Ian Anstice
Public librarian since 1994, user of public libraries since my first memories ... and a keen advocate of public libraries and chronicler of the UK public libraries scene. Library manager since 1998, winner of Information Professional of the Year 2011 and Winsford Customer Service "Oscar" 2012 and 2014, honorary CILIP fellow 2015, CILIP Wales Library Champion of the Year 2016.
Homepage: https://www.publiclibrariesnews.com
Posts by Ian Anstice
A Labour library mess-up and the police in libraries
Aug 24th
Editorial
You know where the parliamentary Labour Party has been when it comes to standing up for public libraries over the last year or so? Absolutely nowhere. And now we know why: the minister for libraries, Chi Onwurah, wanted to do something about it – indeed, did do a fair bit of research on it – but confusion as to who was doing what messed up the whole deal. I’ve emailed and tweeted Chi asking for the release of what research she has done as it would be such a shame to see such work going to waste.
Moving police, and traditional police jobs like lost-and-found forms, into libraries has also made the news. Councils, and police forces, see the co-operation as sensible one to deliver services at reduced costs. Meanwhile, others worry that a police presence in libraries spoils their neutrality and would deter some (no, not criminals, although presumably they won’t be impressed either, I mean some ethnic and religious groups) from using them. In practice, we’re all seeing such co-locations more and more often as cold financial reality makes bedfellows of more and more services that would once have been separate. There’s also advantages to a library for having, say, PCSO surgeries in the buildings. What’s needed, is a proper consideration of the impact before decisions are made.
Changes
- Angus – Police access offices integrating into libraries.
- Cornwall – Upton Cross Library to close.
- Isle of Wight – Mobile library stops reduced, £23,500 reduction.
- Norfolk – Libraries to assist with self-reporting forms for police e.g. lost and found items.
Ideas
- Storytellers without borders – collaboration with journalists and students.
- Summer reading challenge for adults
- Twitter emojis to publicise images
Fewer are Taking Part so let’s have a National Demonstration
Aug 21st
Editorial
I’ve just had a very sunny week in Norway hence this is a combined news summary for the period since August 10th. So it’s a big one. The main news is the reduction in library usage – from, roughly, one half to one third of the population – in the last decade. That’s quite a steep decline. Public library popularity have also reduced in other countries of course but from the figures I have seen the reductions in budgets and usage are less, offset by increased visitors for “non-traditional” services and a slower decline in traditional numbers because, well, the stock is still good and the maintenance and furniture budget means they’re still attractive places to go. It’s also not helped, of course, by a rampant misunderstanding of the purposes of public libraries by some free-market extremists in this country – step forward the Adam Smith Institute below – who are positively gleeful at the destruction of something whose value they cannot, or will not, understand.
I’m glad to see that there will be a national libraries (and museums and galleries) demonstration on 5th November, an easy date to remember, to heighten the awareness of what is being lost.
Changes
- Coventry – Arena Park Library to close on 27 August: some books to be used by charity in care home.
- Darlington – Legal case begins against cancel on grounds cuts to libraries came without sufficient consultation.
- Fife – Lundin Links, Pittenweem and Kinghorn to be passed to volunteers. 1 (out of 3) mobile libraries closed: stops now fortnightly, not weekly.
- Lincolnshire – Holby volunteer library to be moved into a Co-op shop/post office/pharmacy, with 4000 books.
- Northumberland – Morpeth Library floorspace cut by 75% and over half staff lost.
- Oxfordshire – 6 mobile libraries cut from September.
- Surrey – £250k cut: 7% opening hours cut, mainly by opening libraries later.
Ideas
- 1000 books before kindergarten
- “Digital Garage” training sessions.
- Equity crowdfunding – Use small percentage of materials budget to invest, make profit and improve community.
- Karaoke bar
Leading the way? Reading dogs in public libraries
Aug 10th
Editorial
There’s some great initiatives in public libraries around the world but one I always think we don’t see enough of in the UK is that of bringing in dogs to help children with reading. GLL mentioned that Lincolnshire libraries had a few reading dogs a week or two ago so I asked them for more information. The main story below is from them, followed by other links you may find useful. I’m aware Barnstaple also has reading dogs but does anyone else in the UK? If not, it’s worth asking yourselves if they’re possible – they do wonders getting reluctant readers into libraries, are great publicity and, frankly, the dogs are absolutely gorgeous.
Changes
Lincolnshire libraries and reading dogs
The quietest of times, the busiest of times
Aug 7th
Editorial
The Summer counts as the quiet season for library news but the busiest for public libraries on the ground. Tons of children coming to the desk asking for stickers and staff encouraging them to read more makes this the best time of year, with more events going on now than any other month. This post we have a report from Lincolnshire on what is going on there and I am sure it is being repeated elsewhere. Do send me your stories about the great things you have done as well.
Changes
- Brighton – Open+ extended to 8 libraries, which become “Libraries Extra”.
- Northern Ireland – £2m cut reduced by £225k to avoid cuts in opening hours.
- Vale of Glamorgan – Sully library now volunteer-run.
- York – New library to be part of Burnholme community hub.
The Big Friendly Read in Lincolnshire
A communist approach to libraries? It’s falling short.
Jul 31st
Editorial
Another mixed bag of news, with the continuing theme of councils – and proxy trusts – cutting down library services. It’s good to see Haringey bucking the trend with an upgraded library, though. And it’s clear that a few councils have either backed down in a couple of cases because of unforeseen (and, really, in 2016, there’s no excuse not to foresee it) public pressure or because they never intended to put in such deep cuts in the first place and want to be seen as listening to the electorate. The most interesting article I’ve read is that by Leon who points out that the new libraries minister is going to continue a hands-off approach, with an emphasis on facing further cuts to budgets by either alternative governance models (e.g trusts) or by replacing paid staff with volunteers. It will be up to campaigners to limit the damage inflicted to the service – which Frank Cottrell Boyce rightly lauds – anyway they can, with compromises sometimes being necessary.
I’m not sure if I have mentioned this before but I do find it ironic, almost amusing, that right-wing Government is pushing for people to no longer being paid for labour but rather to work free for the good of all. It’s also quite interesting to note that it’s often those in the most prosperous areas that are willing to do it. I’m not sure that many Conservative voters in Buckinghamshire realise that they’re inching closer to the Communist Manifesto by volunteering to keep their library open but it gives me a wry smile. Perhaps Lenin mentioned Austerity a lot in the 1920s too. Anyway, up the revolution, my Tory (and many Labour: although – double irony – fewer Corbynista) friends. I guess.
Take advantage of Love To Read
Jul 28th
Editorial
More details on the BBC “Love To Read” promotion ae emerging. The BBC tend not to do anything by halves, as I discovered when I was lucky enough to experience a children’s book promotion at the Library of Birmingham a couple of weeks ago, which featured hordes of people, Blue Peter and top league authors. So this is going to be a good thing for reading and, by extension, libraries. Take full advantage. Other than that, it’s fairly quiet today in the UK, with a reduction in hours in Shropshire and a move of library in Staffordshire. Abroad, the article on a “secret” Syraina library is the stand out, showing how – when it comes down to it – libraries are actually pretty essential to people’s lives, especially when they have so little else.
Changes
The first letter: New Libraries Minister speaks
Jul 26th
Editorial
The new libraries minister has spoken, showing an interest in the field and an awareness of the Taskforce, amongst other things. He points out that his interest in volunteering has a bearing in libraries, which will be seen as a bad omen by many (especially paid staff) but he does single out young volunteers, which suggests he’s thinking more in terms of Reading Hacks. It’s a good thing he has already had at least one meeting with public libraries people, anyway.
Ideas
Well, that’s not subtle: the new libraries minister is also minister for volunteers
Jul 24th
Editorial
Rather confusingly, there is a new libraries minister. It turns out that Matt Hancock, who has taken over most of the outgoing minister, Ed Vaizey’s, responsibilities, will not have the public library brief as well. That honour goes to Rob Wilson MP who, rather delightfully, is also an MP for Reading. Less happily, his other duties are all about boosting volunteers and non-profits. That may give a rather blatant pointer to where he will be standing on some of the key issues in libraries: it’s hard to see him coming out against increasing volunteers at the expense of paid staff in libraries when his other role is all about increasing them. In addition, his own constituency is seeing some fairly major cuts to libraries.
The big news, other than this, is the big reduction to libraries announced in Derby. Normally, before, the Central Library has been the branch most likely to be considered safe, with it being kept much the same as before while the poor branch libraries bear the brunt. Not so in Derby. There, it is specifically Central that will close, along with a massive 11 of the other 13, in order to cut costs. So that will keep a bare minimum of library provision in that city. But don’t expect out new libraries minister to protest: after all, most of those others will be going to volunteers.
Changes
- Blackpool – Charges increase.
- Derby – £468k cut. 12 out of 14 libraries under threat. Central to close. 11 other libraries may also close or be passed to volunteers: Allenton, Allestree, Blagreaves, Chaddesden, Chellaston, Derwent, Mackworth, Mickleover, Sinfin, Spondon and Springwood.
Ideas
Goodbye Ed Vaizey
Jul 18th
Editorial
So Ed Vaizey is no longer libraries minister. Readers of Public Libraries News will know what he has done, and what he hasn’t, for public libraries in the six years he has been in charge. Before being in power, he stridently called for interventions in libraries but when he was in power, he did not intervene effectively – other than nodding through deep cuts – in a single one. A nice enough chap, even charming I understand, he was perhaps constrained by his background, his ideology, notably that of localism and austerity, and by his colleagues in doing anything more. Certainly, the Sieghart Review and the Taskforce are welcome, although they However, claiming that libraries were thriving when they self-evidently were not and calling in question the number of closures and depth of cuts when the evidence was there was all to see was, I suspect, all him. Or is it? We will see with his replacement, who has already claimed on Twitter to be a supporter of libraries has a similar relationship with cold hard. politically uncomforable, facts.
In other news, I’ve been following news of Pokémon Go visits to libraries throughout the country and many library services have not been slow in taking advantage, at least in social media. That’s all great to see, as are all the wonderful pictures of children joining the Big Friendly Read.
Wifi, digital inclusion, NHS public libraries and a new Culture Secretary
Jul 14th
Editorial
A couple of useful reports on public libraries – one on wifi and one on digital inclusion – to have a read through in this post. Arts Council England have also announced that the procedure for libraries to apply for their grants will soon change. In addition, there’s the amazing news that a Friend’s group in Suffolk has raised £30k for its library. That’s a lot for a support group but, of course, small scale for a council but, if the council does not have any money … There’s also an interesting article about the NHS in Staffordshire (there’s more info here by the way).
Speaking of Staffs, the new Culture Secretary comes from around there and has had some dealing with libraries in the past, speaking warmly of coffee mornings and attending the transfer of Werrington Library to a wellbeing centre, staffed by volunteers, So, she has at least shown an interest but, unsurprisingly, is of the same camp as other Conservatives on the way forward for libraries in these difficult times. By the way, Ed Vaizey has, at time of writing, not been promoted (or demoted) as far as I can see but is now a member of the privy council so will now be called “The Right Honourable”.
Changes
- Suffolk – £30k refurbishment at Aldeburgh funded by Friends group.
- Worcestershire – Cuts in opening hours reduced from 78.5 hours per week to 55 hours per week, after consultation.



Recent Comments