No Safe Place for Trusts

Editorial

The rubber-stamping of the return of libraries in Suffolk to direct council control is full of controversy. We have of course seen many other non-profits (Falkirk, Flintshire, Merthyt Tydfil, Northamptonshire, Peterborough, Warrington – ish – and Wigan) losing public library control over the last few years. But Suffolk stands out, not just because of the unexpectedness and tone of the decision, but because Suffolk Libraries were largely seen as being highly successful.

So for those organisations still running trusts, including the mighty GLL, York Explore and Libraries Unlimited, the lesson is clear. You are not safe. And not because of anything you can do anything about but rather because, simply, your local councillors may just desire to get the contract back. And this could happen any time. Suffolk County Council itself may not last even another year due to devolution.

There are two bigger picture stories that have become crystal clear the last week too. The first is that the current Labour government is effectively simply continuing austerity policies of the previous government, right down to cutting benefits for the disabled. So no-one is coming to save public libraries. Rather it’s up to the sector itself to do so. Thankfully, the last fifteen years or so has given a lot of tips about what works in that regard.

Secondly, USA public libraries are now in a country whose government does not like public libraries. Now, few would have looked at their president before and thought “now there’s a man who’s regularly seen at his local branch” but the decision to effectively eliminate the national funding body for libraries kind of confirms he’s not the type. And the decision to stop up the access to the previously bi-national library on the Canadian border is just an extra sign, a big “no access” sign, that this can take place at the most local level as well. It’s almost as if libraries there are under the control of someone with their own political motives, lack of attachment to facts and prone to acting on a whim. Obviously, not at all like Suffolk.

Changes by local authority

• Stoke on Trent – New unstaffed library at Fenton Manor leisure centre, some libraries to eventually become volunteer.
• Wirral – Beechwood, Eastham, Greasby, Rock Ferry and Upton under threat.

National news

• £1.1bn British Library extension plans to go ahead – BBC. “The project will see a total of 700,000 sq ft (65,090 sq m) of new library, learning, research and commercial space on the site in Kings Cross, alongside a redesigned full-height foyer and public entrances.”
• Anti-racist Book Reviews – People’s Collection Wales. “As part of the CILIP Anti Racist Library Collections in Public Libraries in Wales project we collected short book reviews from public librarians in Wales. As part of Phase 1 of the project we bought books – by black authors, about anti-racism, and about diversity in libraries – from small specialist suppliers (Gwales, Books from Nowhere, and Facet). We posted books from the list to each volunteer reviewer. We hope these reviews will encourage library colleagues to read and talk about a range of potentially anti-racist books. Please see the reviewer guidelines for more information and context and feel free to re-use.”

• Libraries are the heart of our rural communities – Friends of the Earth Scotland. “Across Scotland, local councils are closing rural libraries at an alarming rate. In Aberdeenshire alone, there are thirteen currently at risk.” … “I guess long story short, a library is more than just a building. It’s the heart of our rural communities, and we must ensure that they continue beating for the future generations.”
• ‘A library is more than a place with books, it is a lifeline’ – BBC. “The UK is losing libraries at a rate of about 40 each year, BBC research has found. According to those who depend on them, local libraries are far more than a repository of books – they are community focal points and, for some, a vital lifeline to the outside world. What happens when one closes?”
• The library named the best in Wales is revealed – Nation Cymru. “Awen Cultural Trust has won the Welsh title, engaging the local community in the heart of South Wales with their 21 Book Challenge challenging adult readers alongside the children’s Summer Reading Challenge, resulting in converting more parents to reading.”

“The following table shows the number of open static libraries in England in the most recent 10 years for which data is available. The data is taken from the Arts Council England Basic Dataset for Libraries 2023 which consolidated and validated previous datasets.

	1/7/2016	31/12/2019	31/12/2021	31/12/2022	31/12/2023
Number of open static libraries included in the dataset	3,010	2,938	2,914	2,894	2,877
Number of open static libraries within the statutory provision	2,727	2,585	2,550	2,576	2,578

Chris Bryant The Minister of State, Department for Culture, Media and Sport, Minister of State (Department for Science, Innovation and Technology)

• Santander to close almost a quarter of UK branches – BBC. “It said the areas to lose branches would be covered by 95 “community bankers” who will visit local communities on a weekly basis in facilities such as libraries.”

International news

• Canada – Temporary closure of Saskatoon library branches amid overdose crisis needed but won’t fix broader issues: CUPE – CBC. Two branches closed due to high number of drug overdoses. “Library staff responded to at least 48 overdoses or drug poisonings so far this year — almost double the number from the same period in 2024, according to a statement from the public library.” … “Staff at the two branches are routinely stopping people from using or selling drugs, and are removing intoxicated people from the buildings in line with bylaw requirements” … “The provincial government hasn’t increased library funding in the last three budgets and … they took the funding away for harm reduction”.
• Canada/USA – Library on US-Canadian border feels effects of crackdown on movement – Argus. “For more than 100 years, people in Stanstead, Quebec in Canada have been able to walk into Derby Line, in the US state of Vermont to enter the Haskell Free Library and Opera House – no passport required. But municipal and library officials said on Friday that US authorities have unilaterally decided to end the century-old unwritten agreement.” … “In February, the Boston Globe reported that the US Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem visited the library and repeated Mr Trump’s taunts about making Canada the 51st state as she stepped back and forth across the line that marks the border.” see also US blocks Canadian access to cross-border library, sparking outcry – Guardian. USA claims its to stop crimes but “The department provided no evidence of drug trafficking or smuggling and did not immediately respond to a request for additional information.”

• USA – Executive Order Targets the Institute for Museum and Library Services – Publishers Weekly. Trump will reduce IMLS to minimum. “The IMLS is an independent federal agency that plays a key role in distributing congressionally approved funds to libraries, museums, and archives in all 50 states plus five U.S. territories and three sovereign countries. In 2024, it awarded $266.7 million to advance and support libraries, museums, and related organizations” see also Trump’s attack on libraries was predictable. Its consequences could be devastating – Guardian. “We saw this crisis coming, but our response can still make a difference. Let’s ensure that this predictable attack doesn’t quietly become a permanent loss.”
• Tracking the Trump Administration’s Attacks on Libraries – American Libraries.

Local news by authority

• Brighton and Hove – Brighton and Hove council still to decide which libraries to close – Argus. 3 libraries to close but “Councillors were told that Brighton and Hove City Council was currently carrying out a “needs and use” analysis and it would then consult the public.” at to which ones.
• Bristol – Bristol library staff threatened with shotgun and chased down street with machetes – Bristol Post. [This story appears to be untrue – email sent to myself says “no gun was ever seen and no one was ever been chased with a machete.”]
• Bromley – St Paul’s Cray Library reaches finals for library of the year – Bromley Council. “Recent refurbishment brought services together at St Paul’s Cray Library and Community Support Centre, allowing experienced support centre staff to continue to offer advice and guidance locally alongside the high-quality library service found across the borough, which now benefits from enhanced, modern facilities following the works.”
• Cardiff – Cardiff Council Outlines Future Plans for Hubs and Libraries – Business News Wales. “Almost 16,000 new members joined the city’s library service, 1.9 million book loans were issued, more than 78,000 new books were bought and 175,000 children and adults attended events in hubs and libraries in 2023/24.”
• Cornwall – Sensory kits help children interact with stories – BBC. “Five sensory story kits have been bought by Cornwall Libraries, which use props to help engage with the traditional five senses – sight, sound, smell, taste and touch – along with additional ones such as temperature and balance. Along with the five kits, other standalone books which let people create their own sensory stories have also become available to borrow.”
• Darlington – Darlington Libraries initiative to get readers online – Darlington and Stockton Times. “Books that Bloom sees seeded postcards available to pick up across Darlington town centre which explain how to access the libraries’ digital platforms. The postcards detail how you can sign up for Darlington Libraries’ digital services to access an extensive reading catalogue via the Library App and Borrowbox by scanning a QR code.”
• Denbighshire – Denbighshire Libraries’ ‘25 books in 2025’ challenge sees more than 100 sign ups – News From Wales. “Readers are challenged to pick up a bingo sheet and get it stamped each time a book is returned matching one of the categories. “
• East Sussex – Bexhill library book is returned – almost 28 years later – Sussex World. “It was one of 24,000 overdue books which East Sussex Library Service is trying to recover by waiving fines until the end of March in an annual amnesty.” … “Since the amnesty launched on Monday, February 17, nearly 6,000 items have been returned”
• Glasgow – This Glasgow library is set to be transformed and this is the plan – Glasgow Times. Public library sold for £175k. “The former Parkhead Library is being disposed to Hector House – a company that owns an assisted living residence in the city – and will be used as a multi-purpose community and events space with a dedicated function hall.”

• Greenwich – Eltham library hailed for its status as a community hub and friend of Ukraine – London News Online. “Eltham Centre Library has been been highly commended in the ‘Library of the Year’ awards – acknowledging the part it has played in helping Ukrainians fleeing the war with Russia.” … “This has included more inclusive stock, eye-catching displays and even new wallpaper says October Jones, Children’s Librarian and the driving force behind the scheme.”. Roehampton children’s library mentioned.
• Guernsey – Community library to close after 76 years – BBC. “A community library in Guernsey which specialises in large print books is closing after 76 years. St John Guernsey Charity said it will shut the library, which won the Queen’s Award for Voluntary Service in 2014, in May. The charity said it was “no longer… best placed” to continue offering the service and it would be transferred to the Guille-Allès Library in St Peter Port.”
• Middlesbrough – Hope refurbished central library will reopen early – BBC. “Middlesbrough Central Library is set to reopen its doors sooner than planned following a “really exciting” redevelopment. The facility was closed in December 2023 for a refurbishment and was not due to reopen until the summer. However, councillors have been told it could now reopen in six weeks’ time, in May.”
• Oxfordshire – Oxfordshire library set to reopen after refurbishment – Oxford Mail. “The library, under Oxfordshire County Council, has been made more environmentally sustainable with new heating systems, lighting, and double glazing. There is also new contemporary furniture and dedicated work and study spaces with charging points. The furniture uses fabric made entirely from recycled plastics, including sea debris and landfill-bound bottles.” … “The renovations were made possible through a combination of central government decarbonisation funds and developer funding, also known as the community infrastructure levy”
• Somerset – Library to get £1.5m funding to fix leaky roof – BBC. “”This work will make the building watertight and weatherproof – as what good is a library if it’s full of water?”” … “”This funding of up to £1.5m is coming out of a pot of money we put in place to look after our listed assets.”
  • Library to close for vital upgrades – Somerset Council. Taunton ” library, and The Glass Box innovation space, will close their doors on Wednesday and Thursday 9 and 10 April for a major IT network and Wi-Fi hardware and systems improvements.”
• Stirling – New chapter for library services to be written following public consultation – Stirling Council. “Focus groups are to be set up across Stirling for residents to look at what the future of Stirling Council’s library service may look like.”
• Stoke on Trent – New library for ‘forgotten town’ as satellite site set to open at Fenton Manor – Stoke Sentinel. Unstaffed new “satellite” library planned. “Under the plans, shelves would be installed in the circulation space between the main entrance and the cafe, with existing leisure centre staff overseeing the service.” … ” the city council is looking to recruit more volunteers to work alongside paid staff at its six existing libraries.” … ” Some libraries could eventually move to a volunteer-led model,”
• Suffolk – Mark Murphy: Suffolk County Council libraries backlash – East Anglian Daily Times. Paywall. “Suffolk County Council picking a fight with Suffolk Libraries Trust is liking Donald Trump picking a fight with Canada – why would you do it?”
  • Could Suffolk Libraries decision be challenged at county? – Ipswich Star. “Both the official opposition – the Green Liberal Democrat and Independent group – and the Labour group on the council have asked the council’s monitoring officer to call in Tuesday’s decision.” … ““My group was appalled by the decision on Tuesday, and the treatment of the libraries staff, volunteers and Friends groups – it’s been heartless and I’m sure they felt absolutely wrung out by the end of the afternoon”
  • Despite public outcry, the Tories just grabbed Suffolk Libraries back from a successful not-for-profit – Canary. “the council’s financial prudence is under scrutiny. The sudden decision to terminate the contract with Suffolk Libraries, especially after the charity’s proven efficiency and community engagement, suggests a lack of strategic foresight. This move could result in increased costs and reduced services, undermining the very community-centric model that has been lauded nationally.​” … “Suffolk County Council’s decision to reclaim control of the library services appears ill-conceived and dismissive of the substantial progress made under Suffolk Libraries. The council must reconsider its stance, engage in meaningful dialogue with the charity, and prioritize the interests of the communities that have benefited immensely from the enriched library services over the past decade”
  • New chapter as libraries revert to council control – BBC Radio Suffolk. 3 minute radio article.
  • Opinion: Suffolk’s libraries now need to prepare for future – East Anglian Daily Times. Paywall. “In the end it wasn’t really a debate when Suffolk County Council’s cabinet came to decide on the future of the library service.”
  • Protests as library services taken back by council – BBC. “Bruce Leeke, chief executive of Suffolk Libraries, said its finances were “rigorously managed”. He said the council had “seen the finances every month” and asked: “Why has this suddenly become an issue?””
  • Suffolk County Council confirms decision to bring Library Services back In-House – Suffolk County Council. “The decision, made at the Cabinet meeting earlier today, will ensure continued access to high-quality, community-focused library services across the county.”
  • Suffolk County Council libraries takeover backed as formal challenge request launched – Suffolk News. “On Tuesday, members of Suffolk County Council’s cabinet voted on taking the library service in-house from June.” … “Several protests took place in the weeks leading up to the decision, reflecting the strength of feeling shared in a petition which reached close to 23,000 signatures.” … Councillor “accused Suffolk Libraries of trying to get the authority to ‘roll over’ and agree to its demands with an ‘unshakeable belief’ the charity was the only option.” … “Despite the approval, however, councillors from the opposing Labour and GLI Groups have both invoked the ‘call-in’ process to formally challenge the decision.”
  • Suffolk County Council makes its decision on libraries – East Anglian Daily Times. Minute-by-minute timeline of the debate and vote.
  • Suffolk Libraries responds to Suffolk County Council decision on library service – Suffolk Libraries. “We are all devastated that the achievements and hard work of our staff, volunteers and supporters over the past 12 and a half years, coupled with the amazing support we’ve had over the past three weeks have still not been enough to convince the county council to change its mind, or at least reconsider its proposal.”
  • Suffolk Libraries to hold two-day DiscoveReads book festival in Ipswich – Suffolk Libraries. “Suffolk Libraries is working in collaboration with Suffolk Archives and the University of Suffolk to hold an exciting two-day book festival at The Hold in Ipswich this May as part of its DiscoveReads book promotion for 2025. The festival will include writing workshops, archive rummages, a pop-up book shop and six author talks”
  • Why is Suffolk Council wrecking a successful library system? – East Anglian Bylines. “The local election due in May has been postponed by a year because reorganisation is expected to be imminent. So, a reasonable person might expect an organisation facing a gigantic upheaval would not start tinkering with a part of its service that is working well. A reasonable person would be wrong.”
• West Dunbartonshire – Residents asked to help West Dunbartonshire’s libraries – Reporter. “A consultation has been launched inviting the community to share their thoughts on accessing library services, activities, and priorities.”
• Wirral – All the libraries that could close in £25m cuts – Liverpool Echo. “CIPFA said the council’s programme to transform itself has not saved much money. The organisation said the council’s back office functions “are large, expensive and do not currently provide value for money” with “many staff with legacy or historic job titles that do not accurately describe their current roles.”” … “Council-run libraries still at risk of closure include Beechwood, Eastham, Greasby, Rock Ferry and Upton. Wirral Council has also been asked for clarification about the future of three partnership libraries in Leasowe, Seacombe, and St James.”
• York – Why Explore York Libraries are good for us & deserve support – York Press. “I truly believe that Explore York Libraries and Archives are a beacon of goodness. Our customers make up a wonderful community, and we are grateful for your support.” … “So, if the world ever feels overwhelming, come to Explore. Because in my experience, everyone on our team is good – and we hope to remind you that, even in difficult times, most people are good.”