that the points to be made were (a) “The library service has been well resourced with both capital and revenue”, (b) “Book collections have been neglected and as a result the use of books have fallen and (c) the rise of council overheads have stifled improvement”.   A video presentation by him analysing Somerset’s expenditure is also available. However, one should say that Tim’s views are not one uniformly shared, especially by librarians.  For my part, I don’t know enough to make a firm stand either way, although I would agree with Tim that an easy correlation can be made between bookfund and the resultant book borrowing.

There is something, though, that most would agree on.  We should expect the revenue and capital to fall off a cliff in 2011/12 and into 2012/13.  Whether there will be a corresponding decrease in usage will be the key to the survival of public libraries, at least at the local branch level.  A steep decline would set off a vicious circle where the decline in revenue leads to a decline in usage leading to a further decline in revenue.  This is what many fear.  It’s up to us all to make sure that it does not happen.

I have amended this commentary due to feedback kindly received.  And added paragraph (29/2/12) is in italics.

Number of libraries was already accelerating downwards
before 2011.
Spending on new library buildings and refurbishments
increased greatly.
Staff costs have largely stayed the same
Available books dipped significantly from 2001 (c. 68m)
 to 2007 (c/ 59m) then levelled of to some extent.
Budgets rose 2001 to 2006 then levelled off, with a decline
starting in 2010/11
However, the amount that Councils took from these budgets
 started shooting  up from 2005 from around 10% then to
 14% in 2010/11, presumably making the recent overall
 decline in libraries budget more noticeable.
Child usage has levelled/slightly risen.
Adult borrowing’s decline slowed by 2006/7, with
decline starting again in 2010/11
Visits increased to 2004/5 but have declined since.

From CIPFA data, charts kindly supplied by Tim Coates

The bridge to reading is having its foundations removed

400 libraries (310 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Engineers crashing our gates – Nicolas Morin (USA).  Librarian written blog article: “We’re the nice guys, the not-for-profits, we’re working for the common good, we’re small, we’re poor… but we nevertheless are members of the incumbent class. It’s uncomfortable, since we mostly think of incumbents as people of power who want to preserve the status quo in their favor, but that’s the way it is: we’re incumbents with little power.”.  Not the easiest read or especially relevant to library cuts now but it does point to possible future paths.
  • Lauren Smith to step down as CILIP Vice President – CILIP.  “Lauren Smith has announced her decision to step down from her role as Vice President of CILIP.  Lauren said that she did not take the decision lightly but wanted to focus her time and energies more on active campaigning than she feels is currently possible within the scope of the Vice President role.”
  • Nearly half our kids don’t have anyone to read to them – Mirror.  “The Mirror’s Get Britain Reading campaign aims to encourage viewers to pledge 10 minutes of their time to read every day. Daybreak is to launch a similar reading campaign this week.”

“So what is missing? What is the bridge, the conduit, the middle cog between those children whose parents don’t foster a habit of reading and the necessities of a print-rich world? It is the librarian and the teacher. Thank goodness, I don’t (yet) have to defend the role of the teacher. But why, in the name of all that is coherent and sensible, do I have to defend the role of the professional children’s librarian? Why, in county after county, are they being made redundant? Why, up and down the country have talented children’s reading ambassadors become an endangered species? Why are schools dispensing with their services or failing to sign up to School Library Services?” Alan Gibbons

Changes

Gateshead – £305k cut, some staffing cuts, possibility of volunteers replacing staff in some branches. 
Kent – Sturry Library temporarily closed due to arson attack

Local News

  • Doncaster – We need your help: Legal Aid to match – Save Doncaster Libraries.  Efforts to match the Legal Aid funding awarded to our brave resident heading our fight for justice through the Courts, have begun. A hardy group of campaigners stood outside Doncasters’ fantastic Markets to inform and enable people to drop cash in buckets.  We are also commencing targeted requesting, and facebook/twitter campaigning. We need to raise a significant amount in a very short time, £15,000 (+VAT).” [Plus VAT? Not only are the Government forcing people to fight their battles for them but they’re also taxing them for the privilege of doing so – Ed.].  
  • East Sussex – How do you rate library services? – Eastbourne Herald.  “The county council library and information service is looking at how it provides rural and mobile library services – including its libraries in the Eastbourne area. The council wants to ensure it is giving residents the best service at the best price – and in the right place at the right time. The review runs for 12 weeks from Monday, February 27 to Monday, May 21, and people can complete a survey in paper copy or online at www.eastsussex.gov.uk/haveyoursay.”
  • Gateshead – Hundreds of jobs under threat at Gateshead Council – Chronicle.  “Some £305,000 will go from libraries and arts services, with staffing reductions likely and talk of voluntary groups helping keep some branches open.”
  • Greenwich – Conflict of interest allegation halts Greenwich libraries transferThis is Local London.   “Greenwich Council has announced it will reconsider decisions on leisure and library services at a future cabinet meeting “to avoid any perception of a conflict of interest in the council’s decision making process.” Unite branch secretary Onay Kasab described the surprise move as a “temporary victory”.”
  • Kent – Sturry library shut after suspected arson attack – Kent Online.   “A library has been damaged in a suspected arson attack after a bin was pushed up against the building and set alight. Three fire crews were called to Sturry library, near Canterbury, at about 8.30pm on Sunday. They managed to stop the blaze spreading, but some of the roof and internal areas – including books – were damaged.”
  • Warwickshire – Warwick Library reopens after move to save money – BBC.   “Warwickshire County Council said the move from Barrack Street to Shire Hall was part of plans to save £2m from its £7.4m Library and Information Service budget.”