Archive for June, 2011
Glos Council blame campaigners for noticing their possibly unlawful decision to cut libraries
Jun 18th
Two very interesting articles today from unexpected sources. Firstly, the Express reports on the possibilities of privatised libraries under a heading that fears a new “barbarism”. Interestingly, the private library company in question is apparently based above a lettings agency and is registered to a semi-detached house in Liverpool. Secondly, the Trading Director of Oxfam, no less, attacks the idea of volunteer-run libraries insisting that they should be well-financed and staffed by at least of core of paid workers (Politics Show South England 41:00 to 50). If this keeps up, I am expecting a statement by Ed Vaizey announcing he is taking his responsibilties as seriously as he wanted his predecessor to and will be intervening in several library-cutting authorities by the end of the week. Well, I’m a dad and it is Father’s Day… (S)
393 libraries (319 buildings and 74 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK (for the complete list by area see the page “Tally by local authority”). Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries). The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.
(S) marks updates added on Sunday.
News
As US firm seeks to run beloved institutions, are we at risk of “barbarism”? – Express. LSSI’s interest in UK libraries is noted, as is it’s current tiny presence in the UK (apparently it’s office is above a shop). While fears about it are noted, some campaigners argue it could keep open some libraries under threat. (S)
At least ten arrested in Friday afternoon library cut protest in Oakland – Contra Costa Times (USA). “The demonstration opposed Oakland library cuts and other austerity measures and began around 4 p.m. It was uneventful at first, but when the protesters moved to the street, blocking traffic, and refused police orders to disperse, at least 10 were arrested on suspicion of offenses ranging from failure to disperse to battery on a police officer.”
Localism Bill – House of Lords. Attempt by three peers to exclude the Libraries Act from the Bill.
Running to spread word on literacy – Northern Echo. “For the past four years, thousands of youngsters in Darlington have been rewarded by Miss Youldon’s enthusiasm through her role as Bookstart co-ordinator and community engagement officer for children aged up to seven at the town’s Crown Street library.” “There has been lots in the press about libraries. I thought it was interesting that we are looking at closing libraries in our country, when in the Third World they want to set up libraries.”
This week in libraries – TWIL (a half-hour TV show on libraries no less, based in the Netherlands but in English). Interview with Justin Hoenke (Teen Librarian, Portland, USA).
Volunteer use “not right approach” to spending cuts” – BBC. Trading Director of Oxfam says depending on volunteers alone ro run libraries is wrong. Rather, any volunteers should be additional and complementary to a well-funded library service with a paid staff. (S)
West London councils combine library forces – Londonist. “Westminster, Hammersmith & Fulham and Kensington and Chelsea councils have announced plans to combine library services, in a move they say will secure the future of all libraries in the area and one that will presumably send Eric Pickles into paroxysms of joy.” Article worries that the councils in question will be closing libraries despite combining services (S)
Changes to services
Cheshire West and Chester – Libraries may move to becoming a community interest company, charitable trust or other charitable organisation.
Local News
Camden – Gran outraged at anti-Semitc book found in at Kilburn Library – London24. ‘Are Jews Responsible for 9/11’ book on shelves. “As a Jew I found it exceptionally offensive, but in this instance the complaint by Gillian actually changed Camden policy. Senior librarians will monitor book orders very closely.”(S)
Cheshire West and Chester – Union fears over plan to outsource more services – Chester Chronicle. UNISON: “From our point of view it means dealing with another employer who might seek to change our members terms and conditions or, as with Connexions, they might turn around and say we have not got the money to do things so we will have to make cuts.”
Croydon – Libraries under threat of LSSI takeover – Sanderstead Library Campaign. Regarding Express article “Learning of dealings with LSSI being made so swiftly will only serve to raise residents’ suspicion and concerns in Croydon.” (S)
Ealing – Hanwell, Northfields, Northolt and Perivale library buildings “stay open” – BBC. Decision on 5th July. “Ms Brown said she suspected the mobile service had received little support during a recent consultation because it was mostly web-based and so was not completed by many elderly people.”
Gloucestershire – High Court injunction on library closure plans – This is Glos. Cllr Mark Hawthorne blames campaigners for the cost of questioning the legality of his plans to withdraw funding for 10 libraries.
Gloucestershire – Mark Hawthorne costing taxpayers thousands – Thoughts of a [wannabe] librarian. “arguably the most incompetent council leader in the country”, “Yes, it is costly and frustrating for taxpayers Mark. Which begs the question, why did your council embark on a disgraceful consultation that took little noticed of the needs and requirements of the local community?”
Hackney – Support our libraries, stop these unnecessary cuts – Hackney Unison. Members to strike over reduction in numbers (25% of staff to be lost), cuts in wages (£2000 plus), loss of paid breaks. Investment could save money eg. stop the theft of DVDs.
Hampshire – New county library service set to start – News. 1200 stops cut to 365 stops, which be withdrawn if there are fewer people than 10 per stop in one year.
Isle of Wight – Library protesters at ministry – IWCP. “accused the Isle of Wight Council of failing to consult properly, unfairly discounting a 9,000-name petition and encouraging parish and town councils to break double taxation rules over library funding.”
North Yorkshire – Libraries saved as vans face axe – Ripon Gazette.
Suffolk – Not for profit company may help run libraries – Bury Free Press. “The main proposal we’ll be putting to cabinet in July is to have a social enterprise, an arms length, not for profit company. We feel that’s the best vehicle to assist people to take forward their ideas – and there are some great ideas.”
Waltham Forest – Library closure consultation begins – This is Local London. “The authority says that the proposal to shut the South Chingford branch in Hall Lane and Harrow Green library in Leytonstone is the most efficient way of cutting £1million from the service’s annual budget.” Consultation until 9 September.
Wokingham – Library outrage sparks petition – Reading Chronicle. Protester says “I am appalled by the thought of companies making a profit out of libraries. Libraries should be for the benefit of residents, not city sharks.”. Council responds “This plan means we will be able to save money and give a better service, so I do not know what the petition is campaigning to save the libraries from. We are still providing the service that the residents want, but it is nonsense to think that all of the services have to be run directly by the council at Shute End.”(S)
Court orders temporary freeze on library closures and cuts in Gloucestershire
Jun 17th
“The High Court has stopped Gloucestershire County Council’s library cuts in their tracks today. It cannot proceed with closures, and must continue to fund libraries, until the legality of these cuts has been properly decided by the Court.” Phil Shiner, Public Interest Lawyers, High Court issues injunction against closures – FoGL.
Libraries: a little bit like supermarkets really – Thoughts of a [wannabe] librarian.
Libraries vs Banks: the Old World is in our way – Really Open University. “There is something old-fashioned about the library. It is a remnant from a time when the economy could support a few pockets of sharing. Neither capital nor its robber barons can afford such old-fashioned nonsense now. There is no going back. But there is something about a library that is also an image from the future, when the community, the city, the world is a collective enterprise…”
“Nothing arouses people’s emotions like libraries because they are a source of enormous knowledge and closing them is a death knell to peoples’ prospects of educating themselves. “I have known many people whose lives have been completely transformed by libraries. Browsing libraries with their experienced staff is how many people develop their curiosity and imagination.” Brent – Author Deborah Moggach joins campaign to save Brent’s libraries – Save Kensal Rise Library.
Wokingham may n.o.t. privatise libraries
Jun 16th
“What we have agreed is to use a European process called “Competitive Dialogue”. What this is is to ask interested parties to suggest ways of improving our library service within a given framework (including libraries cannot close). At the end of the response period the replies will be analysed and used to produce 2 key documents 1) Requirements Specification and 2) Business Case. Those documents will be reviewed and if not acceptable by the Executive then nothing will change. If they are then, and only then, will the normal tendering process start with a view to outsourcing the operation only (i.e. all assets will be retained by the Council).” (Cllr Keith Baker, Wokingham Council)
I take from this that, of course, it may be privatised but the deal is not yet done and other alternatives are still on the table.
393 libraries (319 buildings and 74 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK (for the complete list by area see the page “Tally by local authority”). Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries). The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.
News
Age of uncertainty – Independent. “Later learning enriches the lives of thousands of elderly people. But widespread library closures could spell an end to many of these study groups”. The U3A “requires nothing from the public sector except a level of infrastructure, and in particular, good public libraries everywhere. Taking that away is appallingly short-sighted and, even in economic terms, it will cost more in the long term.”
Free libraries from government – Orange County Register (USA). Pro-privatisation piece following on from California bill making it harder to privatise libraries “This also is just more state meddling in local matters. AB438 also is part of the ongoing effort of the Democratic majority to protect government union jobs from being privatized – even at the expense of strained local budgets.”
The #savelibraries chat I had with Ed Vaizey at the Children’s Laureate announcement – @MarDixon. ” Well actually I just blocked the door but it worked. I asked him why he didn’t ever tweet me back. He knew then who I was because at first he got defensive(ish) and asked if I have read his report.”
Three London Tory councils say libraries will not close – BBC. “27.5 full-time jobs cut from a workforce of 259, with annual savings of £1m”.
Use every trick in the book to save at your local library – Independent (Eire). “The number of visits increased by 13% between 2007 and 2009, and statistics from individual library services suggest that this increase has been maintained. The number of books being borrowed has also increased,”
Changes
Pembrokeshire – CDs withdrawn.
Warrington – Photocopiers withdrawn in all libraries except Central.
Local News
Camden – Future of libraries under question – Highgate People. “The survey found that many residents use more than one library across Camden and do not feel tied to a local library. People under 45 were more likely to prefer fewer libraries across the borough offering better services, with older residents feeling that a local library service is important. Overall, 57% of people who responded to the survey would prefer to keep all 13 of Camden’s libraries open with reduced opening hours.”
Camden – Hand-over could be shelved: four Tory councillors force “call-in” of strategy – Camden New Journal. ““There is a little hope the call-in will allow Camden to reconsider its decision. All things are possible but Camden does not appear minded to be sensible. Councillors have not thought things through.”
Gloucestershire – Enjoy pampering to support library – This is Glos. “”It’s just turned out to be a good way of raising money, which we will need when we take on the running of the library.”
Isle of Wight – Library supporters ask council decision to be reviewed by Ethics Committee – Friends of the IW Library Service. “At last nights full council meeting, the ruling Tory group, following their usual non-democratic procedures refused to allow Cllr Jonathan Bacon (Ind) to ask a question about libraries. In view of this and several other matters we are asking the Ethical Standards Committee to investigate the IW Council. Rather than just one or two of us signing the letter we are seeking signatures from Islanders in the form of a petition
North Yorkshire – County Council backs fair solution to libraries’ future – North Yorks Council. Examples of successful community libraries include “a pub in Hudswell”.
North Yorkshire – Mobile library stops at budget “crossroads” – Whitby Gazette. “We are being told that they are going to make everyone redundant and get volunteers to staff it, but that’s totally wrong.”
North Yorkshire – More time for libraries plan to be finalised – Scarborough Evening News.
Suffolk – Campaigners fight on against divestment – Tendance Coatesy. Council still cutting budget, seeking other organisations to run libraries, wishing to avoid running libraries directly.
Surrey – Save Surrey Libraries – Save our services in Surrey. “This is only the beginning – if these closures go ahead without serious public and staff opposition then there will be a Phase 2 and Phase 3 until no more libraries are run directly by the public sector.”
Warrington – Photocopiers axed in libraries – This is Cheshire. Photocopiers no longer profitable. “Visitors can use scanners on computers to make any copies of documents in the future”
Warwickshire – Residents plan to run library – Rugby and Lutterworth Observer. Robin Aird, chairman of Dunchurch Parish Council, said: “There has been a lot of support from the community. We had a very good turn out for the meetings held in the village and we received over 1,400 signatures on the petition. We are very hopeful that the county council will support our plan.”
Warwickshire – We need our books, say Whitnash library users – Courier. “We all know that cuts have to be made and the money has to come from somewhere, but over a quarter of a million pounds was spent refurbishing this building just a couple of years ago. Fifteen hours a week amounts to semi-closure. Where’s the economic sense in that?”
West Sussex – Big changes afoot for Horsham district’s libraries – West Sussex County Times. “Libraries are one of the most wonderful things local government has done for 100 years, and they should not be put at risk.” – looking at co-location, increasing income.
Worcestershire – Council libraries close? – Evesham Journal. “concerns about potential library closures has prompted people to flock to the buildings.” 4 libraries may go. Kathy Kirk of the council said: “It’s great to see so many people taking an interest.”
#whywedontneedibraries
Jun 15th
- I believe everything Fox News tells me
- Because kids with nowhere to go should be hanging around on the corner, not reading and learning stuff like real kids
- Because we can take comfort in the certainty that if it’s not on Google, it doesn’t exist and/or never happened.
- Parents always know exactly what their children should be reading
- Whenever people want to know something, they automatically know where to start and what to look for
- Everyone can access the internet any time they want, everyone can afford all the books they will ever want
- Because taxpayers aren’t entitled to anything they can actually use
- Because if you want to read a magazine or scholarly journal you should be forced to subscribe
- Everyone has someone in their lives who will doggedly hunt down information for them.
- Because boring summers without free books, prizes and activities for kids and teens are awesome
- Because only rich people deserve to read books
- Because there are so many places in the world labelled “quiet study area”
- Because kids who see people enjoying books and reading will get the idea that’s okay and not watch enough tv
- Parents know how and where to find books in braille
- Teachers are the only educators the world needs
![]() |
Threatened libraries figure has gone down to below 400
Jun 14th
The news from North Yorkshire is that “only” 18 libraries (including mobiles) will close or move out of council control rather than the 34 originally threatened. There’s been a lot of these reprieves on recently. So much so in fact that the tally of library threatened with closures has dipped by over a hundred. Great news. However, actual budgets haven’t been restored. We could be looking at a situation like that reported yesterday in the Wirral where the libraries are open but there’s no-one home. It’s worth remembering that the Women’s Institute voted to campaign to “maintain” library services, not merely to keep them open.
393 libraries (319 buildings and 74 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK (for the complete list by area see the page “Tally by local authority”). Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries). The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.
News
Common Knowledge – Voices for the Library (Sibyl Ruth). “Knowledge could be King. Libraries should be places where information is for sharing. Only I keep thinking about those metal barriers. The ‘Keep Out’ signs. Maybe our civic leaders are in the know. We are being kept in the dark…”
Ed Vaizey: You can run but you can’t hide (from the Women’s Institute) – False Economy. Lauren Smith summaries the situation, False Economy adopts the library closures map.
Methods of demonstrating the value of libraries – Library of Digress. Excellent (but academic) literature review on how one can place a value on the invaluable.
Northern leaders call for a culture of collaboration and dialogue – Guardian (Public Leaders Network). Wakefield – “Wakefield is shaping up to meet tough financial challenges by exploring innovative ways of providing public services. It is aiming to becoming a “catalyst council” – keeping the responsibility for providing services, such as libraries, but not necessarily directly delivering all those services itself. Delivery would be left to social enterprises, co-operatives, community groups, local businesses, public sector partners, joint ventures with private sector partners and other models.”
Pete Andre and Boris Johnson launch children’s literacy project – London 24. “The Mayor of London and the Mysterious Girl singer took turns at Botwell Green Library in Hayes, west London to read passages from Julia Donaldson’s The Gruffalo to a group of children.”… “The National Literacy Trust’s work has demonstrated that friends, neighbours and other community members can help parents support the literacy of their children. This is particularly important for parents with low literacy who may be less confident using services such as libraries and children’s centre”
Read-in Roundup – Screwy Decimal. Campaigning in the USA.
Shared service push saves libraries – Local Government Chronicle. Hammersmith & Fulham / Kensington & Chelsea / Westminster merging library services to save £1m per year, “Council leaders will vote on the plans on 20 June and say they will enable the councils to keep 21 libraries open at a time when authorities are closing substantial numbers of libraries.”
Changes to library services
Birmingham – £200k off £1.3m bookfund, some cuts in opening hours, reduction in library staff and bookstock.
North Yorkshire – 10 out of 11 mobiles to close, 8 libraries under threat – Barlby, Bilton, East Ayton, Embsay, Gargrave, Great Ayton, Hunmanby and Masham (may turn to volunteer-run), 16 reprieved. £1.7m cut.
Wakefield – Libraries likely to be run by private company/volunteers/others.
Local Library News
Brent – Library campaigners raise cash for legal battle – Harrow Observer. “At a comedy night in Kilburn on Friday (June 10), called Stand Up For Libraries, £700 was raised for the campaign to save six of the borough’s reading rooms. While at Queen’s Park Book Festival on Sunday (June 12), £800 was taken in donations.” £7000 of £30000 needed for legal challenge now raised.
Dorset – Ten could be spared from closure – Dorset Echo. Also reported in Daily Echo as New proposals could save 10 of Dorset’s threatened libraries.
Lewisham – Library campaigners hailed as Our Heroes – Guardian series. “Married couple Peter and Pat Richardson have worked tirelessly to try to block Lewisham council’s closure of five libraries.”
Lewisham – Public meeting at Sydenham Library – Friends of Sydenham Library. “Darren Taylor of Eco-Computer Systems invites all those interested in the future of Sydenham Library to a Public Meeting on Thursday 29 June. He is happy to share his future plans for the library and answer any questions the local community may have.”
North Yorkshire – Cuts see North Yorkshire mobile library service to end – BBC. Summary of revised cuts. “The challenge is to keep our libraries open in a way that is sustainable so that they can grow and develop to meet future needs.”
North Yorkshire – Library closures on BBC Radio. 1:36:12 to 1:43:40 – 8 libraries still under threat but 16 reprieved, some may be taken over by volunteers. “it’s a vast improvement… but it’s not perfect”. Councillor interviewed is keen on libraries being run in pubs. Mobiles “have reached the end of their shelflife” (£8 cost per book issued). “The important thing is to make your voice heard”. “The status quo is no longer an option”.
Oxfordshire – Rural communities suffer the most – Witney Gazette. “City libraries are reprieved, while rural libraries must move to being run by volunteers, although I cannot see how our very popular, small, part-time library in Charlbury, which is excellently run by our one librarian, can be effectively organised by volunteers without the help of a librarian. And there is not room to serve coffee.”
Suffolk – Plans to offload libraries are confusing and uncertain, meeting is told – Lowestoft Journal 24. Council aiming to put libraries into a Community Interest Company. Uncertainty in last six months has led staff to break down in tears.
Suffolk – Campaigners united to form “Save Suffolk Libraries Campaign Network” – Save Suffolk Libraries.
Suffolk – Library campaigners to put their views to County scrutiny commitee – EADT. “It must be ensured that they are given all the information possible to ensure that they can make an informed decision. As it stands, we do not believe they have that level of information for various aspects of the consultation.”
Waltham Forest – Live: library closures meeting – Guardian. Report live on key meeting to decide if to close two libraries. Cabinet agrees to library closure consultation – up to 200 union members protest outside meeting,
Warwickshire – Libraries attract community groups – BBC. 16 groups have expressed an interest in running the 16 libraries under threat.
Warwickshire – 16 libraries under threat – BBC Midlands Today. Piece on the closures, councillor says communities should run libraries causing report to say “when is a closure not a closure?”, local campaigner says libraries are an “essential member of the community”, Lauren Smith from Voices for the Library defends libraries from closure. Lauren Smith has done a blog post on her experience.
West Sussex – Most villages in Midhurst and Petworth area escape mobile library cuts – Midhurst and Petworth Observer.
Dorset halves number of libraries under threat, but £800k cut still in place
Jun 13th
News
Comment: suicides, literacy and space hoppers – Politics.co.uk. “The truth is that people are not marching through country towns or forming a human chain around a library just to feel good about themselves” [NB this article is written by me]
For the love of libraries: Faye Clowe on the value of public libraries – Read, Write, Repeat USA). “Yes, I believe in public libraries. They were a haven for me as a child. They are a free resource every day for countless people. They nurture reading. They are a fundamental ingredient of this democracy.”
Public Libraries: Where life begins again and friends live forever – JJ Brown, Author (USA). “Fiction, non-fiction, poetry, new friends, old friends and friends that live forever–a great thing about the public library is here you can find them all. And no matter where you find yourself on the curve of normalcy or abnormality, wealth or poverty, a friend is a good thing to have. Even if it’s for a week or two and then you have to take him back to his place on the shelf at the public library.”
Pubs “a good option for libraries” – Morning Advertiser. “We are very pro-pubs on the grounds that they are the last remaining public facility in villages and suburban areas — a place where people can consume alcohol in a controlled and supervised environment.” says chief of Hertfordshire.
Change to Library Services
Dorset – 10 reprieved, 10 still under threat (Burton, Bradstock, Charminster, Chickerell, Colehill, Corfe Castle, Portland Underhill, Puddletown, Stalbridge, West Moors, Wool), 10 reprieved (Beaminster, Corfe Mullen, Crossways, Littlemoor, Lyme Regis, Lytchett Matravers, Portland Tophill, Sturminster Newton, Upton, Wyke Regis). £800k cuts still need to be made.
Hackney – Events to reduce from 500 annually to 200, mainly run by volunteers. Most staff will be paid £2000-5000 less as jobs downgraded.
Hertfordshire – Central Resources Library to move to WGC Library, some stock put in warehouse rather than in open shelves.
Northamptonshire – May move to a trust model. Aim to increase income and lower costs in order to reduce council contribution by up to 50%.
Wirral – Some under threat. Job losses has meant libraries are now “empty shells”.
Worcestershire – £1.8m (28% cut) over four years.
Local News
Croydon – How Croydon Council tries to hide a consultation (Part 94) – Inside Croydon.
Dorset – Councillors throw Dorset’s threatened libraries a lifeline – Ad Lib. All councillors on Policy Development Panel want all libraries to be saved, library management want to close ten as otherwise service would be unsustainable given £800k budget cuts. Decision on 20th May.
Gloucestershire – Concerns over privacy and date protection in the new library structure – FoGL. Date Protection Act not yet sorted out – volunteers will have access to library management system and will be able to see people’s contact details and what they’re reading, presumably even in normally run libraries.
Hackney – Defend Hackney’s libraries! Support Hackney’s library workers! – Hackney alliance to defend public services. “There will also be reduction of opening hours in all but the 3 main Hackney Libraries. Many of us fear that this concentration of resources, staff and events in the 3 main libraries, will result in less people using the other libraries and that the resulting drop in footfall could be used to justify closing libraries in the future.”
Hertfordshire – Plans to move Hatfield library services into warehouse – Times 24. Services to be split three ways, including one in a warehouse, as land needed for an incinerator. “By making these changes we will be able to preserve the library services currently provided by the Central Resources Library, but at a reduced cost to taxpayers.”
Monmouthshire – Libraries get the thumbs up from users – FreePress. “Two recent surveys have given the thumbs up to Monmouthshire’s libraries with 94 per cent of adults considering their local library to be very good or good, and nine out of ten children and young people awarding the service the highest possible rating.”
Northamptonshire – Donations could save libraries – BBC. Volunteers asked to raise £2k to spend on activities, corporate sponsorship being explord. John Hodder, a member of the Friends of Desborough Library, said: “There has got to be another way of funding this situation, the council has admitted to not having enough funds to run libraries, but asking friends of libraries is not the best way to do it.” Also Community may be asked to volunteer or donate cash to help Northampton’s libraries survive in Northampton Chronicle.
Northamptonshire – First stage of library review begins with possibility of Sunday opening considered – AboutMyArea. “This is why we are starting our review by speaking with our partners and key stakeholders as libraries need their help. The thousands of responses we received during our library closure proposals earlier this year showed us just how much libraries are valued by people living and working in the county and we want to harness this enthusiasm and support. In fact, many people have said that they would be prepared to pay something towards keeping their service.”
Oxfordshire – Friends group vows to fight reworked library funding cuts – Henley Standard. “The news comes just six months after Watlington library was re-opened following a £700,000 refurbishment in which the size of the High Street building was doubled.”
West Sussex – Happy story as mobile library escapes axe in Bognor Regis – Bognor Regis Observer.”Regular Nan Macauley, 77, from the Flansham Park estate, said: “The mobile library is very important to me. I have an invalid husband, John, and I come here every week and take seven books and six taped books because he is a prolific reader.”
Wiltshire – Volunteers set to man Wiltshire libraries – Gazette & Herald.
Wirral – Libraries future threatened again by council job cuts – Liverpool Daily Post. “The borough’s new Labour administration claimed they were left as virtually “empty shells” with no one to work in them after massive job losses in the council.” Also reported as “Impossible” to run Wirral libraries as staff cuts take their toll” – Wirral Globe where Conservatives fear the comments from Labout mean it is “softening up” the public for closures. Also in BookSeller as Libraries now “empty shells”. “Councillor Chris Meaden, the cabinet member for culture, said it was “literally impossible to run the library service we used to with the skeleton staff we have remaining” and “creative thinking” would now be needed, the Liverpool Daily Post reports”
Worcestershire – Staff to do all they can to keep library open – Malvern Gazette. “I genuinely believe that community partnership might be a solution that fits for Upton. We are already quite a community hub anyway, and if we were to go down that route then while we would undoubtedly see some change, it might not necessarily be a bad thing.”
Well done to Jim, not so well done to Ed
Jun 12th
Congratulations must go to Jim Brooks who has received an MBE for his work in establishing a volunteer-run library at Little Chalfont after Buckinghamshire Council decided to close it a few years ago. This comes barely a week after the same library won a Queen’s Award for Voluntary Service. It’s interesting timing (and this is not meant to be detrimental to the efforts of Jim and his team), though, that these awards are being given now that public libraries are under threat as never before and councils around the country are actively encouraging volunteers (“unpaid employees”) to run them.
It is also interesting to compare this situation to the Minister for Libraries’, Ed Vaizey, comments on national radio in January that …
“We [Conservatives] have never said – and it’s a gross misrepresentation of what we have said – that somehow volunteers should replace professional librarians. No-one is suggesting that volunteers should take over the role of professional librarians…. Nobody is saying that there’s a strategy to replace professional librarians with volunteers.”
417 libraries (344 buildings and 73 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK (for the complete list by area see the page “Tally by local authority”). Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries). The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.
News
7 habits of highly effective library websites – Lesley Thomson. Sites need to have a purpose, be integrated, designed for the user, access anything in three clicks, use pictures, if there is a complaint it is the computer and not the user that is broken, great content, accessible to all, easily searchable and findable, constantly redesigned, mobile phone access is half as good. “I looked at a large number of UK library websites and, with few exceptions, the usability and UX of these was pretty dire”
“Well done to the Evening Standard, in London, and the National Literacy Trust for their extraordinary and brilliant campaigns about literacy in the capital. I have never seen anything like it – and it has worked. I have been in two council meetings in the last two weeks in which councillors have talked – even with some passion and feeling- about the importance of books, reading, libraries and so on. A year ago I thought I would never hear the like” Tim Coates, Good Library Blog
I really love public libraries but … – Karen Blakeman’s Blog. Caversham (Reading) library user dislikes computer errors with loan dates and online renewal, useless ID number on library card. “Perhaps Reading Libraries is an exception but if libraries seriously want to encourage more users then they need to improve ease of use, especially when it comes to their web based services.”
Killer pets – Library Tribe. Excellent photo of library user in ongoing series by Warrington photographer.
Outgoing children’s laureate Anthony Browne wants youngsters to keep hold of their creativity – Your Canterbury. “Just 85 councils out of more than 150 with responsibility for schools run their own dedicated service, providing fresh stocks of books to schools alongside a range of other resources. Mr Browne said: “It’s a terrible shame. We should be encouraging libraries to become more interesting, provide more resources and be more exciting places to be – not the other way around.”
“We desperately need libraries, but we don’t need them as they were in the past 20 years. I think library budgets should go up immensely, but not if we do things as we do them now. School libraries are one of the first documented points of academic success. There’s just so much data and evidence that talks about test scores going up when you have a school librarian, not just a library. They’re educators, they’re teachers, and they’re not stuck in this straitjacketed curriculum. They let kids explore what they want to know. Imagine if the entire community is allowed to be that agile — if they can make decisions based on better information.” Preserve our dreams, Dallas Observer (USA). Challenging but pro-library piece by one of the most prominent librarian thinkers.
TEDx LibrariansTO – Conference on librarians as “thought leaders” (USA)
Veria Public Library, Greece – Winner of Access to Learning Award 2010, Greece Bill and Medinda Gates Foundation
Wha’s like us – Scotland on Sunday (leading article). Julia Donaldson received MBE as well as becoming children’s laureate. “For those concerned about our children’s literary future, Donaldson is the ideal champion. Not least because, as every Scottish child knows, there really is such a thing as a gruffalo.”
Change to services
West Sussex – 1 (out of 3) mobile libraries closed meaning £65k cut out of £1m cut expected of libraries by 2014.
Local News
Barnet – Last chance to state your views on libraries plan – Barnet Today. Major opposition to plan to close Friern Barnet Library. Council says “Our strategy foresees a service delivered in places that people go to rather than requiring them to travel to come to the local library.”
Croydon – Message clear at Labour’s open meeting – This is Croydon today. Labour asks for cross-party commission to look at options, Tim Coates suggests cutting overheads from 45% to 10% would solve problem.
Croydon – Privatisation of all Croydon libraries? Act now – Sanderstead Library Campaign Group. Privatisation was not part of the now ended consultation process on closing libraries in Croydon and there has been no support for this proposal voiced.
Croydon – Wards among worst in London for children’s literacy – Inside Croydon. Literacy advisors reduced, “Significantly, there is no library service to speak of in the area. A library visit for parents with their under-11s, or for any of the classes at the schools, would require a drive by car or bus to Caterham on the Hill or Purley. And if Kenley residents were to take their children to Sanderstead Library, they would discover that there is now a children’s librarian on duty on only one Saturday every month”. Councillor in charge of libraries for Croydon, Sara Bashford, has said that it would be better to give everyone book tokens rather than keep libraries open.
Cumbria – Self-service machines for Carlisle library – BBC. First refurbishment of Carlisle Library in 25 years to include self-service and re-arrangement. “The changes will allow more library staff to get out from behind the counter and really provide a service which involves interacting with library customers.”
Cumbria – Views sought on Cumbria library shake-up – BBC. “”There are no preconceptions to this debate and we may end up with more library access points in Cumbria than we have now – or we may end up with fewer”, although 20 branches are still under threat.
Gloucestershire – FoGL fundraising campaign and legal challenge – FoGL. Council may be in breach of Public Libraries and Museums Act, Libraries Act and failed to consult properly. Up to £15,000 needed for case as government has cut Legal Aid’s budget.
Northamptonshire – Review of library service begins – BBC. “The aim is to make libraries more self-supporting and reduce council costs.”
Northumberland – Coffee, cakes and Catherine Cookson – Morpeth Herald. Two-year old report starting to be acted on – cafes may be installed. Councillors suggesting increasing income by charging for libraries, charging coffee companies to use buildings, cutting management. “This is not about deciding which libraries are unsustainable and will be axed, it is about making sure there will be a library service in all our communities and that it is sustainable.”
Suffolk – Libraries: air your views on future – Haverhill Echo. “This is an important opportunity to look at how the council is moving forward with the libraries review – and give interested parties an opportunity to air their views in public
West Sussex – £65k cuts lead to loss of West Sussex mobile library – Bognor Regis Observer. Survey showed 30% used a static library as well, some alternative provision found for the 70% who did not. Also reported in Mobile library cut balance council books – Crawley Observer. “I’m more than a little concerned. There are many elderly residents in Worth. The library service will stop at Pound Hill Parade and that’s a bit of a long slog.”
Birmingham and Islington guarantee no libraries will close
Jun 10th
News
Campaign for the Book June Newsletter – Alan Gibbons. Gives an overview of the new allies for libraries this month – the children’s laureate, the WI, even (more equivocally given Brent and Lewisham) the Labour Party.
Donaldson backs National Libraries Day – BookSeller. “Hooray for National Libraries Day! So many wonderful things go on in libraries—not just reading, browsing and borrowing, but storytelling, rhyme times, book clubs, activity days, author events and holiday reading challenges—and this special day will be a celebration of them all.”
Don’t privatise that book! – City Journal. Anti-union, pro-privatisation viewpoint on the Californian law that now makes it harder for libraries to be privatised.
Future Library – BookSeller. New “Library of Birmingham” biggest public library project in Europe, “shop window for the city and culture of the city”. Birmingham Council says it will not close any libraries.
Happy in the Library – Blog posts on people using the library.
“Surprisingly, far from being made obsolete by the Internet, public libraries are becoming more important. Forty-four percent of people living in households below the federal poverty line use the library to access the Internet. Yet many librarians report they cannot keep up with the demand of these patrons. (Chapter 18, Libraries.)” Information needs of communities – Federal Communications Commission (USA).
Landmark US library to close – Guardian. ‘The greatest nation on earth’, as we still call ourselves, no longer has the political will to arrest its visible and precipitous decline and save the institutions on which the workings of our democracy depend … Their slow disappearance is a tragedy, not just for those impoverished towns and cities, but for everyone everywhere terrified at the thought of a country without libraries.”
People matter – Annie Mauger blog post, CILIP.
Reading buddies project helps the blind use North East libraries – Journal Live. Training for volunteers to help visually impaired users in libraries.
Somewhere special – Voices for the Library. Touching descriptions of people using public libraries.
Women’s Institutes joins battle to save libraries – Guardian. ““It’s fabulous news for the millions of people across the UK that love their libraries. Libraries are an essential education and information resource. They are at the heart of communities across the country and are too important to lose,” (Annie Mauger, CILIP).
Changes to Library services
Birmingham – 39 less under threat.
Islington – Guarantee no libraries will close. 10% (£600k) cut. May be job losses, cuts in hours, more self-service. Seriously considering turning into a Trust to save £450k p.a. in tax.
North Yorkshire – £300k off bookfund as part of bid to keep more libraries open. £592k cut to mobile libraries meaning no standard mobile libraries to remain running.
Somerset – The four (out of six) mobile libraries to be closed are based at Minehead, Bridgwater, Taunton and Wells meaning 209 communities will still receive a mobile library service whilst 206 communities, which currently receive a service, will no longer do so
Wokingham – Privatised libraries may include community groups taking over libraries as well.
Local News
Bexley/Bromley – More than 70 posts to go as Bromley and Bexley libraries merge – Bromley Times.
Bolton – High school offers to open its library to community – This is Lancashire. If Astley Bridge library closes, local high school could open a public library in its building if it was paid to do so.
“If you removed every single public library from the budget, it wouldn’t affect the budget crises we are trying to resolve. From a budget point of view libraries aren’t that significant. From a point of view of their contribution to a community and health of a local community, they are enormously important.” Brian Gambles, Assistant Director of Culture, Birmingham
Brent – Save out libraries: fight goes to the High Court – Londonist. “Unfortunately, no legal fight is cheap. There are lots of ways to lend your support; for starters, check out the comedy night at the North London Tavern on Friday 10th June. The Save Kensal Rise Library crew will also be at the Queen’s Park Literary Festival on Saturday 11th June.”
Croydon – Book Trail tragedy averted as Bashford overlooks the law again – Inside Croydon. Plan to have volunteers helping children without any CRB checking quashed.
Isle of Wight – Library campaigners report successful meeting with DCMS – Ventnor Blog. DCMS officials interested and impressed by documents received. They also appeared surprised by lack of consultation by council and its lack of looking for alternatives of closure. Campaigners have produced a full newsletter on the subject.
Islington – Library service could be run by charity trusts to save thousands in taxes – Islington Tribune. 10% (£600k) cut in Islington library service, no closures – some job losses, cuts in hours, more self-service. Turning to a Trust would save £450k per year.
Manchester – Homework clubs axed at Manchester libraries in council budget cuts – Manchester Evening News. Qualified tutors stop, librarians will be trained up instead. Campaign started in Levenshulme against this – “The teacher at the homework club is brilliant and knows all the children, what their weaknesses are and what they need help with”.
North Yorkshire – Library chiefs look to cut amount spent on new books by £300k – Press.
North Yorkshire – End of road for mobile libraries – Whitby Gazette. ““I think if we were in a town there would be enough heads to make a great big wave to stop this, but we can only create a ripple.
“It’s almost as if because you are rural you are not important because there’s not enough of you to fight back.”. Only 3.4% of those consulted were in favour of closing mobile libraries but the cost per user is £77 per year.
Somerset – County Council plans to cut mobile libraries – BBC.
Wokingham – “Council consulted no-one” claim as libraries row rages on – Get Wokingham. Council says that just because a private company will run the libraries, it does not mean they are privatised. Opposition councillors point out there was no consultation and no detailed business case. “Library services are being privatised for ideological reasons. They could be the first in a long line of services that could be outsourced by the Conservative council. History tells us that outsourcing leads to cuts.”
Jun 10th
Donaldson backs National Libraries Day – BookSeller. “Hooray for National Libraries Day! So many wonderful things go on in libraries—not just reading, browsing and borrowing, but storytelling, rhyme times, book clubs, activity days, author events and holiday reading challenges—and this special day will be a celebration of them all.”
Future Library – BookSeller. New “Library of Birmingham” biggest public library project in Europe, “shop window for the city and culture of the city”. Birmingham Council says it will not close any libraries.
Women’s Institutes joins battle to save libraries – Guardian. ““It’s fabulous news for the millions of people across the UK that love their libraries. Libraries are an essential education and information resource. They are at the heart of communities across the country and are too important to lose,” (Annie Mauger, CILIP).
Changes to Library services
Birmingham – 39 less under threat.
Islington – Guarantee no libraries will close. 10% (£600k) cut. May be job losses, cuts in hours, more self-service. Seriously considering turning into a Trust to save £450k p.a. in tax.
Somerset – The four (out of six) mobile libraries to be closed are based at Minehead, Bridgwater, Taunton and Wells meaning a reduction of 206 stops.
Local News
“If you removed every single public library from the budget, it wouldn’t affect the budget crises we are trying to resolve. From a budget point of view libraries aren’t that significant. From a point of view of their contribution to a community and health of a local community, they are enormously important.” Brian Gambles, Assistant Director of Culture, Birmingham.
Islington – Library service could be run by charity trusts to save thousands in taxes – Islington Tribune. 10% (£600k) cut in Islington library service, no closures – some job losses, cuts in hours, more self-service. Turning to a Trust would save £450k per year.
Somerset – County Council plans to cut mobile libraries – BBC.
Wokingham – “Council consulted no-one” claim as libraries row rages on – Get Wokingham.
A review of the situation from the MLA
Jun 9th
A Regional Manager from the MLA gave a talk yesterday to the Cambridge Library Group on “Libraries and the Big Society”. Annie Johnson, who was there, has kindly sent me a summary of this talk which I have tailored for posting below. It is worth reading as it gives an overview of what stage public libraries are at now, albeit a surprisingly upbeat one and one which some library staff/campaigners would disagree with on a few points:
There are many negatives to the current situation. There have been falling (physical) visitors since 2005-6, Libraries and Culture are being disproportionately cut by councils, the 1964 Public Libraries and Museums Act makes libraries statutory but in a “hard to define” way, there are too few library advocates “higher up” and Public Library Service Standards are now abolished so there is no way for libraries to demonstrate performance. Cutting because one has to is not a good way to review a service or to prepare for the future.
In other ways, there’s some positives. Libraries are now constantly in the news and high on the public agenda, campaigns have proved that libraries have an unprecedently high level of public support and “creative solutions” to the cuts are being found.
Public libraries are, and are seen to be, an embodiment of the Big Society in action (and were long before this became a political buzzword). The values that are important to libraries include community empowerment, information literacy, openness of public services, social enterprise. Volunteers are a difficult issue. Volunteers should not replace paid employees, but creative use of volunteers as a supplement to paid staff is good, filling gaps in services libraries would like to provide but can’t due to budget constraints (e.g. silver surfers, local history etc.).
Possible efficiencies (this does not mean simply cost-cutting) include less back-office staff, more self-service, more collaboration (eg. Essex runs Sloughs’ public libraries), more market research, more shared services and shared locations (eg. with trading standards), more commerical businesses (e.g. cafes).
My thanks to Annie Johnson for the reporting.
455 libraries (383 buildings and 72 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK (for the complete list by area see the page “Tally by local authority”)
News
Are libraries a dying breed? – Barbara Talley.
CLG talk on the Big Society – Wee Bookworms.
Don’t be afraid to go in you library and read every book – Voices for the Library. Matthew Hyde guest posts “Nowadays people don’t tend to be burning down libraries, at least not in Dudley, but they’re under threat. It’s easy to take them for granted, but in a world where we can access a mountain of information with next to no quality filter, librarians should rule. Somewhere along the line, that building full of books has seen the skillsets of the people who work there gain in currency.”
Government plans to block extremist websites from public internet – v3. “”Internet filtering across the public estate is essential. We want to ensure that users in schools, libraries, colleges and Immigration Removal Centres are unable to access unlawful material,” the report said.” but, on the other hand, Jim Killick of the Open Rights Group calls it a “step too far” – “Libraries are a resource for sharing knowledge and study, no matter who you are. Adults must be assumed to be responsible and capable of making their own judgements,”
Libraries and the WI – Walk You Home. Lauren Smith was there.
Public libraries briefing – CILIP.
“Next time you’re driving or walking past your local library maybe break the habit and step inside. It’s even cheaper than Amazon… all of it’s free. No wonder those that use libraries regularly are up in arms about proposed closures of them. It just strikes me as something a nation can boast about – we lend people books for free.” This place will lend you books for free – Sabotage Times. See also the excellent comments (and not just the one recommending Public Libraries News).
Windows on the world, keeping them open: the prospects for public service broadcasting, libraries and arts – Voice of the Listener and Viewer, public meeting in Leeds, 16th July.
Women’s Institute will campaign for libraries – BookSeller.
Change to library services
Camden – 2 more under threat (1 branch, 1 mobile) – 3 libraries to transfer to being run by volunteers, Mobile Library to close, Regents Park Library to close. 10% opening hours cut for all, bookfund cut, 35 jobs lost,
Local News
Bexley – Mobile library service faces axe – Bexley Times.
Brent – Another chapter in bid to save libraries – Wembley and Willesden.
Cambridgeshire – Longer opening hours for Linton Library – Haverhill Echo. 3 hours per week more but library still under threat of “divestment”.
Cambridgeshire – Huntingdonshire library open hours cuts planned – Hunts Post 24. ” “I would say I do not see the point in knocking two hours off the opening times. The library should be the hub of the town. It should have the tourist information centre there. In some communities, the town council offices should be there.”
Camden – Library funding cuts: Town Hall approves plan for three branches to be run by volunteers – Camden New Journal. Camden, Belsize and Heath to be managed by volunteers by mid 2012, or closed, mobile to close, Regents Park Library to close (mothballing may happen). ““The lack of trust in the management of Camden’s libraries is palpable. We will be holding meetings to discuss our options. One major issue will be having faith in the Town Hall to work with us.”
Isle of Wight – Library campaigners meet officials today – Ventnor Blog. Meeting appears to have been positive but, as normal, with no guarantees of action. Also covered on Isle of Wight Radio.
North Yorkshire – Council U-turn over village facility – Craven Herald & Pioneer. Gargrave and Embsay Libraries will not survive without volunteers, council withdrawing broadband “churlish”.
North Yorkshire – Kirkbymoorside and Helmsley libraries saved by people power – Gazette & Herald. Malton and Norton libraries, though, will be shut and a combined library opened instead.
Northumberland – Cafes could help to keep libraries open, council told – New Post Leader. Councillors also suggest charging for libraries and suggests German public libraries do this, less management, more opening hours.





Recent Comments