Ian Anstice

Public librarian since 1994, user of public libraries since my first memories ... and a keen advocate of public libraries and chronicler of the UK public libraries scene. Library manager since 1998, winner of Information Professional of the Year 2011 and Winsford Customer Service "Oscar" 2012 and 2014, honorary CILIP fellow 2015, CILIP Wales Library Champion of the Year 2016.

Homepage: https://www.publiclibrariesnews.com


Posts by Ian Anstice

“An environment in which knowledge appeared valued and precious”

Tim Coates (ex boss of Waterstones and now boss of e-book company Bilbary), on the last Public Libraries News post, commented on Phil Bradley’s article on 3D printers.  Phil has responded to the comment below.

“I’m not sure what point Mr Coates is trying to make, since even a cursory reading of my article makes it perfectly clear that I’m considering the role of these printers across the board. Indeed, the specific point that I make regarding public libraries is that they are NOT yet appropriate. With regard his other issues with my statements; he says that libraries should provide people with information when they want it. I agree entirely, and that is what libraries do, and in some instances this helps people back into work, improves or empowers them and by doing so, helps to improve their community. I’m sorry if he thinks that this is ‘pretentious’ or ‘ridiculous’, but since he’s in agreement with me I’m not sure what else I can say.” Phil Bradley, via email.

In other news, the importance of internet access in libraries is underlined by a report that says a third of poorest pupils do not have it available at home.  There is also considerable coverage of Chris Packham’s criticism of cuts to his local library and to the ongoing Newcastle library cuts.

More >

Library cuts “a betrayal of trust and an insult to sensibility” says Chris Packham

It’s great to see Chris Packham join the ranks of celebrities speaking out to defend public libraries.  It’s also good to see the ever-excellent US Geek The Library campaign’s page on debunking the myths behind US public library finance.  It would be useful to have a similar page somewhere in the UK too to challenge those who think that all council services are padded and wasteful. A recent Oxford University report which shows the altogether disastrous impact to teenage studiers of not having an online connection is also useful ammunition in the fight to highlight the continued importance of the library.

The good effects of having a far-sighted and dynamic, and perhaps well-funded, public library service is shown further down today’s post in the success of Edinburgh.  It’s also good to see a vacancy in Norwich for someone to keep up the good work there.  It’s not often one sees a job advert like that these days.

As to what public libraries should be for … well, that’s always been a contentious issue.  There are some who see libraries as simply for the provision of literature and information and others who see them as having an altogether wider remit.  The response, below, by Tim Coates to an article by Phil Bradley on 3D printers shows this difference of opinion in sharp relief.

More >

Buckle up for the new year

In the first Public Libraries News post for 2013, the articles doubtless show themes which will be with us throughout the year to come.  We have national government blaming councils for closing libraries and councils blaming the government for doing so.  We have questions over what public libraries are for – books are an important one here but increasingly with an – and questions over using new technology, with our old friend 3D printers making a controversial appearance once more.  Big names (step forward the New York Post, Independent and Guardian) argue for the importance of libraries while the decision-makers who really matter keep silent or blame eachother.

On a more local scale, we have further moves towards volunteers running libraries (with a noticeably increasing and controversial emphasis on this being able to improve the service) and for co-location.  We also have more evidence that, surprise surprise, closing branches actually directly reduces library use. Different forms of governance of libraries is covered, with the pros and cons of transferring a library service to a trust (“community benefit society”) looked at in York. Something new last month but that is being repeated a lot is using the new user-friendly Cipfa figures to embarrass poorly performing councils. Finally, we of course have public protest, with Newcastle in particular looking like the big flashpoint.

So, in summary, much of the same but a smattering of the new.  Another year of immense change is upon us.  It’s going to be exciting, dramatic, depressing, optimistic, frustrating and dynamic.  Buckle up, look for opportunities, work hard and … above all … don’t give up.

More >

“I had never seen a library before – that was an astonishment – I never looked back”

The above quote is from an excellent brief clip about the author Junot Diaz’s first experience of a public library that shows the impact and importance of public libraries.  It’s a message that the ex head of Lancashire libraries makes clear needs to be got through to those holding the purse strings … especially those in central Government.

More >

Merry Christmas everyone

Christmas is here so let us forget our sorrows for a few days, recharge our batteries and have fun. Have a great Christmas everyone and let us hope that 2013 is a better one … and remember, librarians are in the only profession where borrowing going up is a good thing.

More >

Labour Public Libraries policy review – “innovation, co-location and partnership”

 

The Labour Party have released their long-awaited review of library policy, entitled “Libraries: innovation, co-location and partnership”.  Dan Jarvis MP said when launching it:

More >

Libraries will “become almost unsustainable” says LGA

The Government has decided to further cut local government spending by 1.7% on average.  This is on top the already historically high level of cuts of 28% already agreed.  Inflation of course makes that figure even worse.  It’s interesting to see that different authorities are, however, being dealt with differently – with some (with a high proportion being  in comparatively prosperous parts of the country) receiving fairly large rises of up to 6.4% (well done Uttlesford).  but others (with a high proportion being in less prosperous areas) getting cuts of up to 8.8% (bad luck Barrow-in-Furness).

The chair of the LGA finance panel, Sharon Taylor, was questioned about this on Radio Five and used libraries as a direct example of a service that libraries would “become almost unsustainable”.  Well done to her for standing up for libraries, by the way.

More >

Eric Pickles calls campaigners “luvvies” & Cipfa produce detailed easy-to-understand performance indicators for every library authority

Eric Pickles, the Communities secretary, appeared to call library campaigners “luvvies” in Parliament today.  He also put forward the view that Cultural services such as cultural institutions should make money.  On the same day, a new graph – called the “Jaws of Doom” – shows that the planned cuts in council budgets combined with an increased demand for their services will mean a cut of nearly half in council’s spending.  This will mean – as the people of Newcastle (one of the few councils who have made their plans public for the next three years, rather than for just one) have discovered – the effective end of Arts provision and, at least, the halving of public library provision.  Not that Pickles will care, especially as he appears to believe  that such cuts can be achieved solely by efficiencies.  Conveniently for him, this means that he can blame councils – and not his own policies – for any cuts in services.  As a campaigner pointed out in an email I saw today, it also means that it’s “becoming clear that the real purpose of the Localism Act was to transfer blame, not power, to local authorities”. That the public will protest actively against such cuts has been more than proved by the last two years of protest.  Expect a lot more to come.

More >

“One upon a time” – Newcastle before the cuts.

A look into the past with Newcastle libraries chief explaining the strategy before the cuts hit and a challenge on library RFID are the two notable items today.

More >

“You have two, maybe three, years”

The above eye-catching headline is not about libraries generally, nor the average time left for paid members of staff (although it feels like it) but the window of opportunity that public libraries have with e-books before things are settled.  An important article looks at the subject in some depth from different points of view.

In these hard-nosed times, one of the key weapons libraries have of defending their worth is to point out their economic value.  Two new resources have been produced by Carl Clayton (in his private capacity) that will be useful in this regard:

  • The economic value of public libraries – Depression costs the Uk £12bn. Bibliotherapy – as well as library’s help in job hunting etc – can greatly help those suffering from depression. “Every pound spent on library services will create a future saving in costs for the council. It is not possible to quantify this saving exactly but a comparison of the limited cost of the library service with the large costs of depression (not to mention other illnesses) indicates that this would be significant.”
  • Value of public library services – Covers “published reports that consider the value of public library services in a quantitative sense.”  Lists and summarises some very useful documents including some unfamiliar ones such as a Norwegian study showing that libraries have a cost benefit ratio of 1:4

For volunteers, a new court decision has meant that volunteers cannot claim under employment law unless they have a contract or are undergoing vocational training.  This removes an obstacle for volunteers taking over libraries in that it frees them from having to worry about employment law with their unpaid workers.  Of course, it’s also equally a detriment to those same volunteers who cannot appeal to the same rights that paid workers have, at least in this instance.

More >