If you tolerate this

428 libraries (337 buildings and 91 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

Can you help?

Everyone – Submit evidence/views to Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee on Library Closures before Thursday 12th January.
Surrey – Campaigners are looking for someone who qualifies for legal aid (owns less than £8000) in order to challenge council over library cuts.  Must be a Surrey resident.

News

  • Campaign for the Book Newsletter – Alan Gibbons.   Looks at the legal actions Glos/Somerset/Brent, closures, Liverpool cuts and National Libraries Day.
  • “If you tolerate this …”: Nicky Wire on library closures – Guardian (Music).  “Libraries were my band’s lifeline, writes Nicky Wire of the Manic Street Preachers. We must fight for them.” … “One of the most amazing things about public libraries remains their utter classlessness. You don’t have to have gone to Eton to make the most out of a library. They aren’t inhabited by the kind of people currently damning them.”

“It’s hard not to feel utterly despondent at the current plight of public libraries. Along with the NHS and the BBC, our libraries are some of the few truly remarkable British institutions left. So often absolutely ordinary in appearance, a good library should offer escape routes down the most extraordinary avenues, pathways into different worlds from the one you’ve left outside. Ridding our villages, towns and cities of libraries, which are essential in shaping a nation’s consciousness, seems like a direct attack on the soul of the country.”

  • Islwyn MP joins campaign to save libraries – South Wales Argus.  MP Chris Evans has joined other politicians in campaigning for Britain’s libraries to be preserved. They helped launch the All Party Parliamentary Group on Libraries (APPGL), which will seek to ensure that continued public sector cuts don’t devastate the provision.”
  • Library – Rainy Day Mum.  One of my goals for 2012 is that we make a regular visit to the library. This time last year our local library was under threat of closure – the county were going to close all but 3 or 4 of the libraries – we supported the “Save the library” campaign and attended the Book Start groups for Babies and Toddlers (J was between the two groups at the time), but funding was cut to let the libraries stay open and the toddler group was gone and for some reason we stopped going. Towards the end of the year we started again when I realised that we needed to add books to our collection, so we have decided to make it our goal each week to go and visit the library.”
  • Point of View: Why didn’t Harry Potter just use Google? – BBC.  Potter was written justg before the invention of Google. Internet has changed it all: “There is all too little danger of the knowledge currently accumulating in floods – multiply-owned, stored and captured – being lost. Rather, if we are going to make sense for posterity of today’s information-saturated present, one of the things we will have to learn to do is decide how to prune the evidence, and ultimately, what to forget.”
  • Universities collected £50m in library fines, figures show – Guardian.   “With fines as little as 10p for each day a book is overdue, it shows that students are returning thousands of books late each year. But many are never returned – more than 300,000 university library books remain unaccounted for.”

Changes 

Calderdale – 1 mobile to end, cuts in opening hours in “Brighouse, Elland, Hebden Bridge, King Cross, Sowerby Bridge and Todmorden from 45 to 37 hours a week.”.
Warrington 6/1/12 Grappenhall Library taken over by volunteers eight months after it was closed: group: Friends of Grappenhall Library. 

Local News

  • Bradford – Extended building would accommodate convenience store – Ilkley Gazette. Plan for Co-op store to open, with library.  “There has been a big response to the proposal from the community, including both letters of support for the development and a petition against the plans. The Co-op already has a store in a former newsagents premises on Station Road, Burley, but wants to move to bigger premises. There has been a big response to the proposal from the community, including both letters of support for the development and a petition against the plans. The Co-op already has a store in a former newsagents premises on Station Road, Burley, but wants to move to bigger premises.”
  • Brent – Update January 2012 – Save Kensal Rise Library.   “We may not be given leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in which case we will explore other options, and we have other options. We believe this community needs a library and that is the end we are pursuing.” … public meeting soon, “pop-up” library continuing, business plan for running library created.  Artist Jamie Reid has done poster for campaign, to be launched at start of February.
  • Brighton and Hove – An unsavoury morsel – Christopher Hawtree.   Conservative MP called Cllr Hawtree (a well-known library campaigner) the Dr Beeching of library services.  Cllr replies “I have urged a continuing, central place for public libraries despite the fact that Mr Weatherley’s own Government is imposing cuts of up to a third on Council budgets over the next few years.” … “What is proposed is to use the mobile library as a temporary one while the adjacent branch library in Woodingdean is rebuilt. For fifty years Woodingdean has had a temporary one but the new one will be twice the size. Pretty bloody good in these times.”.  Priority will be on bookfund.
  • Calderdale – “Drop new library and rescue all the others” – Halifax Courier.   “A total of 2,235 people responded to the latest council survey on opening hours and they were equally divided over whether there should be cuts to the six biggest branches.”

“What is the point of spending millions on a new library and archives in Halifax when other library services are being slashed?” said Coun Stout (Ind, Brighouse). “Of course there are some serious decisions to take about cutting costs but it is no good protecting Halifax to the exclusion of everywhere else,” he said.”

  • Dudley – Library to close while asbestos is removed – Stourbridge News.   ““Although it is unfortunate the library has to close for one week, it is necessary to ensure the asbestos can be removed safely. The housing office located on the ground floor of the library will, however, remain open as normal while the work is carried out.”
  • Hampshire – Cuts in services loom again – Gazette. A further 8% cut to all services, following a previous 8% cut last year.  Cuts of “£4.7m in libraries, museums and country parks.” … “Library opening hours have also been cut. The council is aiming to make the savings it needs to in two years instead of four as a result of the Government squeeze on spending.” [presumably to have extra boasting points while cutting services prematurely by two years? – Ed.]
  • Hertfordshire – County Council axe school library service – Advertiser 24.  “A plea to save the schools’ library service has been snubbed after the county council agreed to axe the resource aimed at boosting literacy among all children and young people throughout Herts.”.  Service cancelled because it was not making a profit. 
  • Liverpool – Letter from Council Leader – Liverpool Echo. “It is by being imaginative that we have brought forward proposals which will retain 85% of our libraries despite a cut in the budget of a quarter.” … “Cllr Kemp suggests placing libraries in schools. We have done this at West Derby and would have liked to do it with more schools as part of wave six of Building Schools for the Future, but unfortunately his government axed the scheme.”
  • Middlesbrough – Thousands sign petitions over Middlesbrough council cuts – BBC.   17000 signed peition against cuts.  “The planned closure of youth centres and libraries has also prompted about 800 letters to the borough council.”
  • Nottinghamshire – Kipper the Dog set for library opening – This is Nottingham.   “Improvements include a computer area with free wi-fi, dedicated children’s, local studies and professional gallery areas, a Discovery Room for courses and training, a new theatre space and thousands of books for all ages.”
  • Suffolk – Can you help with the future of Suffolk libraries? – Haverhill Echo.   “Community groups are being asked to nominate members to join an organisation being set up to run Suffolk’s libraries.”.. “Mr Fox said: “I’ve taken on this challenge because I believe it is the way forward for public services. To reflect local priorities, communities themselves must be fully engaged and sufficiently empowered to ensure the service delivers what they want. They must take responsibility for shaping their own destiny and making sure the services they receive are right for their communities and not just based on a single, ‘one size fits all’ solution.”
    • Board members sought for library enterprise – Bury Free Press.   “Letters went out this week to the county’s 44 libraries plus local groups who had expressed an interest in running them inviting nominations for the four other interim board positions, by January 22.”.  Will be in partnership with council.  “The IPS will be registered and appoint its interim board this month then, between February and May will apply for admission to the Local Government Pension Scheme and consult on and transfer employment responsibilities from the county.”
  • Warrington – Grappenhall villagers win campaign to take ownership of former council library – Warrington Guardian.   “A group of campaigners in Grappenhall have been handed the keys to the village library – nine months after it closed. The Friends of Grappenhall Library, a group of volunteers, won the right to take ownership of the building after the council closed it as part of budget cuts.” … “We already have a good mix of 3,500 books to fill the library from fiction to non-fiction and adult to children’s.” 
  • Worcestershire – New year timetable for Worcestershire mobile libraries  – Shuttle.   “Rural communities are being urged to make the most of Worcestershire County Council’s mobile library service, with a new year timetable available.”

Horror Section

Comment

Some further information (from the ever helpful LibraryWeb) about the cuts in Liverpool.  He has commented that there were around 50 staff lost last year so, along with the 76 losses announced yesterday, that means almost a full one half will be lost (126 of 260) will be lost since 2010.  That is one large cut  and it is hard, on the face of it, to see how the libraries can remain as “comprehensive and efficient” as they were two years ago.  Of course, given the current Secretary of State, legally it does not matter that the 1964 Public Libraries and Museums Act is in danger of being contravened – he’s not going to do anything about it.  However, it shows that the headline figure below of library closures is just a small part of the story.  Indeed, that “story” is beginning to resemble that often found in the Horror section, and not the ones with the impossibly handsome male/beautiful female vampires on the cover either.

428 libraries (337 buildings and 91 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

Can you help?

Everyone – Submit evidence/views to Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee on Library Closures before Thursday 12th January.
London – Attend a rally at Willesden Library, Brent on Saturday 7th January. 
Surrey – Campaigners are looking for someone who qualifies for legal aid (owns less than £8000) in order to challenge council over library cuts.  Must be a Surrey resident.

News

  • Are libraries a priority in a downturn? – BBC.   “Across the UK one in 10 libraries has been under threat of closure, more than 400 in all. Yet, London appears to have escaped relatively unscathed with just three councils definitely closing libraries, in Brent, Lewisham and Waltham Forest – 13 in total.”.   Hillingdon and Wandsworth (“”We’ve had expressions of interest from over 30 organisations around the world who run libraries in different ways so we’re exploring that as a way of enhancing the service and do it more cheaply.”) examined, as is Brent and York Gardens (Campaigner says”We did our own research to work out how residents used the library. We asked over 1,000 people and many used it for social and educational reasons but not to borrow books.”). News item likely also to be on BBC London programme this evening (Friday). 
  • Chicago Public Library lays off 176 employees, closes 75 branches on Mondays – Library Journal.  $6.7m cut to budget means cuts.  Council blames trade union for making situation worse.

“Vintage, an imprint of The Random House Group, and independent charity The Reading Agency are to work together in partnership to launch Stop What You’re Doing and Read This! – a passionate, funny, revelatory and inspiring book about the transformative power of reading – and The Reading Agency’s Mood-boosting Books campaign. The partnership kicks off with a public launch event at Canada Water Library on Monday 23 January at 7pm with authors Mark Haddon and Michael Rosen joining Miranda McKearney, Director of The Reading Agency and Debbie Hicks from The Reading Agency to discuss the paramount importance of reading to our quality of life.” (Press Release. see also Southwark events).

  • Libraries fuck yeah – Diary of a contrarian librarian.  Poem about benefits of libraries.  Readers need hardly be warned that there’s a lot of swearing in it.

    “I have loved the library ever since I was six years old and that school librarian placed my first library book in my hands. I have learned much there, and have had many great adventures. This is why I have chosen to be a librarian. I want to be able to help other people learn to love the library as I have. It is a magical place where anything is possible – even surviving a zombie apocalypse.” My Library Love AffairMynx Writes.

Changes

Lancashire – Brierfield Library £500k upgrade inc. more meeting rooms and Arts project.
 
Local News

  • Brent – Sat 7th Jan: Willesden Library Rally – Save Kensal Rise Library.   “There will be a rally outside Willesden library this Saturday from 11-1pm in order to raise awareness amongst the community of Willesden about their loss of facilities and building. Brent council are considering alternative locations for this Library whilst they close it for upgrades. The council are not considering Cricklewood Library or Kensal Rise library as alternative locations, despite the fact they are both currently available and are perfectly suited to being libraries. Apparently Cricklewood and Kensal Rise libraries are “too far away”.”
  • Croydon – Irresponsible Lambeth, apparently – Save Croydon Libraries Campaign.   “So when Cllr Arram speaks of acting in “such an irresponsible and damaging way” perhaps he should take a look at his own Council’s track record and actions. Croydon’s refusal to meet and the only options given to Lambeth which absolve Croydon of any responsibility for this library, used by its residents, seems far from responsible or constructive.”
  • Gloucestershire – Hopes for a win/win for Matson Library – Friends of Matson Library.  Details of meeting between campaigners and council (inc. new libraries chief) in preparation for new council plans for libraries after their legal defeat.  “Jo Grills, who has only recently taken up her new post will be visiting Matson next week to see Matson Library for herself and to meet other community groups ahead of the formal consultation in February. Rough Timetable Proposed Plan for Gloucestershire Libraries c. 13th January Countnty Council vote on proposals 20th January Six Week Consultation c. 1st February.”
    • FoGL members meet with GCCFoGL.   Council officers have met with FoGL twice.  “They explained to us the process behind the new library review which is taking place at the moment, and which is based on a needs analysis, demographic information on the various library catchment areas, and information obtained during the previous consultation process. The council is also in discussion with the Equalities and Human Rights Commission.”
  • Lancashire  – Pendle Library set for £500k facelift – Lancashire Telegraph.   Brierfield Library will be closed for 3 months for refurbishment inc meeting rooms and space for “In Situ” Arts project.  Lancashire Libraries have a £5m regeneration programme. 

“Unlike many other councils, we are not closing any of our libraries. In fact, we are continuing to invest in the service wherever we can. This will help to ensure that our libraries not only remain open but provide modern, flexible resources, fit for the 21st century. When Brierfield reopens in a few months’ time, local people will see an up-to-date, welcoming and accessible lib-rary the entire community can enjoy.”

  • Norfolk – Drunks, racial abuse and food fights: a year in the life of Norwich’s Millenium Library – EDP.  Staff at the city’s Millennium Library have had to deal with a racially-abusive man, teenagers throwing food and a girl punching another girl in the face. A security assistant also had his shins kicked in an unprovoked attack at closing time, according to the library’s staff logbook. A customer was banned for a month after he became abusive and threw a pencil when asked to stop drinking water in the heritage section. And a drunk woman started being “overly familiar” with staff, and another report describes how “unnecessarily loud moaning” could be heard from a man using a computer.” [An interesting insight into the darker side of library work: there’s a lot worse out there though – the cleaning up of human faeces, for example, is not unknown – Ed.].
  • North Yorkshire – Selby and Sherburn library hours cuts – Selby Times.    “Selby is earmarked to see its hours sliced from 52 to 40, losing Sunday opening completely, and Sherburn will see opening times reduced to 30 hours from the current 39. Barlby Library is pencilled in for closure, although the village’s parish council is currently preparing a business plan with a view to taking the service over and using the building as a combined library and community centre.”
  • Northern Ireland – Curtailing library hours unthinkableNews Letter.   “To restrict access to such information is unthinkable. At a time when we are seeking to ‘grow our economy’ in the ‘info’ sector, to restrict availability in the rural ‘remainder’ is nothing less than discriminatory.”
  • Somerset – Libraries to stay open, says High Court – This is Somerset.   “Library services in Somerset which were under threat from public spending cuts will be officially restored by Somerset County Council next week. But their future will still be the subject of an 18-month review of all council services to begin in April”.

Liverpool

Comment

The big news today is about Liverpool.  It’s losing three library buildings and a mobile library and more than a third of its library staff.  Opening hours are facing big cuts in many branches.  The news makes the leader page in both the Liverpool Echo and the Liverpool Daily Post.  Amazingly for a city famous for its left-leaning politics, the Echo suggests that given cuts of such magnitude, perhaps volunteers running libraries isn’t such a bad idea after all.  The Council has said that it would consider passing the closing branches (whose stock will be relocated into other council buildings) to community groups.  This news, and an annoucement from Torbay about cuts, adds five more onto the headline tally of libraries under threat.
Many thanks, incidentally, to you all for the emails about yesterday’s posting about donation boxes in libraries.  It turns out that, while Lincolnshire may be the first council-run libraries to have them, Luton’s libraries (part of the Luton Culture Trust) have had such boxes since 2008. 
Northamptonshire council’s libraries have no less than ten different donation packages for members of the public to support their service, ranging from £3 for providing a one-hour jobhunting session to no less than £450 for providing a term of weekly homework club sessions.  Northamptonshire have also placed four donation boxes in their branches in 2011 which have generated £150 “without any publicity”.  Their review document says:

“We know it is illegal under the Act to directly charge for book borrowing and is likely to continue to be so. However, there is significant opportunity to encourage donations, charge for added value services and attract more significant income from organisational donors.”

It is significant that councils feel the need to do this.  It is also interesting that Trust’s have been the ones taking the lead.  It cannot bode well for a comprehensive and efficient library service that councils are finding it necessary to ask its users for more money than that already provided by Council Tax.  On the other hand, at least Northamptonshire appear to be using the money largely for value-added services.  The challenge for librarians, and councils, is to ensure that this is done with the needs of the service in mind rather than that of the Finance Department.  Times are so hard, though, that all options need to be considered and seen to be considered.  Even, it seems, in Liverpool.

428 libraries (337 buildings and 91 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Challenging government cuts: library closures – Law Think.  “Challenging the substance of a cuts decision is difficult for two reasons. Firstly, one has to establish that in making the decision the local authority was either irrational or acting outside of the statutory provision which requires them to provide services. However, almost all such statutory provisions are broad, allowing discretion to the authority.” … “Secondly, challenging the substance of a cuts decision is difficult because the decision on spending is for the local authority and not the court. In the Brent case, Mrs Bailey “accepted that in these times of economic difficulties, economies have to be made and decisions are primarily for democratically elected local authorities”. The court only can ensure the decision was taken by a legal means.”

“With the cuts affecting public services all over the country, this is certainly far from the last decision on the issue. Many of the issues that arise in these cases are similar. However, as long as a local authority follows the correct procedure in making a cuts decision and keeps good records of how that decision was made, then can probably fend off any legal challenges to their decision.”

  • Demise of the Public Library – International Herald Tribune.   Writer felt proud of British public libraries when visiting Pakistan where they do not have any and often buy cheap pirated books instead.  “I had no idea then of the crisis facing British libraries. Over the last year or two, you’d have had to be living under several rocks not to notice.” Concentrates on the closures in Brent, highlighting the need for libraries to be local and free, continuing to provide free printed books and internet access to those who would otherwise not be able to access them.
  • Retro Library – Annoyed Librarian (USA).  “As the new book world order comes to pass, libraries can make themselves more attractive by obsessing less about the popular. Let’s face it,  the blather about libraries being the cornerstone of democracy and all that is a little hard to take when one of the biggest challenges is making bestselling novels available to library patrons. If the bestsellers aren’t freely available, democracy – such as it is –  will survive, or at least the absence of free bestsellers won’t be the cause of its demise.”  See also If libraries didn’t exist, would publishers be trying to kill book lending? (Tech Dirt).  “A familiar pattern emerges. Small, innovative publishers who are ready to adapt, reap the benefits by meeting the growing demand for ebooks at local libraries – and doubtless picking up knock-on sales as a result. Meanwhile, big, sclerotic publishers resist trying out new business models, preferring to make the use of digital formats for lending as “inconvenient” as possible – in the forlorn hope that readers will just give up and buy something. We all know how that story ends.”
  • Thoughts on library membership charges – Information Twist.   “Apart from  Central Government funding cuts, another reason local councils are having to save money is because Council Taxes were capped. This ensured local residents didn’t have to stick their hands in their pockets any deeper to pay for local services. Membership schemes like this mean that residents are still going to have that money taken out of their pockets anyway… If you have more money you’ll receive more library services. This is at odds with the ethos behind public libraries, which provides services for free because it’s recognised that some people can’t afford or don’t have access to these services/resources via any other means”
  • Times: Lawyer of the Week Daniel Carey acted for campaigners in case on cuts to library provision – Public Interest Lawyers.  “What were the main challenges in this case and the possible implications? Both councils paid lip service only to their equalities duties but the challenge was to ensure that an effective remedy was granted for this. Injunctions stopped the library closures from taking effect, allowing the judges to later quash the decisions outright. He said that it was important for the rule of law to do so.The case has implications for every local authority in the UK, which must now reappraise their planned cuts to library provision. Since the judgment, the Commons Culture Select committee is investigating the issue nationally.”
  • Windsor Public Library eliminates overdue fines in 2012 – CBC News (USA).   “”You don’t want to penalize people for reading. Sometimes you’re really into a novel and it takes you a little longer to get through it. As it happens, you return a book two or three days late. It’s not a big deal. We can get over that,” Maghnieh said. “It’s a way of really rewarding our patrons for using the library.”
  • Writer Maggie Gee vows to carry on libraries fight – London Evening Standard.  Regarding Brent. “The 63-year-old, who was the first female chair of the Royal Society of Literature and was short-listed for the 2003 Orange Prize for her seventh novel, The White Family, was awarded an OBE in the New Year Honours list.” … “Dr Gee said: “Libraries matter because they are the seedbed of literature. They are where people read our books, it’s where children find out they can read.”

Changes

Herefordshire – 20 communities have “expressed an interest” in running their own library.  Garway has new library in its village hall run by residents.
Liverpool 3 libraries (Edge Hill, Woolton, Great Homer Street) and mobile library service to close (or be taken over by community groups). 76 of 210 jobs (more than one-third of the total, including 27 managers and other senior staff) to go.  Opening hours reduced (inc. 12 libraries to be only open four days per week).  Closed libraries will have stock moved into other council services
Torbay – £170k cut (10% off £1.7m budget): possible loss of six posts, opening hour reductions, loss of one library, extra charges, encouraging book donations(Somewhat limited option) library consultation here. Group: Friends of Brixham Library, Friends of Paignton Library.   

Local News

  • Brent – Is a Rotten Borough 2011 – Preston Library Campaign.   Brent’s “Library Transformation Team” has won a Private Eye Rotten Borough Award for its work pushing the closure of half of the council’s libraries in the teeth of fierce local opposition. There’s a nice picture of the team, with its (presumed) leader, appropiately enough, holding a Kindle at the front, with some remarkably depressed looking team members behind.
  • Essex – Library fines to be chased by debt collection agency – BBC.   Called a “gentle nudge”.  “”To even be approached and warned this company might contact you, you would need to have at least four items out of the library for several weeks beyond their due date. You would have had two warnings as well to remind you to bring them back.” … “Unique Management Services (UMS) said it had recovered about $250m (£156m) in unpaid fines and lost items for libraries in North America, Australia, New Zealand and the UK since 1996.”
    • Will debt collection firm be worth taxpayer’s money? – This Is Total Essex.  “Where local authorities are facing significant cuts in funding from central government, any efforts to increase income should be welcomed. However, such initiatives need to be implemented properly, otherwise the promise of additional income will come to nothing. In this instance, only time will tell whether the money the council forks out on UMS will prove to be well spent.”
  • Herefordshire – Garway village library to host new library – BBC.  “It is being opened as part of Herefordshire Council’s Future Libraries project, being run in conjunction with Shropshire Council.”… “”Some 20 communities in the county have already expressed an interest in running their own library and we are working with them to see how the library service can support their plans by providing regular stocks of books and simple systems for them to track where any borrowed books are.”
  • Liverpool – Libraries in Liverpool to shut and jobs to go in restructure – BBC.   Cuts announced, will soon be formally agreed in council.  Cuts include library closures and opening hours cuts.
    • Time to turn the page on library cuts – Liverpool Daily Post (Leading Article).   “Whatever happens, we must hope this is an end to the cutbacks in this particular sector of the city’s activities. The service will take a huge hit, if these proposals are introduced – and so will the loyal clientele from all sections of the community who have patronised the city’s libraries for so many years.”
    • Three Liverpool libraries closed, 76 jobs lost and opening hours cut at 17 more as council makes £2.2m savings cuts – Liverpool Echo.  “The council said the libraries earmarked for closure require £3m investment it does not have to bring them up to standards required by the Disability Discrimination Act. It will hand the builings over to community groups to operate them on a voluntary basis if it can find groups willing to run them.”… “More than 4,000 people returned questionnaires and 71% of respondents preferred reducing opening hours to keep more libraries open.Only 19% supported libraries being run by a charitable trust, community group or social business.”
    • Libraries are vital to city – Liverpool Echo (Leader).   “But money does need to be saved and nettles grasped, which is perhaps why the idea of community organisations potentially becoming involved could be relevant. To many this might sound, perhaps uncomfortably, like the Big Society – but, in these tough times, if all else fails when it comes to saving libraries then perhaps the Big Society isn’t such a bad idea after all.”
    • Cuts to hit Liverpool library service – BookSeller.  “Libraries campaigner Desmond Clarke said he was in “no doubt” a campaign group would rise up in Liverpool to fight the closures as they had done in other areas across the country threatened with library caulaties, such as Somerset, Gloucestershire, Brent and the Isle of Wight. Clarke said: “The agenda is not being set by professionals or the government but by library protestors. The public is saying ‘we are not happy about libraries being closed’ and that is putting it in the spotlight.”

“There is much that can be done other than simply taking the axe to library services. For example, Westminster Council expects to reduce its operating costs by £1.1 million by merging its library service with those of two neighbouring authorities. We don’t need to have 151 separately managed authorities in England, a 50% increase in the number of authorities that existed just fifteen years ago! We can make better use of technology and improve further operational efficiency. And if we need to develop volunteer supported libraries, we must develop a workable model which ensures that the service is sustainable and can be supported by librarians. This is the time for imaginative solutions and making the optimum use of available resources to the benefit of those who rely upon public libraries. Fortunately, there are some councils that are doing just that.”

  • Somerset – Councillors say Somerset Library cuts should halt – BookSeller.  “Councillors have told Somerset County Council if it does not halt cuts to its library service it could be held in “contempt of court”.”
    • Library services to be reinstated – Yeovil Express.   “users in Somerset are celebrating after council officers recommended that all services which had faced the axe should be reinstated.” … pleased that the council will forget closures rathen than just try again.  ““Our library is a vital community facility. The idea that busy parents would be willing to drive or get the bus into Taunton to visit the library is unrealistic.””
    • Reprieve on the cards for Burnham-on-Sea and Highbridge Libraries – Burnham on Sea.com.  
  • South Ayrshire – Libraries leap into future – Ayrshire Post.   “South Ayrshire’s library team are now working on launching their very own app for smartphones in the early months of 2012.” … ““Times may have changed but people still want their libraries. And it’s not just about reading – you can go in and access computers and get any information you want from all around the world. Our libraries should always be a democracy and that’s the motto we work by.””
  • Suffolk – Your library: pain ahead? – Caroline’s Woodbridge page (Liberal Democrats).   Worries about the funding for libraries (only guaranteed for two years), reliance on volunteers.  The Council also seems to suffer from problems in keeping an open debate going.  “It was only opposition councillors who stood up and asked searching questions .  In reply, Cllr Terry directed extremely aggressive and insulting remarks at them.  Sadly, I have heard similarly rude and insulting remarks regularly at Suffolk County Council meetings -not only from Cllr Terry, but other Portfolio Holders too. Why doesn’t the Chairman intervene and stop such objectionable behaviour? “”
  • Torbay – Friends step up in fight to save library in face of funding cuts – This is South Devon.   “The local authority has told the library service across the Bay to make 10 per cent cuts to its £1.7million budget which would mean slashing about £170,000. The cut could lead to the loss of up to six library jobs, reduced opening days and some fear even the loss of one of the Bay’s four libraries. Opponents say the cuts could lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy of closures.”
  • Wandsworth – Opens the competition to save London’s libraries – Guardian Local Government Network.   “In Wandsworth our big idea is to look at competitively tendering our library and heritage service. We believe a new and competitive market of library service providers has emerged with the potential to improve delivery and reduce costs. If another organisation can do a better job, we will open the door.” … “If an external bid is successful then both councils will remain in control of their libraries. As with all outsourced services the contract specification will tightly define every aspect of delivery including opening hours, free access to books and free IT provision. All of the new ideas and improvements developed during the process will be written into the contract and closely monitored against clear performance targets.” … negative comments, highlighting danger of giving long-term contracts.
  • Westminster – One Stop services move into communities – Westminster Chronicle.  “New One Stop Express services are available at 19 locations, including all of the borough’s libraries, and give free access to the council’s website, allowing card payments, for example for council tax and parking permits, and providing more information about what is happening in the borough.”

Rent a mob

Comment

Some very interesting happenings at the start of the New Year:

  • Suffolk have been appointing the first board members for it’s new Industrial and Provident Society that will be taking over the running of libraries shortly.  They will all be chosen by the Council and so may thus be counted upon to agree with its views.  Certainly this seems to be the case with at least two of the members already appointed. The new Chair, for instance, is someone who has reportedly called library campaigners “rent a mob“.  The irony here is that, from another perspective, it appears that the Board itself may be in danger of fitting that same description.  There is no democracy in its makeup and certainly no voting in of its members.  Not the best of omens but we shall see what develops.  For other thoughts, see the previous post “Suffolk Enters the Unknown“. 
  • Surrey is facing the first steps of legal action against the converting of ten of its branches to being run by volunteers.  The campaigners behind the action, SLAM, are asking for funding.
  • Bexley is either starting a great new funding initiative or opening the thin end of the wedge to charging for library services.  Bexley Village Library will be run by a charity, with free basic membership but a £24 charge if one wants more loans or wants to avoid late charges.
  • Lincolnshire is installing donation boxes in its larger libraries.  This is the first I have been aware of this practice in the UK.

With developments like these, the reputedly Chinese curse “May you live in interesting times” springs to mind.

423 libraries (333 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

Best Campaigning Blog: Voices for the Library. For no other reason than being simply the best cause that I have ever had the pleasure of championing. Without my library I wouldn’t be here, writing this blog. I might not even be around at all. Love your libraries folks. Save them and cherish them.” Blog Awards, Stupidgirl

  • Biddy Fisher: Libraries need you as they adapt to a new age – Yorkshire Post.  Libraries can help people in time of austerity – free access to books/family history/internet.  Excellent article by recently honoured senior librarian including campaigning and use of volunteers.
  • Callow: My love of books is all down to a kind, cockney ladyLondon Evening Standard.  Simon Callow on donating books to library: “Callow said books play an “invaluable” role in society and that he was “deeply concerned” about cuts to library services and shocking levels of illiteracy.”
  • Cuts in education continue form libraries to outdoor centres – Guardian (Letters).   Letter from Alan Gibbons on the cuts to school libraries, 
  • Denby Dale biker Biddy Fisher honoured for library work with OBE – Huddersfield Daily Examiner.   “Biddy a former president of the Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals, has now been honoured for her services to libraries with an OBE from the Queen.”
  • Despair about public libraries in EnglandGood Library Blog.   “I can’t see anything more that can be done, The library service in England will collapse, slowly and painfully. Some people will be able to have ready access to an abundance of literature that they do not know about, as I did; and many people won’t. We won’t be a happier or better society- we won’t. And I hate to leave behind a problem unsolved – especially when I have found the solution – and yet failed to persuade people to listen to it. There are other things to do now.”
  • High Court ruling paves way for closing 600 libraries – World Socialist Web Site.  Reports Brent legal decision.  “The decision shows how Labour councils nationally are operating as de facto coalition partners with the government in enforcing austerity measures to meet the interests of the banks and super-rich. The role of the local government trade unions is to dissipate opposition and prevent a united offensive by council employees and working people against the cuts.”
  • Imperial age of libraries – Guardian.   CNN report police have raided 5 year old’s home in USA to get back overdue books.  Article remembers the days when librarians instilled fear. 
  • Pelham to hold library head’s job while he’s in jail – Eagle-Tribune (USA).  “The library director is heading to jail for six months, but his job will be waiting for him when he gets out. Robert Rice Jr., 46, was sentenced yesterday to six months behind bars for stealing more than $200,000 when he was the director of Revere Public Library.”.  Director jailed on eighteen counts having bought items using public funds then selling them for private gain.  This whole article should have exclamation marks after pretty much every sentence. The chair of trustees says “”His position will be held until he gets back,” Garboski said. “The decision is up to him when he wants to come back.”.  Only, one hopes, in America.

“Among the things Rice bought, allegedly for the library, were a 3-foot replica of a submachine gun, diving gear, a Leica camera, a Rolex watch, Red Sox baseballs, swords and armor. He is believed to have conducted more than 1,500 online auctions.”

Changes

Bexley Bexley Village Library will be run by charity “Greener Bexley” from Spring, with membership charge for “extra benefits”, library will be independent of council (who will supply one secondment and bookstock), saving £40k p.a..  Cafe in library, with free wifi (but charges for using computers), extra 9 opening hours. 
Calderdale – Central Library to be sold off to developers with new replacement library to be sited by Piece Hall with minimal public consultation.
Essex – US debt recovery agency to be used for people with library fines/late items
Lincolnshire Collection boxes for donations to be put in all libraries
Somerset – £600k self-service to cut staffing.  
Surrey – Legal action has started against the council’s plan to run ten branches with volunteers by SLAM.
Waltham Forest Libraries being merged with benefits/council tax/advice service, library jobs lost.  

Local News

“Libraries matter so much because they have books that everyone can read. “I came from a background that was not very literate so I want my work to be available for everyone. “Kensal Rise library matters to his community because it’s the heart of the community and everyone has worked so hard to keep it open. This is a community I love to live in and write about because it’s a community full of hope. “It’s not about little houses it’s about the things we share. Kensal Rise is on the rise.”” Dr Maggie Gee MBE

“All Soul’s College have rejected the view of Brent Council that the reverter has been triggered and have refused the transfer of the library sites at Cricklewood and Kensal Rise  back to them.Save Cricklewood Library has written to the Bursar of All Soul’s on this point thanking them.” Save Cricklewood Library newsletter.  [The College owns the two libraries but Brent Council could use the two buildings only if they were used for library services].

“Detractors of the public library service seem to assume that it’s all about issuing cheap thrillers and romances on a Saturday morning, overlooking the wealth of study support offered, particularly for minority interests. Public libraries provide a comprehensive and efficient service, despite decades of low investment for some. There is nothing you could do ‘on the cheap’ that could replace them,” read one comment.”

  • Hampshire – Fareham Library closes for refurbishment – BBC.   £130k for self-service, information point, £13k new stock, carpets, windows.
  • Lancashire – Library loans down by sixthLancashire Evening Post.   Quote is for Preston Library over three years. 
  • Lincolnshire – Stamford Library’s book fundraising scheme to expandRutland and Stamdford Mercury.  “Lincolnshire County Council installed a collection box in the foyer of the library in April, which we featured on our front page, to help pay for more books. It was part of a pilot to see if library users would be willing to support the library financially. So far, the box has been so successful it has raised £850, which has been used to buy more books.”
  • Northumberland – Libraries action plan working says report – Journal.   More books, online/phone reservations, improved computers, co-location with tourist information.  
  • Oxfordshire – Library protesters’ anger at council decisionGet Reading.   Sonning Common library campaigners not impressed by proposed imposition of volunteers into library.  Suggest council decision placing the branch in the band for volunteers was made on “misleading and inaccurate” information.  Decision to put branch in bottom tier depended on a very low estimate of population.
  • Scottish Borders – Library hours cut, despite user surge – Southern Reporter.  “Amid warnings that it could become an issue at next May’s local government elections, Scottish Borders Council has unanimously agreed to merge library and contact centre services in six towns. The move, which will cut library opening hours in Selkirk, Jedburgh, Coldstream and Duns and maintain the status quo in Innerleithen and Kelso, will save the council about £190,000 a year and bring in capital receipts from the potential sale of surplus buildings worth a further £259,000.” … “What councillors were not told, however, was that the total number of active members of the 12 static and six mobile libraries in the region has risen markedly over the last five years. A Freedom of Information response reveals that the number of active members, which stood at 16,741 in 2007-08, had increased to 21,709 in 2010-11.”
  • Somerset – Library cuts “should not go ahead” – Mercury.   Councillor report recommends libraries ot be kept open after court decision judging closures illegal.  Suggest £600k investment in self-service in order to cut back on staff. 
  • Suffolk – New library group’s board set up – EDP.  Chairman and some new board members of the Industrial and Provident Society that will run the 44 branches have been appointed.  The Chair is part of the group taking over control of Aldeburgh Library.  Members include ex Groundwork director,  a CILIP trustee [who has previously said “Some libraries will close in the future and “I am not personally averse to some libraries closing”.  I have closed fifteen myself.  We do have to change and deliver things differently. It’s going to be a tough decade.”], chief exec of Suffolk Association of Local Councils. 
    • Council invites community nominations for interim libraries board – Ipswich Spy.   Four vacancies still be filled.  ““The IPS is a pioneering model for delivering modern library services. It will be owned by its members and was chosen to give Suffolk people more say in the running of their local library and the county-wide service.”
    • Libraries interim board announced – BBC.
    • Interim board to run Suffolk Libraries announced James Hargrave’s Blog.  “I think Clive Fox will have an uphill struggle to get credibility amongst local library groups. When Suffolk County Council’s scrutiny committee met I personally heard him describe library campaigners as “rent a mob”. It looks likely that he will now be sat next to at least some of these people in Board Meetings….” … “Shona Bendix comes from SALC who are supposed to support local town and parish councils but during the library campaign SALC seemed to side more with the County Council than the town and parish authorities they were supposed to be supporting.”.  Blog points out none of the members will be elected – they will simply be appointed by the Council. 
    • New chapter for county’s libraries – EADT. 
  • Surrey – Campaigner begin legal battle over Surrey library cutsBookSeller.  “Public Interest Lawyers sent a pre-action protocol letter on 30th December to SCC c.e.o. David McNulty for the purposes of a judicial review. A statement posted on the SLAM campaigners’ website said: “We are challenging SCC’s decision-making process and their lack of scrutiny, both of which we believe to be inadequate and unlawful. We have taken this action with great reluctance, having exhausted all other means of trying to hold SCC to account over their library plans.”
    • SLAM initiates legal action against SCCSLAM.  “We have taken this action with great reluctance, having exhausted all other means of trying to hold SCC to account  over their library  plans. We have also become exasperated at SCC’s avoidance of any discussion or consultation with Surrey residents on the library plans, and also the Council’s increasing hostility towards legitimate protest (blocking SLAM’s emails, and witholding information in relation to Freedom of Information requests, to name just two examples).”  Appeal for funds for legal action also made.  
Surrey_SLAM SaveSurreyLibraries on Twitter: “Dear @edvaizey. Please, please intervene and put libraries on a firm footing before 2012 turns into one long legal battle to save them.”

Scrooge starves the shelves

423 libraries (333 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Library book is 123 years overdue with £4509 fine – Mirror.   One has to laugh at these articles, especially the bit with the notional “fine” that no authority would dream of charging and in a world where almost all authorities have maximum fines anyway.
  • LSSI gets its first contract in FloridaLibrary Journal.   “Under the terms of the five-year agreement, the county will pay LSSI just over $24 million; LSSI will collect $4.7 million the first year, and that amount will rise slightly over each of the following four years. The county will also spend from $580,000 to $670,000 annually on library costs not covered by the LSSI payments.”.  $6m cut in funding expected over five years due to deal. “According to the agreement, operation hours will “initially” remain unchanged. LSSI will offer positions—at the current base salary—to all current 76 library employees who must reapply for their positions, and compensation levels will remain unchanged for at least six months.”
  • Scrooge starves the shelvesIndependent (Boyd Tonkin).   “Against stiff competiton, this year’s prize for the most purely Scrooge-like behaviour among cost-cutting library authorities goes by acclamation to Redbridge council in east London. Via the Vision agency, a “charitable leisure trust” which now manages the borough’s libraries, the council made 15 library staff redundant on the Tuesday before Christmas.”
  • Six things that must happen to reverse this headlong rush to an illiterate British generation – An Awfully Big Blog Adventure.  The six things are (a) occupy libraries to protest, (b) stop closing libraries, (c) books should be cheaper, (d) ebooks should be much cheaper, (e) reading must be made cool, (f) be involved in advocacy work.

Changes

Nottinghamshire Mansfield Library: new building officially opened on Tuesday 3.1.12 after £3.4m refurbishment inc. wi-fi, local studies expansion etc.
Stoke on Trent Promised Blurton Library cancelled due to cuts

Local News

Police side with council as it empties the library. Brent takes advantage of the holiday shutdown to pre-empt any intervention from the Supreme Court, where an appeal was lodged two weeks ago. Campaigners expect the council to rush through the sale of the library in the coming months, depriving the area of its last local service.”

  • East Sussex – Staff celebrate 10th anniversary of library – Eastbourne Herald.  “Eastbourne MP Stephen Lloyd donated £100 to the celebrations to show how much he valued their efforts. He said, “It’s great to see that this community project is still going strong and providing a much needed service to the people of Old Town for almost 10 years.””
  • Hertfordshire – North Herts library group bids to prove service worth – Comet.  “The We Heart Libraries group, which was founded this year, has a number of activities lined up for the first ever National Libraries Day … users to sign up to one of several pledges, such as borrowing a book a month, signing their children up for library cards of visiting a new branch.”.  Group unhappy with closure of school library service and renting out of libraries to voluntary groups in times when branches were previously open.

“We need to make sure that they’re not taken for granted so that, when the council needs to find cuts, it doesn’t turn to them first. For this reason, we are really hoping that as many people as possible will help us shout about them and make National Libraries Day a success in North Herts and Stevenage.”

Police hold back protesters while library cleared

Comment

“Please encourage individuals, as well as campaign groups, to write to the Select Committee before 12th January describing the impact that library closures have on residents and communities.  The committee needs to hear from library users and not just the voices of council chiefs and DCMS bureaucrats. It is often the personal experiences of individual library users, young or old, which resonates most with members of the Committee. The Committee also needs to hear the experiences of campaign groups in dealing with their Council, the DCMS and the MLA in trying to get their voices heard and their concerns addressed.” Desmond Clarke, veteran library campaigner.
Details on how to write to the Select Committee are available on this webpage.  See also this previous post for some of my thoughts on the subject.  If you’re reading Public Libraries News then you care about libraries and want the best for them – and this may be the most significant thing you can do to help safeguard them in 2012. 
423 libraries (333 buildings and 90 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.
 

News

  • Library vs. the mobile – Christopher Fowler’s Blog.   “Louise Robinson, the new president of the Girls’ Schools Association, says that smartphones and tablets are about to take over from reading books, partly because children will be able to access information more easily in their spare time.” … “a danger that anything on the printed page will be regarded with the horror the young have of the old or old-fashioned. There’s nothing as conservative as a young mind, and books could easily end up relegated to Oxfam shops and old folks’ homes.”

Changes

Local News

  • Bolton – Council leader warns further cuts may comeBolton News.  Reading between the lines, it looks like the Council may be considering further cuts to a library service that is already closing five out of fifteen branches. 
  • Brent – Campaigners held back by police as Preston Library is clearedHarrow Observer.  Protesters who have fought tooth and nail in a bid to save 50 per cent of Brent’s libraries are being held back by police today as council workers begin clearing books. Around ten members of the Brent SOS campaign group are gathered outside Preston Library and have no choice but to stand and watch as staff begin emptying the building.”.  Seven police on scene.  Campaigners say library should be kept as is due to moves being made to appeal to Supreme Court.  Also in Willesden and Wembley Observer.

“We are trying to obstruct the way but the police are moving us. I feel that Brent Council is showing contempt to the legal process and the community who have shown how much they need their local library by doing this.”

    • Police protect Council as it seizes library stock – GreenFeed.   “The following was posted by Jessica Thompson of the Willesden and Wembley Observer at 11am this morning. When I visited the library this afternoon there was no one outside and the gate in the hoardings was closed.”
    • Preston Library cleared – BookSeller.   “Library campaigners on watch outside Brent’s Preston Library cried “Shame on you” as books and computers were cleared from the building by council workers today (29th December), with police in attendance. Vans arrived at 9.30am to begin clearing the library of its contents. Local campaigners had been on intermittent vigil outside the library building over the Christmas holiday, with a Christmas tree on display decorated with children’s book characters.”
  • Camden – Surviving library cuts: volunteer’s bids accepted, but now the hard part!Camden New Journal.  “Town Hall has confirmed bids have been accepted to run three libraries – Chalk Farm, Belsize and Heath – which the council can no longer afford to operate. The groups involved now have until April to finalise their plans. But to make ends meet, branches are looking at innovative ways to raise funds – prompting fears that the core library services of book-borrowing and providing a place to read and work will fall by the wayside.” … ” the council will gift the branches around £250,000 worth of books, chairs and desks. Including transitional support, the cost in total of the handover is estimated at around £300,000″
  • Central Bedfordshire – Have your say on future of libraries – Comet.   “… three weeks left to have their say on the future of libraries in Central Bedfordshire through a public consultation.”.. ““The aim of the Future of Libraries consultation is to help improve the services which libraries currently offer, making them modern and even more accessible to the community.”
  • Gloucestershire – Painswick group plans to run a community library – BBC.   Painswick Library closed in 2009, room in Town Hall may be used for library if funding won from council.  Organiser says “My wife and I do extensive amounts of reading and also we are involved in a number of activities where it has become quite apparent that having a library in the community is of very great importance to older people and particularly to families with children.” The chairman of Painswick Parish Council, Terry Parker, said there had been quite a lot of reaction to the closure of the previous library and as to why the listed building had not been better maintained.”
  • Scottish Borders – Libraries merger approvedBerwickshire News.   ““This is not primarily a cost-cutting exercise. However, by bringing libraries and contact centre services together we can secure savings and retain the full range of services delivered from library and contact centres to ensure that both stay locally available. The Library and Information Service restructure will modernise the service and result in the development and improvement of both the quality and range of services offered to the public.”
  • Somerset – Garfield’s big effort to save the libraries – This is Somerset.   “… without a doubt, the biggest – and most successful – campaign this year was the one to save Shepton Mallet library.” …  Cllr Kennedy was one of the campaigners behind a pro-libraries video including Julian Fellows and Michael Eavis: “The film We Love Libraries became, on Love our Libraries Day throughout the UK, the most shared video in YouTube’s non-profit video category section.” … “So for all his work helping save the libraries the campaigner of the year award must go to Councillor Garfield Kennedy.”

No commitment to do anything

Comment

 

A North Yorkshire MP asks Ed Vaizey, minister for libraries: “… will the Minister intervene to assist with at least a part-time library presence from North Yorkshire county council to enable it to put a business plan in place in the interim?”. Mr Vaizey responded: “I would always encourage any local authority to work with the community on the provision of community libraries and to provide support of a professional librarian [sic] behind the library service.”” 
This is typical Ed Vaizey in that it looks good but contains no commitment to do anything.  It is worryingly new, though, that Ed has toned down his previous stated support for paid staff to a position where he appears to be wanting just one somewhere in the organisation.  Even then, he is limiting himself to a vague desire to “encourage”.
No surprises there.  Library supporters have looked for help from the Ministry throughout 2011 only to be completely rebuffed, sent form letters (sometimes even with the incorrect wording left over from the previous reply) or been met by note-taking officials but ultimately with no action forthcoming.   It seems unlikely that Mr Vaizey and his boss Mr Hunt will change their tune in 2012 without being forced to.  They are, after all, part of the Government who believes in a hands-off policy to local government of the like that worked so well in the City of London.  It also allows them to shift the blame of the effects of the historically high level of centrally imposed cuts onto local councils.  
The only thing that will change their minds is if the Select Committee on Library Closures comes down with sufficient force against them, although even there, the Committee is only advisory or is ignored.  The Courts may also somehow force them to intervene.  However, of course, this is the nub of the problem.  The Courts have said that it is up to the Secretary of State to intervene but the ministers do nothing … and library services continue to be savagely cut.   
Something must change in 2012 or it will be more of the same (closing down the library) business as usual.

415 libraries (323 buildings and 92 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Big Society“You and Yours” BBC Radio Four.  An hour examining the push towards volunteering in local services, which has had great implications for public libraries.  Lewisham libraries are mentioned (5.50 for a couple of minutes). Professional trained library staff are being removed there, being “dumbed down” and staffed by volunteers.  People are not going into profession as they don’t see a future in it, retired staff are volunteering and thus removing the need for staff.  Agreed that an open volunteer library is better than no library at all.  £400m from dormant bank accounts to be used to fund Big Society bank.  A good strong and relatively neutral look at the subject, including aspects from all sorts of areas.
  • Careers service and literacy hit by schools funding cuts – Guardian.   Does not mention school libraries, strangely, but does include details of other cuts.
  • In praise of public libraries, and librarians – What’s Next: Top Trends.  “Whether or not we will want libraries in the future I cannot say, but I can categorically state we will need them, because libraries aren’t just about the books they contain. Moreover, it is a big mistake, in my view, to confuse the future of books or publishing with the future of public libraries. They are not the same thing.”

“There is a considerable amount of discussion at the moment about obesity. The idea that we should watch what we eat or we will end up prematurely dead. But where is the debate about the quality of what and where we read or write? Surely what we put inside our heads – where we create or consume information – is just as important as what we put inside our mouths.”

  • Ministers under fire for campaigning against the cuts – Telegraph.  “Sarah Teather has been applying pressure to save several local libraries in Brent, writing to the Culture, Media and Sport Secretary to ask him to “intervene and instigate an inquiry into the closures”. Her spokesman said it was “perfectly within her rights to criticise the council for making a decision to restructure to libraries which she feels will provide a significantly poorer service to local residents.” Meanwhile, Jeremy Browne has also campaigned to keep local libraries open and launched an attack on cuts to recycling services in his Taunton constituency. On his website, he criticises said “the long term consequences of the Conservative Council’s cut in funding.” He defended his stance by saying Britain has to tackle its economic problems but he still wants to see “money spent efficiently on valued local services in Taunton Deane and elsewhere.””
  • Publishers versus libraries: an e-book tug of war – New York Times (USA).  Library ebook lending is “…a source of great worry for publishers. In their eyes, borrowing an e-book from a library has been too easy. Worried that people will click to borrow an e-book from a library rather than click to buy it, almost all major publishers in the United States now block libraries’ access to the e-book form of either all of their titles or their most recently published ones.”

Changes

Brighton and Hove – £150k budget cut 2011/12, mobile library to close.  
Gloucestershire – Moreton Library to reopen in April 2012 incorporating volunteer services/registration/police/self-service.
Milton Keynes – Consultation ongoing.
North Yorkshire – Hunmanby library to close due to failure to gain enough volunteers/retain funding: library services likely to be moved into community centre or be served by a mobile library.
Oxfordshire Police offices now in Deddington Library.
Slough – Britwell Library to move into new upgraded building,  Central Library to move into new “flagship” building, Chalvey and Colnbrook to have new libraries based in children’s centres, new library planned for Wrexham Lea.  22% increase in opening hours 2008 to 2010.  Service run by Essex on behalf of Slough.
Warwickshire – Bulkington Library to be run by volunteers “in weeks” (28.12.11). 
Worcestershire Co-location increasing: Stourport Library to be moved into Civic Centre after three months consultation, Bewdley Library may move into town’s museum, Kidderminster Library may have other services using its space.

Local News 

  • Bolton – Fight to save libraries is taken to topThis is Lancashire.  “Save Bolton Libraries Campaign has submitted a weighty dossier of evidence to Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt urging him to intervene in the town’s library closure row.” Council says ““We have been in constant contact with the Department for Culture, Media and Sport throughout our review and kept them up to date with our progress.””
  • Bradford – Addingham Library volunteers want to hear your ideas – Ilkley Gazette.  “Villagers quickly got together to form a charitable association to manage and staff the library for the benefit of the community, still making use of some library services provided by the district authority. The day-to-day running of the library has proved a success so far, and the association feels it is time to look at how services and facilities could move forward.”
  • Brent – Council blew £15,000 on awards ceremony which honoured library closure team – Preston Library Campaign.  “The night cost taxpayers around £50 for every person who attended, the council said. The Libraries Transformation Team, which was behind the project which closed half of the borough’s libraries, was named Team of the Year.”…”The council’s chief executive, Gareth Daniel, said: “The awards provide a fantastic boost to staff morale in what are very challenging times for everyone working in local government.”
  • Brighton and Hove – Fines not paid at Sussex libraries – Argus. In this month’s budget announcement, the Green party proposed saving £150,000 over the next year by reducing library opening hours and scrapping the mobile library.”
  • Derbyshire – How libraries help bring race hate to book – Buxton Advertiser.   “Libraries in Derbyshire are offering the charity Stop Hate UK telephone and computer services to victims of hate crime by providing an alternative place where a victim, or someone concerned about a victim, can report hate crime incidents without having to speak directly with police. The service is victim led and library staff can help discuss the options with those wanting to report a hate crime, and can support them in which option they take.”

““Victims may find it easier and more comfortable reporting hate incidents at their local library, which can offer a supportive and confidential environment. This means that the police can take action and help stop offenders from getting away with crimes which may previously have not been reported.””

“… unprecedented uproar across Oxfordshire.”

    • New crime section opens at Deddington Library – Banbury Guardian.   Policing team has moved into library, with its former office closed. ” “Having the police within the library is a fantastic step forward for the community. In the past, going into the police station could be quite daunting but the library is a much more inviting place to go and puts them in a much more prominent position.” A community engagement service point (CESP), manned by volunteers, will be set up inside the library itself.”
  • Slough – Opening, not closing, local libraries – Slough Labour.   Britwell Library will move into new refurbished building (more self-service, meeting space). Central Library will move into new “flagship” building (more meeting space, adult learning, theatre, cafe).  Chalvey (to be in community hub with children’s centre), Colnbrook (to be in children’s centre) and Wrexham Lea may have new libraries. 

“Libraries have featured heavily in Labour manifesto’s in 2008 and 2010, resulting in a 22% increase in opening hours across the town’s libraries. As part of the partnership between Slough Borough Council and Essex County Council the service will undergo continuing investment and improvement to deliver the service that residents have told us they would like.”

Expensive to run?

414 libraries (323 buildings and 91 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

News

  • Actor boosts library campaign – BBC.  Actor Simon Callow has donated almost 1,000 of his own books – including hundreds of specialist performing arts titles – to London’s Westminster Reference Library.He told the BBC he intends to highlight the importance of libraries in the community in the context of many facing closure.”.  Westminster Libraries boss says all will stay open.
  • Are UK public libraries expensive to run? – Wordshore.   One of the best analyses of how expensive public libraries actually are for the country, now updated for 2012.
  • Great Britons 2011 – Independent on Sunday.  One of the fifty are the Brent library campaigners.  “Residents fighting the closure of six libraries in the London borough of Brent represented the outrage felt by much of the nation’s readers and researchers about cutbacks by staging a round-the-clock protest outside Kensal Rise Library, which was opened by American writer Mark Twain 111 years ago. The campaigners were the first in the country to seek a judicial review into library closures.”
  • Independent voices of 2011: The most influential non-celebrity users of Twitter – Independent.  Voices for the Library is given an honourable mention, with over 2800 followers with a high trust rating.
    • Thank you to all of our supportersVoices for the Library.  “When we first started up in August last year we never imagined that we would have such an impact.  We are all volunteers who spare whatever time we can to keep the campaign going by highlighting both the cuts to libraries across the UK as well as the value of libraries and librarians.” 
  • Prologue to the Living Library – Open Writing.   “Last summer, writer and researcher Nilam Ashra-McGrath (www.nilamashramcgrath.co.uk) completed a writing-residency at Huddersfield Library, UK, and is now writing a non-fiction book about her experiences. The book will be out in 2012, and you can read the prologue here”.  Excellent article lists and describes what libraries offer and why they are different to other outlets.

“If you were asked to name an institution that expects nothing from you, but gives you the most in return, you would have to name your local public library. No other public service institution is subject to such praise and abuse in equal measure, and no other institution is currently in such jeopardy.”

  • Shelf life in hard times: The book folk who wrote glorious chapters in 2012 – Independent.   Brent, Gloucestershire and Somerset campaigners are one of the six examples.  “Lords Justice Pill, Richards and Davis this week shamefully upheld the High Court decision, which they felt had been made only after a “most careful and thorough review of all the points advanced” which contrasts with the victory in Glos/Somerset.  “As this newspaper noted, Brent’s plans are “vandalism on a worse scale than the riots”. But the official vandals in Brent and elsewhere will not, however, be hunted down and sent to jail.”

Changes

Calderdale £65,000 cut in bookfund
Gloucestershire Friends of Matson Library.  
Hull – New co-located library expected in Newland Road expected after closure of one on Beverley Road
Redbridge 13 staff, including senior and long-serving, made redundant five days before Christmas 2011.  “Vision expects a “noticeably reduced” library service from April, although all 13 borough libraries and the mobile library will stay open.”
Surrey Hersham Library not be included in volunteer takeover pilot.
Waltham ForestPlans to relocate Wood Street Library and sell off land for housing put on display without publicity just for Christmas period until 3rd January 2012.   

Local News

  • Brent – Library campaigners keep their spirits up by holding festive carol concerts – London 24.   “Sadly, the only Christmas present that is being bestowed on this diverse community from Brent Council is parking ticket machines which will be effective from the New Year.” … “At Cricklewood Library, opera singers entertained the community outside a new-pop-up library set up to replace the old reading room in Olive Road.”
  • Calderdale – Freedom of Information request – What Do They Know.   Details on book fund.
  • Camden – Groups get keys to run three libraries – Camden New Journal.  “The Winch commun­ity centre will be handed the keys to Belsize, in Antrim Grove; Chalk Farm in Sharpleshall Street will be run by a co-operative made up of the Friends of Chalk Farm Library and the Primrose Hill Commun­ity Association; while the Heath Library in Keats Grove will be run by the  newly formed Phoenix Group, made up of the Heath and Hampstead Society, The South End Green Association and then Friends of Heath Library.”.  Council says “We were determined to minimise disruption to the library service and make the best of a bad situation. The impressive bids we’ve received have shown how residents are willing to step up and help run their well-loved libraries.””
  • Doncaster – Freedom of Information request – What Do They Know.   Arts Council England report that they have no records on Doncaster but does not mention any records inherited from MLA.
  • Gloucestershire – FoGL and GCC in conversation at last – Friends of Matson Library.   “Friends of Gloucesteshire LIbraries (John, Johanna, and Demelza) met with Jo Grills and Duncan Jordan who are the civil servants overseeing the new ‘meeting the challenge’ (if it’s still called that) of reshaping library service. Demelza writes that “they seemed to take many of our comments on board and took copious notes”. I have to say that Antonia Noble also took copious notes last time around so the proof, as ever, will be in the pudding. ” … “It is also worth knowing that on Saturday Richard Graham MP approached one of the board members of Together in Matson (TIM) to ask if the board were ‘disappointed’ in not having the community-run library in the Redwell Centre. He would like to be able to tell people that but no statement has come from the board of TIM.”
    • Friends of Gloucestershire’s Libraries’ first birthday: the story so far – FoGL.   Summary of an amazing campaigning year for FoGL, from it’s beginnings in Cheltenham Library to a 10,000 petition to legal action/victory.  “I would like to use this ‘birthday’ to say a heartfelt thanks to everyone who has joined with us, campaigned with and supported us on the journey so far. We hope you stick around for the next stage of the fight and new Friends of our libraries are always welcome too – our libraries are too important to lose!
    • Have your say on county council spending – This is Gloucestershire.  We’re not planning dramatic cuts. Most of the pain will have come last year. There will be reductions to certain budgets, but nothing like with the libraries and youth service last year.”.  Comments describe questionnaire as biased with loaded questions and suspect the council will ignore any inconvenient results anyway.
  • Hull – Novel idea to get an Avenue library – This is Hull and East Riding.  “”The council has the former Newland School in the street, but a shop front would be far more accessible to the public.”
  • Northern Ireland – Decision on library hours cuts deferred – Belfast Telegraph.   7000 questionnaires and 500 other correspondance has been received.  Decision to be made in January 2012.  

“We have been overwhelmed by the level of response and it is clear our customers value both the role that libraries play in local communities and the importance of ensuring that opening hours are such that people can access the wide range of services available when they need them most.”

  • Redbridge – 15 Redbridge library staff to lose their jobs – Ilford Recorder.   “The employees, including senior community librarians, were informed of the outcome of a redundancy procedure on Tuesday, just five days before Christmas.”.  Vision Trust decide to sack library staff than other services, having taken over responsibility for libraries earlier this year.  Some staff have worked for service for 20 years or more.  “The Recorder understands Vision expects a “noticeably reduced” library service from April, although all 13 borough libraries and the mobile library will stay open.”
  • Surrey – Community partnership reprieve for Hersham Library – Elmbridge Today.   “At the time, they also agreed to consider nine other libraries – including Hersham’s – for inclusion within the community partnership scheme once the pilot has been in existence for a full year from April 1, 2012 and an evaluation of its success has taken place. At a cabinet meeting held on Tuesday (December 20), however, the second phase of the project was shelved.”
  • Waltham Forest – New housing and library “relocation” proposed – Guardian series.    Wood Street Library‘s premises could be sold off, with the library moved to somewhere else unspecified.   Plans have been put on display, without publicity, at start of Christmas period about the development and will be taken down on January 3rd: “…critics have questioned the timing of the plans going on display, while others fear further cuts to the library service”
  • Wiltshire – Libraries in Wiltshire kept open by volunteers – BBC.   “Wiltshire Council planned to close 10 of the county’s smallest libraries to save money, but enough volunteers came forward to keep them all open.”.  300 volunteers being used.
  • Worcestershire – Libraries and learning in Worcestershire praised by Ofsted – Worcestershire County Council.   “The Libraries and Learning team which provides courses for adult learners throughout Worcestershire has been praised for both the high quality of courses available and for providing value for money in a report released by Ofsted this week”

True libraries

414 libraries (323 buildings and 91 mobiles) currently under threat or closed/left council control since 1/4/11 out of c.4612 in the UK, complete list below. Librarian professional body CILIP forecasts 600 libraries are under threat (inc. 20% of English libraries).  The Public Libraries News figure is obtained from counting up all reports about public libraries in the media each day.

See also “Special Report: A vision for a 21st Century Library?” post below.

News

  • Corporate profile: LSSI – Canadian Union of Public Employees. The most comprehensive report yet noted on the private libraries company LSSI.    Although an obviously biased source, the document provides much useful information and confirms the accusations of many that LSSI reduces staff costs.  Interesting piece on its political donations too.
  • Happy ending predicted – Courier.   “Goole and Brigg MP Andrew Percy proved the future of libraries was no laughing matter when he joined comedian and best selling author Tony Hawks and Libraries minister Ed Vaizey at the launch of the new Libraries Group in the Houses of Parliament. The Libraries All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) was launched in the House of Commons with Andrew as the group’s Vice Chairman.”

    “Most contact for assessing an initial inquiry is currently face-to-face. I have not followed why, if someone accesses, say, a CAB, law centre or public library, the initial face-to-face inquiry that has already taken place cannot then be referred for another face-to-face discussion.” Lord Shipley in House of Lords debate on the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill via They Work For You.

    • Library campaigners hunt the Secretary of StateSpectator.  The battle in Brent is symbolic because it is the most prominent in the country — defeat for Brent is a defeat for library campaigners in general. The Brent team has renewed its calls for the secretary of state, Jeremy Hunt, to intervene under the 1964 Public Libraries and Museums Act: an indication that it might not pursue further costly legal action, although leave to appeal to the Supreme Court may yet be sought.” … “…there is little point in having statutory duties if they are not applied.”

    “The Department for Culture, Media and Sport is thought to be wary of intervention for fear of contradicting the government’s decentralisation agenda.  The government insists that it does not need to use its statutory powers because local cuts are an exclusive competence of councils under the 2011 Localism Act. It says that there are alternatives to library closures; and it has branded those councils that are substantially reducing services as ‘politically motivated’. ”

    • Love Libraries badges – Love Libraries.  Get your groovy buttons and magnets saying “love libraries” for some serious campaigning action in 2012.  
    • National Libraries Day official website – The site has now been launched, including a map of events, ideas, logos, links [great to see Voices for the Libraries at number one and Public Libraries News at number two – thanks NLD team! – Ed.], social media options, quotes and testimonials from supporters, a forum, news.
    • New shadow libraries minister condemns closures – BookSeller.  “Recently appointed shadow libraries minister Dan Jarvis has condemned “mindless closures” of libraries and said that now more than ever is the time to harness the opportunities libraries offer and use them as “ladders of social mobility and personal development”.  Jarvis’ words come as an open letter criticising culture minister Ed Vaizey’s inaction over closures, signed by many prominent authors, was delivered to the minister by the Friends of Gloucester Libraries campaign group.”
    • North Yorkshire/Doncaster/Leeds/Wakefield – Yorkshire Library volunteers prepare New Year takeover – Look North BBC (Video).  “Hundreds of volunteers are preparing to take over libraries across Yorkshire in the New Year as councils continue to make tens of millions of pounds of cuts. Some libraries have already closed, while dozens of others will only survive if local residents come forward to run them. Unpaid volunteers and charity groups in places like Denby Dale and Rawdon in West Yorkshire and Bawtry in South Yorkshire are now being trained to take charge.”
    • Open Letter attracts 456 signatures – Alan Gibbons.   “The letter expresses library users’ shared dissatisfaction with Mr Vaizey’s execution of his duties to superintend public library services, in the face of closures and service reductions of an unprecedented scale nationwide”. Very impressive list of signers.
    • Things to cut before closing libraries –  A whole humorous website on the issue.  So far, Big Society “experiments”, professional portraits of councillors, councillor expenses and County Halls.  You know the situation is bad when there’s a website on this…
    • Unhappy feet – BookSeller.  Examines the depressed usage figures for Lewisham’s withdrawn libraries.  “I would be the first to say that the quality of a library service should not be assessed solely on the number of books issued. But a decrease of this magnitude indicates that community management of public libraries simply does not work. It may be too early to judge the success of this experiment, but it looks like the good people of Lewisham have voted—with their feet.” … ” public libraries must stay democratically accountable, publicly funded and free at the point of need.”

    “I agree with the comments made by Patricia Richardson. I am a Lewisham resident and have visited three of the “community” lbraries. Like has in no sense been replaces by like either regarding stock or quality of advice. I do not regard such facilities as true libraries. I was shocked to see the statistics.”

    Changes

    Caerphilly Blackwood library opens again after £215k upgrade.  
    Gloucestershire – Redundancy payments for staff in 2011 cost £1 million.
    Surrey Campaigners considering legal action.   
    Worcestershire – Woodrow Library to merge with One Stop Shop, Redditch Library to have other services moving in, possibility of closing then renting out one floor, self-service

    Local News

    • Brent – R (Bailey) v. Brent: law against the cuts (and politics) – Head of Legal.  The council argued that the closures were not intrinsically liable to affect Asian people more than anyone else, and I suspect this may be the answer, or something like it, though none of the judges seems to have agreed. In any event, though, the real complaint about the closures has nothing whatever to do with race discrimination – which is what lends this case a distinctly straw-clutching unreality.” … “We have to accept, in a democracy, that politicians will make decisions we don’t like. If we can’t, and instead turn increasingly to tactical legalism in effect as a replacement for politics, we’ll deserve a less political, more centralised and less democratic society.”
    • Brighton and Hove – Mental health services to move to libraries? – Argus.  “Providing activities, group meetings and other support in different locations around Brighton and Hove is being considered as part of a consultation on the future of community mental health in the city.”
    • Caerphilly – Blackwood Library reopens after £215k revamp – Campaign.  “The library underwent an impressive refurbishment and now has a completely redesigned interior with new furniture, shelving, lighting, decoration and improved provision for disabled library users. The facelift was funded through a £94,000 grant from the Welsh Government via CyMAL – the body responsible for museums, archives and libraries in Wales.” 
    • Camden – Progress for the future community use of library buildings – Camden Council.   Details of the “winners” of bids for withdrawn libraries: “Officers will work with the three organisations to further develop their proposals and in particular ensure that they are able to put in place a strong sustainable financial proposal by the end of January 2012.  Providing the necessary work has been completed, the Council will then be able to finalise arrangements for the future use of the buildings.”
    • Gloucestershire – Redundant Gloucestershire librarians back on payroll – BBC.  Libdem opposition councillor says This is a fine example of the shambles in the way the council has handled the matter. The whole review looks like it has been worked out on the back of a fag packet” … Council says “These workers were recruited to expand the numbers on the casual relief register specifically to cover these opening hours under the terms of the injunction issued on 7 July 2011, whilst waiting for the full judicial review hearing”.
    • Hertfordshire – Petition to save school libraries launchedRoyston Crow.   ““This has all happened at very short notice, it was kept pretty quiet. The agenda item was added late, so we’ve tried to do what we can.””
      • Closure confirmed for Hertfordshire School Library Service – BookSeller.   “”The library service offers expert advice and support to schools on a traded basis, and it is expected to cover its costs,” he said. “In recent years, fewer and fewer schools have been buying into the service – only a third of secondary schools and 43% of primary schools now choose to buy in, with others finding alternative provision. This means that, despite restructuring in 2010, the service is running at a deficit and is no longer viable.”
    • Kent – So who has stepped forward and offered to run library services in Kent? – INFOism.  Council appears to be unsure if parish councils have expressed interest in running libraries or not.  No formal submissions of interest have been received.

    “Meanwhile, it is certainly worth showing a bit of love and appreciation to your local library staff over the festive season.  Morale is at an all-time low with many library workers across the county fearing for their jobs with cuts and closures just around the corner.  Not helped, of course, by those at the top failing to consider the impact their decisions will have on those who are serving on the ‘frontline’.  Times are hard for library workers across the county, it would mean a lot to them to know that the public are on their side.” 

    • Surrey – Campaigners take legal steps over libraries – Get Surrey.  Representatives of the Surrey Libraries Action Movement (SLAM) claimed the authority’s plans for 10 sites to become volunteer-run or face being shut fell short of its obligations to provide the county’s residents with library facilities. SLAM said it was reluctant to take legal action but had already gathered “a mountain of evidence” and conducted talks with lawyers.”
      • Slam legal action – SLAM.   “We need someone to come forward that qualifies for legal aid and that would be willing to be involved in the legal action. The level of involvement in preparation for the case is discretionary: we are more than prepared to do all the work necessary and we will fully protect the person, but if the person wants to be more involved then we are certainly happy to work in any way that the person is comfortable with. Legal aid criteria basically comes down to how much capital a person holds (the limit is currently £8,000).”
      • Nine Surrey libraries to be saved: ten still face uncertain future – Eagle Radio.  
    • Worcestershire – Library review will see staff and opening hours cutRedditch Standard.   “Between 28 and 30 full-time jobs will be lost across Worcestershire under the plan, which will also see Redditch Borough Council’s One Stop Shop merge with Woodrow Library to cut costs. It is also planned to bring other council and non-council run services into Redditch Library while other options such as closing a floor of the Market Place building to rent out and shutting the library for at least one day a week are also being looked at. In future it is likely both libraries will open for periods when they are not manned by staff but residents will still be able to use the self-service machines.”.  Charges will also go up.

    “We believe this two pronged approach can actually protect both libraries, so we are not weakening both to save both, I actually think you strengthen both by working with others, so I actually see it as a positive not a negative. There’s no proposal on the table to close the main Redditch Library and no proposal on the table to close Woodrow Library so the main outcome of all this is we can still offer a library service to both communities”

    Special Report: A vision for a 21st Century Library?

    What?

    An article called “A Vision for a 21st Century Library” has been published on the New Labour pressure group website Progress

    Why is it important?  
    The article is written by Dan Jarvis MP, the new shadow minister for libraries, and represents the first clear guide to current Labour thinking on libraries.  It also announces that he will be writing a report of the same name after researching the issue more.  It emphasises that Labour is against “shortsighted” policies of cuts and closures and, above all, is doing something in comparison to the inaction of the current Government.
    What does it say?
    • Libraries will change, with the emphasis being on access to information and the internet.
    • They’re a unique public space, with special importance for encouraging the young to read and as a neutral ground which encourages a strong sense of community ownership.
    • Challenges include – spending cuts (“You can’t ignore the need for cuts”), internet access, ebooks. “the idea of going to a library and trawling the shelves for something to borrow seems to some an outdated practise”
    • Desired aims are to enhance social mobility and personal development.
    • New libraries like Canada Water (Southwark) and  Idea Stores (Tower Hamlet) seen as examples of best practise.
    • A report called “A Vision for a 21st Century Library” has been commissioned.
    • Co-location seen as a good idea, merging a library with a museum or advice bureau etc to share costs.  Similarly, libraries should be more used by government services.
    • Closures are too often seen as an easy way out.  “When they shut their doors they will be lost forever. Long after the deficit has been paid off and the rhetoric has been forgotten, communities will still be feeling the effects of these shortsighted policies.”
    • Volunteers are fine as complementary to staff but not to replace them.  “Volunteers are important and welcome additions, but I have yet to meet a group who would not rather be supporting a service adequately funded by the state.”
    • The Government is not doing enough/anything to stop preventable library closures. 
    • Dan Jarvis is visiting libraries over the next few months and welcomes input “from anyone who cares about libraries”.
    Cons
    • An acceptance that large-scale cuts need to be made.  The budget cuts to be implemented by local government, and that the shadow minister does not seem here to oppose, will mean a 27% cut over four years (plus large cuts due to inflation).  These are seriously going to damage any service, especially one as dependent on buildings, constant replenishment of stock and long opening hours as a public library.  To pretend that new ways of thinking could get around the most devastating peacetime cuts in history is simply that – a pretence.
    • Co-location is seen as a good idea.  They are admittedly, sometimes an unblemished success, when the co-locating service is complementary to the library and, to be fair, the article lists many that are.  However, this is not what is often happening currently in practise.  In reality, libraries are often being crammed in with other less complementary services which affect the long-term viability of the service.  As Worcestershire shows today, with a One Stop Shop merged with a library simply to cut costs, all is not rosy wtih co-location. 
    • A liking for big libraries.  Canada Water is a new showpiece flagship library that does its job well but is not the same as a small community library which are always the ones currently under threat.
    • The internet and ebooks have reduced the need for libraries.  It is unquestionable that the internet has greatly reduced the number of enquiries in libraries.  However, libraries have found a new major customer base in providing internet access, often for free, for the fifth of the population who do not have it.  Also, if one can afford an e-reader and ebooks then one would normally have bought one’s books anyway.  Libraries are not, and never have been, in that market.  Libraries are for those who cannot afford (or who do not wish to buy) an e-reader or the instant gratification of all the new e-book they want when they want them.  Again, to be fair, the shadow minister does acknowledge this later on.
    Pros
    • That it has been written at all.  Labour has done very little so far to take advantage of the tremendous ill-feeling that library cuts and closures have caused  and that has severely affected the party loyalties of many library users.  It is unfortunate for the party that some of the leading library closers are Labour authorities – notably Brent – and thus the chance to create clear blue (red?) water between it and the coalition parties had been largely (to possibly overextend the metaphor) muddied over the last year.
    • Putting the boot into the current Ministers.  Ed Vaizey and Jeremy Hunt are now widely reviled by library users for their inaction.  Anything that draws attention to this and embarrasses them further, possibly even into action, is a good thing.
    • The importance of libraries is recognised.  The article is spot on about the importance of libraries to children, the less wealthy, adult learners and to communities.
    • Volunteers.  It is completely correct about this issue.  Volunteers are fantastic as an addition to existing library staff but often feared as disastrous as a long-term widespread replacement to it.  The Government, and many councils, appear to be deliberately blackmailing local communities to work in libraries so that paid and skilled staff can be made redundant.
    • That it is being researched.  It sounds like the Dan Jarvis is going to do his homework and actually see things for himself, not just spout off a good line and cross his fingers. 
    Verdict
    A good and promising start.  Campaigners should be heartened by this and the increased pressure on the Government that it represents.  They should also make sure to invite the shadow minister to hear their thoughts, concerns and to above all invite him to visit their local, smaller, libraries to show why small is sometimes beautiful and that co-location and the switch to ebooks will not cure all ills.   At the same time, the record of Ed Vaizey, who said and did all the right things while in opposition but has so far done negligibly littler while in office, remains the spectre at this New Labour feast.  However, library supporters will be largely happy and positive about what they have seen so far from this as yet little-known shadow minister for libraries … and that is no bad thing.  We need all the good news we can get.

    See also

    New shadow libraries minister condemns library closures – BookSeller.   Article by Dan Jarvis MP contrasted very favourably with inaction of libraries minister Ed Vaizey.