Ian Anstice

Public librarian since 1994, user of public libraries since my first memories ... and a keen advocate of public libraries and chronicler of the UK public libraries scene. Library manager since 1998, winner of Information Professional of the Year 2011 and Winsford Customer Service "Oscar" 2012 and 2014, honorary CILIP fellow 2015, CILIP Wales Library Champion of the Year 2016.

Homepage: https://www.publiclibrariesnews.com


Posts by Ian Anstice

This one’s for you, Baroness Sanderson

Editorial

Advertisement

Baroness Elizabeth Sanderson is the chair of a new advisory panel that will inform the Government’s new public library strategy this year. Elizabeth, a life peer, although described as “independent”, sits on the Conservative benches, has advised Theresa May and has, well, before been a Mail on Sunday journalist for seventeen years. Given that is the case, and being it’s not an alternative universe, any advice to her has to be made being aware that there won’t be any significant extra funding (that is, more than is taken away via budget cuts) for library services. In addition, localism and lack or regulation are very much still the flavour of the month, so any proposals which require large amounts of money or new rules are not likely to be accepted. With all that in mind, here are my thoughts, on the understanding that if this was for someone in a government of a different colour, they would be very different:

  • A strategy that deals with attempts at censorship both in terms of stock and events. We’re seeing increasing attempts, especially by those on the fringe (anti-vaxxers, religious extremists) and others to stop anything too LGBT in the sector. It would be useful to have some thought on how to respond to such attacks. After all, even the Times, is questioning whether we’d prefer children to have advice from Pornhub instead.
  • The fines-free movement has, from being almost unknown in 2018, taken off at speed in the UK with 71 services now no longer charging money for late books. However, this is heavily skewed towards Scotland (two-thirds), Northern Ireland (all) and Wales (half) compared to just to a quarter in England. Encouragement to push for all library services to be fines-free would be good as this would be instantly popular, promote equality and, crucially, not result in huge extra costs. However, being budgets are very strict, some thought needs to be given to account for the small percentage of funding that they do bring in.
  • Back up the current law about all areas having a “comprehensive and efficient” library service. In addition, the lack of any actual standards for English public libraries is a bit embarrassing. I know this is the most unlikely of the suggestions to be carried out in practice but, remember, closing libraries is not a popular vote-winner.
  • Libraries Connected has proven to be a big success in sharing best practice and encouraging responses to challenges (e.g. Covid) on a national level. It needs to be continued.
Advertisement
  • Libraries are a brilliant springboard for lending and providing information for others e.g. NHS information and heart monitors, covid tests. A push for this to be known to all government and agency services, to make it a case of think library first and only if that’s not possible create your own (expensive, reinvention of wheel) service instead would be good. This may both save money and provide extra funding for libraries.
  • Usage is changing since Covid but not declining. The big change is a sustained increase of e-lending. Some thought as to how services should pay for these as well as for printed stock would be useful as well as a way of encouraging publishers to reduce their (often inflated) library e-book prices and encourage all publishers to allow library lending.
  • A lot of libraries need refurbishment. This is especially true in the children’s areas, which are often too small compared to the adult areas and not exciting enough. The Libraries Improvement Fund has been a success in providing capital investment (rather than soon-forgotten events) to libraries and should be maintained and hopefully expanded.
  • A national public library website, LibraryOn, is being tested and will one day become public. This needs to be as public (rather than librarian) focused as possible, with some way of allowing minimum-clicks-needed access to finding book titles both in print and e-book form. It should also be maintained long-term.

That’s enough, for now, Baroness. Let me know if you want to know or are curious as to what I’d suggest if legislation, enforcement or funding are options.

Changes by local authority

Ideas

National news

International news

  • Colombia Of libraries, ruralities, and mycelia – Medium. ” the greatest value of libraries lies in how tremendously adaptable they can be. But their success depends on us. It depends on us removing stereotypes from our heads and limits from our eyes and hands, and being able to see mycelia where others see closed rooms and ordered shelves.”
  • Denmark – Children, reading culture and libraries: Building blocks for a better future – Christian Lauersen. “Being a Children’s Librarian is a crusade for a better future for us all.” We had four criteria for the new Children’s Library: it should not be made for children but with children; it should not be a playground – it should be a universe for stories, imagination, curiosity and community and a place where children and their families could meet books and library staff in an inspiring and inclusive environment; on a functional level it should be flexible and be able to hold different kind of activities; The collection should be made accessible from a children’s logic – not a librarian’s logic”
  • European Union – Recommendation on Library Legislation and Policy in Europe – EBLIDA. “This Recommendation reinforces active citizenship in a democratic environment and, beyond culture and education, focusses on the 2030 Agenda for sustainable development. It also reinforces the social dimension of libraries and their commitment towards a sustainable, democratic and equitable society.”
  • Global – Where does the Cardigan-wearing Librarian Stereotype come from? – Book Riot. Pre 1800s librarians mainly men (seen as “fussy”) then female-dominated from 19th Century. “because mostly unmarried women were the ones joining the workforce due to demographic shifts and societal changes, the spinster old maid stereotype was born”. Librarians seen as fearsome and libraries are, well, cold.
  • Ireland – ‘Not the country I left’: Cork man working in UK’s oldest LGBT bookshop proud of changed Ireland – Echo. “Amid the difficult period, however, staff are believed to be receiving overwhelming support in the form of everything from bouquets to letters and chocolates from members of the public who oppose the protests. And now, Ballinlough native Jim MacSweeney who is the manager of Gay’s The Word, in London, the UK’s longest-running LGBT bookshop, has also sent words of support from overseas.”
  • New Zealand – Libraries branching out for community wellbeing – NZ Herald. “Public libraries help local government enhance community wellbeing by fostering networks, providing spaces for people to gather and share knowledge and adapting services to respond to community needs.”. Incorporating Maori language “extremely important” … “The research noted that in an ideal future, libraries would be neutral safe spaces that anyone in the community could access. Libraries should be involved in local and national decision-making, and receive national funds.

Local news by authority

“We would struggle to take the tea and coffee away in some of those venues now. I think it is a service that has been introduced that is very popular.”

Andrew Olney, Glasgow Life director of libraries, sport and communities
Check the date

A rainbow of different library services

Editorial

Advertisement

One of the many fascinating things about public libraries is that they’re so very diverse. In the UK, and in many other parts of the world, each library service (or the council or other body that controls it) is effectively its own kingdom, with its own rules and norms. This is shown by variation in even neighbouring services: requirements to join (normally one of three, with no evidence of a connection between it and theft rates – none, one, two including proof of address), fines (from, increasingly, none, to sky’s the limit), number of loans (anything from normally 6 or 8 to limitless), stock (size and composition), how to loan (self-service or staffed), size of library per thousand population, staffing (staffless, unpaid, paid but none professionally qualified, etc). Really, there’s no end to it. Moreover, each individual library within a service often has its own character, depending on neighbourhood, building and even the personalities of those working there. And, of course, in England even more diverse. After all, England quite literally has no standards when it comes to libraries. Which means that the individual library offer can appear pretty darn random at times.

So it’s not surprising that an organisation like GLL/Better has wide variations, even in one week of news. Recent statistics and surveys reported by GLL shows its libraries to have some of the highest usage in England along with high satisfaction rates. On the other hand, the situation in Dudley – which it runs on behalf of the council there – is looking pretty dire. The council is looking to cut it so much that only 2 or 3 of the current 13 libraries may still be open in three years. It’s worthwhile pointing out that this has nothing to do with GLL – it’s the council that decides these things – but still it’s interesting how different things can be even within services run by the same organisation. And it’s a reminder that diversity represents a rainbow, from the brightest to the darkest colours.

Advertisement

Changes by local authority

Ideas

National news

International news

  • Australia – Toy libraries becoming more popular as parents borrow in bid to beat cost-of-living pressures – ABC News. “There are more than 380 registered toy libraries across the country, with an estimated 130,000 members”
  • Canada – Okanagan Regional Library receives $1.6 million from province – Penticton Western News. “The funds are part of $45 million the province has earmarked for libraries throughout B.C., funding which was announced March 24. All 71 B.C. public libraries, and organizations that help libraries deliver their services, will receive one-time grants in addition to their annual operating funding. This aims to give libraries flexibility to address local priorities including longer hours, bigger digital collections and better access to literacy and lifelong learning opportunities.”
  • Global – The technology career ladder – Lorcan Dempsey. “Library leaders should be drawn from across the organization. Any idea that technology leaders are overly specialised or too distant from general library work is outmoded and counter-productive.” Academic library focused but some relevant points.
    • Public libraries are critical social infrastructure – Press Reader. “Contemporary libraries are the lifeline for communities in times of crisis. But as sociologist Eric Klinenberg noted in the New York Times, libraries are criticized and abandoned at the exact moment when they are most needed because “the founding principle of the public library — that all people deserve free, open access to our shared culture and heritage — is out of sync with the market logic that dominates our world. It’s also because so few influential people understand the expansive role that libraries play in modern communities.”

“I’m so saddened that this level of behaviour has now perpetrated Irish public libraries. But I am also not wholly shocked as despite a massive change in public attitudes to LGBTQIA+ rights, and bodily autonomy from when I grew up there in the 80s and 90s, there is still a religious and conservative undercurrent that has more influence than people realise. I am also disgusted that librarians are being targeted, as librarianship was always seen as a respected profession in Ireland – far more so than in the UK. I found that out very quickly to my huge disappointment when I moved here. I am proud of the librarians who are standing up for young people’s access to material but angered that the councils are hiding behind parental consent beyond the initial sign up. No-one ever policed my choice of books growing up in the library. Outside of it though, I remember the uproar in primary school of us sharing Judy Blume books secretly through the senior classes. They treated her books like moral semtex. Hiding and culling books on LGBTQIA issues entrenches shame and limits young people from accepting their whole selves. That’s what it used to be like in Ireland when church and state controlled the narrative. We can’t go back there again.”

Email about the current attempts at censorship in Irish libraries received

Local news by authority

  • Dudley – Waterstones Children’s Laureate to visit Stourbridge Library – Stourbridge News. “Coelho is set to visit and join a library in every local authority in the UK”
    • Fears raised about the future of Dudley’s libraries – Dudley News. “Dudley Council has proposed nearly £1.5 million in savings on library services over the next few years.” … opposition says ““With the additional £1 million paid to GLL in 2021, the library contract has cost the council £4,230,000 since 2017, but it has not achieved the projected savings and the number of library users have declined significantly due to GLL’s mismanagement.””
  • Greenwich – Record numbers of visitors to South London libraries ranked busiest in the UK – London News Online. “Residents are making the most of the 12 libraries in Greenwich, the borough ranking as the location with the most visits compared to its population.  Woolwich Centre Library also stood out nationally by being the second busiest library in the UK. 547,440 people walked through its doors between 2020 and 2021.”
  • Gwynedd – Gwynedd Libraries Service announces vision for next five years – In Your Area. VR Hubs plus “Development of the Library of Things – People can borrow useful things for their homes and more, for example, tools, electrical items and toys. It saves money and is less harmful to the environment than buying new and using only once. The library, known as Petha, will be available at the Dyffryn Ogwen, Penygroes and Blaenau Ffestiniog Libraries. Improving Penygroes Library – Thanks to the grant from the Welsh Government Transformation Capital Grant Scheme, the space at Penygroes
    Library will be improved and improvements at the Dyffryn Ogwen library will also include a new wellbeing garden.”
  • Hertfordshire – Cuffley Community Library Open Day – Hertfordshire Council. First year anniversary of volunteers. “We are proud to celebrate our achievements over the past year and have a special day planned that will appeal to all our visitors”
  • Kent – 200 protest to save Folkestone Library – Socialist Party. “Local activists spread the word for a protest and within 24 hours of the call, a demonstration of around 120 people gathered outside the library demanding that it must be kept open. Anger against the threatened closure has spread quickly, shown by the support for the ‘Save Folkestone Library’ Facebook page.” … “We decided that the pressure must be maintained and so we called another demonstration and rally. Over 200 people, mums and children, young and old, marched …”
  • Lancashire – Lancashire Libraries are supporting voters to be election ready – Lancashire Council. “Lancashire Libraries will be offering trained staff to help people navigate the voting application process. Voters who require support when registering to vote can visit their local library. Staff will be available to help people access the website and apply. Support is also being offered by libraries across Lancashire to help voters complete their Voter Authority Certificate application. An appointment may be required in advance.”
  • Liverpool – Liverpool libraries where children discovered their love of books – Liverpool Echo. Old photographs of people using libraries 1960s to 1980s.

Aberdeen getting worse but otherwise we’re getting Beta

Editorial

Advertisement

It’s not often that I get to report on Scottish public library closures. This is because, well, there aren’t that many Scottish library closures. Aberdeen, however, is bucking the trend by closing six libraries, despite sizeable opposition. The amount of money saved is £280k. Meanwhile, the same council is putting an art installation in, right next to a closing library, for £155k. So, there’s priorities for you. The new First Minister of Scotland had, as one of his first duties, the need to respond to why this happened with a SNP council in charge of Aberdeen. His response was not overly reassuring.

In other news, the beta version of LibraryOn is now open for people to look at. It’s hard to tell with such things and unfair to give an opinion on an unfinished product so I will refrain from commenting on it yet.

The normal madness in US libraries is continuing, with Republicans now trying to withdraw funding from public libraries because there’s some fight back over censoring stock. This, as Judy Blume notes this week, is a dark time for America and is downright embarrassing to look at. Great also to see Wil Wheaton getting in on the act. Not embarrassing at all, though, is a nice new library song to have a listen to. I’m also loving the Somerset idea of lending out activity monitoring watches.

Changes by local authority

Ideas

Advertisement

National news

  • BFI Replay – BFI. “BFI Replay is a free-to-access digital archive exclusively available in UK public lending libraries. Thousands of digitised videos and television programmes from the BFI National Archive and partner UK regions and nations film archives are available to browse and enjoy, research or study – with some familiar and memorable, others rare and unseen for decades. If you are a UK lending library service and would be interested in knowing more about the service, use our enquiry form below.”
  • The Buildings of Philanthropist John Passmore Edwards – Historic England. “Over 70 buildings were constructed in 14 years due to his dedicated philanthropy, including libraries, literary institutes and art galleries.”. 19 libraries for 19 letters: “Taking advantage of the 1850 Free Libraries Act, he pursued opportunities for public self advancement. His ambition was to build a library for every letter of his name. The 1850 Act gave local councils the power to establish libraries open to everyone without a subscription, and many councils had technical schools for science and art.”
  • In celebration of small & thoughtful innovation – Artefacto. “Consider the significance of the fine-free library policy. This relatively minor adjustment has had a profound impact on making the library more inclusive and equitable.” …
  • Libraries in five London boroughs to benefit from £60m funding – Yahoo News.
  • Libraries Strategy Update – DCMS. “Baroness Sanderson began a series of 9 in-depth discussion sessions with a wide range of people – both within and outside the sector – looking at the successes of the sector as well as the challenges confronting it and possibilities for the future. These sessions are taking place in libraries all over the country from Ipswich to Leeds, focusing on one of the 7 strategic outcomes in Ambition, plus sessions on libraries governance and ‘blue sky thinking’.” … ” The conversations have been wide ranging and thought provoking covering issues such as the need for improved data collection to better showcase the impact of public libraries, how libraries can most effectively  raise awareness of their local and national offer and the importance of seeing libraries as an investment rather than a cost.”
  • LibraryOn – Site now in Beta, with very limited functionality. Includes LibraryMap to show where your nearest library is (many links not working correctly as of yet). Become a Beta tester here. Includes grants for public libraries.
  • Musician Natalie Merchant, poet Victoria Adukwei Bulley, library funding – BBC. “Libraries were awarded the smallest amount of money from the Cultural Investment Fund, which was announced last week. Front Row speaks to Nick Poole, Chief Executive of CILIP, the Library and Information Association.”
  • £5.8 million project to deliver a more sustainable future for Open Access books – University of Lancaster. “Led by Lancaster University, the Open Book Futures (OBF) project will develop and support organisations, tools and practices that enable both academics and the wider public to make more and better use of books published on an Open Access basis. “

International news

“Sarah Brimelow is offering a short, fun video to any group that wants to promote their library service. You can view it here. It was made by her partner, ‘part-time musician’ John Phillips. He says: ‘During lockdown I started making videos to accompany my home recordings. I was inspired to make “My Local Library” because I was impressed with the range of services offered at Grove Vale Library in Southwark, and concerned about the threatened loss of libraries to local communities in the UK.””
  • Australia – In this sleepy Sydney suburb, a 24-hour venue is thriving – Sydney Morning Herald. “the suburb has become an unlikely champion for the 24-hour business district, as the home of Sydney’s library that never sleeps.”. Staffless over the small hours.
  • Global – Public Library of the Year – Systematic. “To qualify in 2023, the library must be built and opened between January 1st 2022 and December 31st 2022. “
  • USA – Judy Blume worried about intolerance and book banning in the US – BBC. “I came through the 80s when book banning was really at its height. And it was terrible. And then libraries and schools began to get policies in place and we saw a falling off of the desire to censor books. Now it is back, it is back much worse …”
    • Libraries Need More Freedom to Distribute Digital Books – Atlantic. ” if Controlled Digital Lending sought to provide an alternative pathway for the possession and use of digital books, it did so only after a new, highly constrained marketplace arose that disadvantages the mission of libraries. The frustration libraries feel about this state of affairs has reached a high enough level that bills are making their way through a number of state legislatures trying to regulate the library-ebook market.”
    • “The library is a safe place.” – Wil Wheaton Dot Net. “Why libraries? Because the library is so much more than a building with lots of books, internet access, 3D printers, D&D programs for kids, and all the other things. The library represents and offers equal access for everyone to all of those things. Not just the wealthy. Not just the privileged. Not just the in-group. It is a safe place for everyone to be curious, to find inspiration, to sit in the stacks, as far away from the door and the world as possible, and just quietly exist for a minute. (Don’t you love the way those books smell?) The public library is a safe place for all of us, whether we are a kid who feels invisible, a woman who is lost, or a New York Times bestselling author who has the privilege of sharing their story with you.”
    • Missouri House gives initial approval to $45.6 billion state budget that defunds libraries – NPR. “Democrats and Republicans repeatedly clashed over language that bans staffing for any programs or vendors “associated with diversity, equity and inclusion.”
    • Programming with Constructive Destruction, a guest post by Austin Ferraro – Teen Librarians Toolbox. “our library can be the center of absolute chaos on Friday afternoons.”

Local news by authority

“… Equally, it is often the case that members across the chamber quite rightly believe, as I do, that decisions for a local authority should be made by the local authority. Aberdeen City Council’s plan to close libraries will be extremely difficult for the library staff and the community. However, we recognise the financial challenges that local authorities are facing.” AberdeenHumza Yousaf Scottish National Party

  • Aberdeen – Anger as council confirms plans to close libraries and swimming pool – STV News. “An emergency meeting was held at the Town Hall in Aberdeen for councillors to have a second vote on budget cuts. Following deliberations, the decision was confirmed by a vote of 24-21.It meant plans to close Bucksburn Pool and Cults, Kaimhill, Woodside, Northfield, Cornhill and Ferryhill libraries were confirmed. Protesters said they won’t stop their fight, despite being unable to voice their concerns at Monday’s meeting.”
  • Anger as £155k to be awarded to ‘inferior’ Woodside Gateway project over saving library just yards away – Press and Journal. “Opposition councillors have slammed the decision to spend £155,615 on an art installation in Woodside while shutting the library around the corner.”
    • Opinion: Not just books – Public libraries and their role in communities – Robert Gordon University. “The public library quality framework for Scotland, ‘How good is our public library service?’ helps to inform what ‘adequate’ might look like by suggesting that it is a ‘planned strategic network of branches offering core functions’. The danger with piecemeal reactive cuts to branches as part of annual budget-setting processes is that services end up without that ‘planned strategic network’ of libraries, delivering services to communities for whom it really matters.”
    • Protestors against library closures at Aberdeen council meeting – Herald Scotland.
    • Scotland’s Makar slams ‘uniquely cold’ move to shut Aberdeen libraries – National. “She said it meant communities would be deprived of literature and learning and insisted Scottish philanthropist Andrew Carnegie – who donated money to build thousands of libraries – would be “spinning in his grave”.As Makar, I’m dismayed to hear of Aberdeen Council’s determination to close six local libraries,” said Jamie.“There is something uniquely cold and shrivelling about closing down libraries.”
    • Six libraries to close in Aberdeen, despite efforts to save them – Guardian. “Many of the buildings are in deprived areas, say Save Aberdeen Libraries, while Aberdeen City Council argues facilities will be moved to cheaper ‘hubs’”. SNP says “We’re closing buildings, we’re not reducing library facilities and services,” the newspaper reported him as saying. “For example, the one in Torry – we’re closing the building but the Torry library service will go into a hub in the school two minutes walk away. We’re closing buildings which are old, expensive to heat and need staff, so we’re co-locating the service in schools and community centres.””
    • SLIC criticises Aberdeen City Council’s decision to close six libraries – BookSeller. “Pamela Tulloch, SLIC chief executive, told The Bookseller that the decision “demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of what a library service is by those elected members who voted to close one third of the Aberdeen’s public libraries”.”
  • BarnsleyBarnsley’s libraries set for huge overhaul after securing £50k grant – Yahoo News. “The LFT aims to increase and improve digital access within communities by increasing the number of users accessing services and increasing the number of PCs available to users.”
  • Brighton and Hove – Relaunching Brighton & Hove’s toy library – Brighton and Hove Council. “An additional smaller toy collection has been set up in Coldean Library and a new satellite toy library established at Portslade to provide wider accessibility for residents. Toy libraries are a fantastic way to keep your toy box full without breaking the bank, provide mental stimulation to your child, make friends and meet new people. “
  • Coventry – Libraries provide a much-needed home for digital cultureArts Professional. ” how bringing digital culture into Coventry’s libraries is building communities and helping to bridge a digital divide.”
  • Devon – Unlocking the Cage at Tavi Library – Tavistock Today. “The installation features a uniquely designed book which you use to navigate your journey. With the turn of each page, narration, original music and stunning animations bring the stories to life. The exhibit can be enjoyed alone or in groups of up to four people at a time, taking around 28 minutes to complete, no need to book. Find out more at librariesevolve.org.uk”
    • Future uncertain for Devon’s mobile library service – BBC. “The mobile library vans were “expensive to maintain” and “far fewer” people now used them, Devon County Council said.Roger Croad, the council’s cabinet member for communities, said three of the county’s four vans were coming to the “end of their serviceable lives”.Replacing them would cost between £500,000 and £800,000, Mr Croad said.” … “Despite an uncertain future for the mobile service, a report to the committee revealed that, across the whole library service in Devon, the number of visitors and active library users had continued to increase.” Consultation.
  • Inverclyde – Libraries team up with arts group for workshops this Easter – Yahoo News.
  • Kent – Save Folkestone Library – Facebook group. “Kent County Council have announced the planned closure of our 135 year old library, one of the last free, warm, communal safe spaces in Folkestone. The library was gifted to the people of Folkestone, and is not Kent County Council’s to sell. We must fight back.”
  • Lincolnshire – Works start on Boston Library building this April – Lincolnshire Council. “Boston Library is based in the County Hall building in the town centre. The private owner of the building is carrying out extensive work over the coming months to turn a large part of the building into a hotel. As part of these works, the area occupied by the library needs to be made stand-alone, to separate it internally from the hotel.”
  • Merton – Mitcham Library receives funding boost for education and digital hub – Merton Council. Library Improvement Funding. “The funding will make adaptations to the building to increase access using self-service technology (already deployed at our four branch sites) and create a makerspace using 3D printing, coding and virtual reality equipment, a large TV screen and science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) resources. “
  • Nottingham – Council has spent £24,000 storing books amid fit-out of new Central Library – Notts TV. “Nottingham City Council opted to retire the facility and keep it closed during the development of the new £10.5m Central Library, which forms part of the new Broadmarsh Car Park and Bus Station. Residents have been left without a main city library ever since, and the project to build a new one has been hit with numerous delays.”
  • Nottinghamshire – £1.2 million for rural gigabit broadband for libraries and schools through devolution deal – Nottinghamshire Council. “The Government have made £1.2 million of funding available for new gigabit broadband for Derbyshire, Nottinghamshire, Derby, and Nottingham. It means that an extra 118 rural public sector schools and libraries will be connected to gigabit broadband. When complete, it will help librarians and teachers and allow whole classes to be online at once with no interruptions.”
  • Somerset – Somerset libraries offering activity tracker by SASP – Bridgwater Mercury. “Each Activity Tracker Watch can be loaned completely free for up to six weeks and every watch is cleared of all the data and information when you return it, ensuring your privacy isn’t compromised.”
  • Southend on Sea – Your Library Needs you! Apply to become a Summer Reading Challenge volunteer – Southend on Sea Council.
  • Staffordshire – Mobile library service now available in Burton – Staffordshire Council. “A mobile library service is now available in Burton outside the main library building after it closed temporarily on Monday due to safety concerns.”
  • Suffolk – Discover your new favourite reads with Suffolk Libraries DiscoveReads programme – Suffolk Libraries. “DiscoveReads is a reading programme launched by Suffolk Libraries in 2020 to help people broaden their reading horizons and find exciting new reading experiences. It includes a lively Facebook discussion group with nearly 700 members, and each month the group discusses an unlimited audiobook title on our free BorrowBox service.”
  • Swindon – Library becomes first in town to abolish late fees for under 10s – Yahoo News. Old Town Library. “Until now, only children aged between 0-4 were exempt from late fees, but that is now being extended to all children aged 10 and under in a year-long trial.” … “”Families tell me they are already struggling with the cost-of-living crisis, and while they like to use the library the fear of overdue fines is a barrier to them letting their children borrow.”
  • Wiltshire – New chapter as library officially opens at new home – Yahoo News. Durrington: “The library has been relocated to the Robinson Room at Durrington Village Hall, a much-anticipated feat made possible by Wiltshire Council. The previous location was a well-used portacabin which had reached the end of its structural life. The new home will help to preserve the future of the library and the essential services that it provides to local residents.”
  • Wirral – Extended opening hours to return to Wirral libraries – Wirral Globe. “The four central libraries at Bebington, Birkenhead, Wallasey and West Kirby will be open until 7pm on Tuesdays and Thursdays from Monday, April 3. Six community libraries will also have extended hours to include opening on four weekdays, plus every Saturday morning. This improved offer provides an additional 91 hours per week across the library service and improve residents’ access to books, technology, study space and all other services provided at the local library.”

Bidding for a bouncy castle

Editorial

Advertisement

The Government has given out £4.9 million to English public libraries in a competitive bidding process. This is to be welcomed but it’s worth pointing out that (a) this is likely to be much less than overall funding cuts to libraries this year and (b) is for stuff that library services can’t now afford normally but in any well-funded service would have been able to. Plus also it’s sometimes for additional stuff when the core service is being cut. As Libraries Hacked points out it’s a bit like “watching a house burning down and asking for money to install a bouncy castle in the garden.”. This point is demonstrated this week by Kent where the deputy council leader says that the council cannot afford to reopen Folkestone Library (where apparently 50% of the children are in poverty) because “KCC has to be realistic that in the current challenging financial climate, any spend has to be prioritised”.

Advertisement

I may have mentioned last week that several newspapers had reported a story that Devon was censoring stock for what can only be described “woke” reasons. I understand from contacts in Devon that this is nonsense and that “sadly some newspapers have recently inaccurately reported” their stock management policy. and that “There is not, and never has been, a decision to “remove unedited copies of certain Enid Blyton books from the shelves” and that they do not “operate a trigger warning system”. So, heaven knows what the Telegraph, Mail and Express think they were reporting on. If I didn’t know that they were all unbiased high-quality resources, I’d say it was almost as if they’re trying to stir up controversy or something. And of course this places libraries in a difficult position. They can either feed the trolls by pointing out the mis-reporting or keep quiet and leave it unchecked. And that way can lead to the ridiculous position we see in the USA where some politicians are so sure of how terrible public libraries are that they’re now advocating churches getting the funding instead.

Finally, I wish to mark the farewell of Diana Edmonds from GLL libraries. Being overall for no less than five library services and over 100 libraries, she was de facto the most senior public librarian in the country. Although, some of us may harbour some doubts about the placing of library services under leisure trusts, this did not prove detrimental to the ones she led (the “gymbraries” some of you may know were differently managed) and she used her position, where she could, to protect libraries and the role of professional librarians. I’m glad to say that she will staying in the public library sector.

Changes by local authority

National news

  • Arts, culture and libraries 2023 – Local Government Association. Peer challenges. “The LGA’s important partnership with Arts Council England enables us to provide critical support to our member councils by developing the knowledge and skills of both councillors and officers to champion cultural activity in their local areas during a period of rebuilding, where leadership is needed most.”
  • Culture boost of £12.8m for West Midlands – BBC. “More than £1m from the LIF will be shared between libraries in Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, Shropshire and Walsall.”
  • DCMS announces further £4.9m for 27 library services – BookSeller.
  • Edmonds steps down as GLL national libraries director – Bookseller. “Diana Edmonds MBE is stepping down from her role as national libraries director at the social enterprise Greenwich Leisure Limited (GLL), effective 5th April 2023 … Rebecca Gediking will step in as interim head of libraries to oversee the management and direction of more than 100 libraries in Bromley, Dudley, Lincolnshire, Wandsworth, Wales and the Royal Borough of Greenwich.”
  • Enid Blyton’s racism doesn’t deserve to be in libraries. Read Terry Pratchett instead – Big Issue. “He’s not always perfect but, unlike Enid Blyton, he evolved. A mid-90s Discworld novel, Jingo, has its heart in the right place but is guilty of some fairly broad stereotypes about an Arab-like culture. You can see Pratchett pushing at the edges of the idea, but still falling into some of the traps he set his own characters. But Sir Terry’s mind never sat in one place. He soaked the world up as he moved through it, and as the world around him changed, so did he. At the heart of his work was always the idea that people were complicated. That they were never one thing”
  • Government announces almost £60m in cultural funding for regions outside London – Independent. “They will share a pot of £58.8 million as part of what the Government has billed as plans to “make sure everyone, no matter where they live, can access the UK’s world-renowned culture”.”
  • Green Libraries Manifesto– working together for people and planet – CILIP. “As libraries we occupy a place at the heart of the communities we serve. Through this manifesto, we want to come together towards a shared vision: to lead by example through our own environmental actions and use our power and reach to inform and inspire people to take positive action and build resilience in the diverse communities we serve. We recognise the diversity of our sector which is why this is an inclusive initiative for all libraries to help them make the changes they can, with the resources they have.”
  • Libraries Connected welcomes £4.9m Libraries Improvement Fund investment – Libraries Connected. “While competitive funds can make a huge difference for recipients, without a more secure long term financial settlement many councils will have no option but to consider making cuts to frontline public services, including libraries. We need Government to take decisive action now to avoid a crisis in our libraries over the coming years.”
  • Manchester libraries and Salford and Bury museums to get boost to funding – Manchester Evening News. “Under the government’s Libraries and Improvement Fund, Manchester Libraries will receive £198,872, and Oldham Council Libraries £151,520.”
  • Over 70 cultural venues, museums and libraries supported with £60 million boost – Gov.uk. “£135,000 to Leicester Libraries. £124,355 to Nottingham City Council Library Service. £50,586 to Inspire Libraries (Nottinghamshire), £337,500 to Essex Libraries. £219,000 to Suffolk Libraries, £255,554 to Kingston Libraries, £231,500 to Brent Libraries, £150,000 to Croydon Libraries, £125,000 to Barnet Libraries, 73,354 to Merton Libraries, £266,066 to North Tyneside Libraries, £225,000 to Darlington Libraries, £200,000 to Hartlepool library service, £50,000 to Stockton Library Service, £275,960 to St Helens Council Library Service, £198,872 to Manchester Libraries, £260,000 to Hertfordshire Library Service, £150,031 to Hampshire Libraries, £102,000 to Portsmouth Libraries, £75,000 to Surrey Libraries, £151,520 to Oldham Council Libraries, £300,000 to Stoke on Trent Libraries, £265,000 to Staffordshire Libraries, £241,950 to Shropshire Libraries, £202,349 to Walsall Libraries, £50,000 to Barnsley Libraries”
  • Uncensored Enid Blyton books with ‘outdated’ language are ‘being stashed in off-limits spaces by librarians’ – Mail. Rightwing sensationalist article aims at whipping up hatred of public library.

International news

  • USA – American Library Association reports record number of demands to censor library books and materials in 2022 – ALA. “1,269 demands to censor library books and resources in 2022, the highest number of attempted book bans since ALA began compiling data about censorship in libraries more than 20 years ago. “. Nearly double 2021. Most in school libraries, 41% in public. Most challenges are now for multiple titles so number of books challenged actually far more.
    • Library director fired for trying to relocate book reading – Wear News. “The library director, Allan Morales, suggested the event be moved to a large church due to interest. Some, including Cameron, viewed this as retaliation for the book’s biblical principles. However, emails between Morales and the publisher – obtained by The Tennessean – show that the library director showed genuine concern about the library building’s ability to handle such an event.”
    • Public Knowledge Disappointed in Decision Restricting Ability of Libraries To Lend Books – Public Knowledge. “Under this “Controlled Digital Lending” (CDL) system, only one patron can access a copy of a book at a time – just like with lending physical books. The Internet Archive argued that any additional copies made during this process should be “fair use” under copyright law.” see also Book Publishers Won’t Stop Until Libraries Are Dead – TechDirt. “We’ll get to some of the details in a moment, but we’ve joked in the past that if libraries were new today there’s no way that book publishers would let them exist. In some ways they’re a legacy holdover from before publishers had that much power. The attack on controlled digital lending (CDL) more or less proves this.”

Local news by authority

  • Leicester – New digital suite created at iconic Leicester library – Leicester Council. “isitors to the Grade II listed St Barnabas Library, on French Road, can now make, edit and share their own video content, thanks to new cutting-edge facilities that have been created as part of an £85,000 project. Twelve new PCs have also been provided for library members to use, along with a new performance area, projector and viewing screen. New bi-fold doors will allow the area to be separated off or opened up to the wider library for large performances” … ” The project has been made possible thanks to a £65,000 funding award from Arts Council England’s Libraries Improvement Fund, with Leicester City Council providing an additional £20,000 of funding.”
  • Liverpool – New chapter for library of the future – Liverpool Express. “Previously Spellow Library, situated in the heart of Walton in North Liverpool, was open just three days a week and typical for a 1960s building had poor accessibility, no toilets and limited services. Now following a radical, community-led makeover – the renamed Spellow Hub will be the first facility of its kind in the north of England to offer a complete “education to employment” service for people of all abilities.”
  • North Ayrshire – Irvine mother and daughter star in promo for North Ayrshire libraries – Irvine Times. “Jen and her two-year-old daughter are at the forefront of the ‘Every Child A Library Member’ initiative which promotes the area’s library services and urges parents to sign their children up for a free membership. Showcasing the libraries’ extensive physical and audio book collections and their BookBug events for toddlers, the videos will be shared via social media and the NHS Health Visitor app over the next few months.”
  • North Northamptonshire – Kettering’s £4.5m Cornerstone art gallery and library project needs community ‘support and understanding’, says councillor explaining extension leaks – Northamptonshire Telegraph. ““North Northamptonshire [Council] are now working to rectify the issues, which include long-standing defects with the library roof that have further deteriorated, impacting the new extension. “The issues with the rapidly deteriorating library roof have impacted the new build part of the project as water is travelling through the roof space from one building to the other. A decision has now been taken to ensure the library building is watertight before we open Cornerstone”
  • Nottinghamshire – Service Disruptions – Inspire Culture. Gotham Library closed due to fire.
  • Shropshire – Six Shropshire Council libraries to share in £236,000 Arts Council England funding – Shropshire Council. “It will be used to purchase 1:1 interview pods with supporting technology, enabling private consultations with the public, both face to face or online, for example by offering Shropshire Local customers privacy when discussing their individual needs. It will also fund new mobile shelving to create flexible space to accommodate health and wellbeing sessions offered through social prescribing and creative health models.”
  • Staffordshire – Burton Library closed over ceiling safety concerns – BBC. “A new ceiling is due to be installed later this year as part of a planned renovation of the site. The council said it was working on providing an alternative service as soon as possible.”
  • Stoke on Trent – Stoke-on-Trent Libraries Secure £300,000 funding from Libraries Improvement Fund – Stoke on Trent Council. “The first project that will benefit from this funding, includes the installation of self-release printing on four library sites plus WiFi printing in all six libraries. A second project is also planned, which will modernise Stoke and Longton libraries, making them flexible community spaces for various groups and customers.”
  • Suffolk – Suffolk Libraries officially launches Menopause & Me – Suffolk Libraries. “programme is being run with funding from the Department of Health and Social Care. It aims to help people who are experiencing the menopause and perimenopause, with a focus on empowering local employers to provide as much support as possible for their staff. Suffolk Libraries will be working with Suffolk Mind and other partners on the project.”
  • Suffolk: Museums and libraries receive £3m for improvements – East Anglian Daily Times. ” £219,000 from a separate fund to pay for the creation of an online tool providing tailored recommendations for people looking to find out more about local activities.”
  • Surrey – Surrey Libraries receive £75k funding – Surrey News. Flexible shelving. “The recent funding of £75k from the Arts Council Cultural Investment Fund will help libraries to continue to deliver their “Dynamic Spaces” project in eight libraries. The first part of this project was completed in 2022 with the provision of flexible shelving in ten libraries, which has meant that libraries can move furniture around to reconfigure spaces to accommodate far more events and services, and for many more of our residents.”
  • Wirral – Extended opening hours to return to Wirral libraries – Wirral Globe. Trial: “The four central libraries at Bebington, Birkenhead, Wallasey and West Kirby will be open until 7pm on Tuesdays and Thursdays from Monday, April 3. Six community libraries will also have extended hours to include opening on four weekdays, plus every Saturday morning. This improved offer provides an additional 91 hours per week across the library service and improve residents’ access to books, technology, study space and all other services provided at the local library”

Another normal week in 2023: death threats, censorship, cuts and investment

Editorial

Advertisement

Censoring libraries is hitting stronger all the time – this week we have (1) death threats against US and Irish libraries (2) Devon apparently (the papers reporting it are the Telegraph and Express so it’s not certain) restricting access to Enid Blyton (3) the Mail stoking outrage at a LGBT books in a British school library and a Michigan prosecutor considering an up-to-four-year jail term for a librarian for stocking a book he doesn’t agree with. It’s all pretty sickening.

In other news, some New Zealand politician has come up with the brilliant idea of having volunteer libraries, Scotland is celebrating having a majority of fines-free libraries while at the same time fighting closures in Aberdeen, Cardiff still cutting jobs but by stealth, Hackney’s staff cuts completely accidently wiping out union stewards, Stockport getting a nice new co-located library, Stoke selling off libraries (including one that promptly caught on fire) and a potentially dodgy consultation In Worcestershire. Another normal week in 2023.

National news

Advertisment
  • Death threats and hate mail: America’s drag queen culture wars hit hard in Europe – Euronews. “While those claiming drag shows endanger kids often compare these performances to cabaret and burlesque, drag shows do not inherently involve explicit nudity, and they don’t contain explicit sexual references in the case of storytime events where children are in the audience. On the other hand, storytime events like Drag Queen Story Hour focus on inclusiveness, education, and representation of marginalised groups. But this truth is often lost in the rhetoric circulating among conservative circles …”
  • Enid Blyton books hidden ‘under the counter’ as libraries fret about offensive language – Telegraph. Behind paywall. see also Enid Blyton novels being hidden in libraries in bizarre new woke driver – Express. “Uncensored original versions of some of Blyton’s 700-plus collection have been removed from Devon library shelves and stored in back rooms to prevent the public “stumbling upon” language that is “outdated”. Although listed on the online library catalogue, readers can only get their hands on earlier editions of the texts if they specifically ask librarians for them. At this point they will be verbally given a trigger warning about the language contained within. “
  • Forum 2023 – National Acquisitions Group. May 25, 10am to 4pm. “Tickets now on sale, subsidised to £40 for NAG Members.” see also Public Libraries Project of the Year Grant “5,000 is on offer for one NAG Member public library.  Very simple application process, open to all sorts of projects, why not give it a try?”
  • Public libraries: the local levelling up machines – MJ. Diana Edmonds: behind paywall. “libraries are now playing a crucial role in supporting communities during the cost of living crisis and should be seen as a vital tool within the levelling up agenda.”

Changes by local authority

International news

Local news by authority

  • East Sussex – Poet Laureate Simon Armitage to visit Eastbourne library – Sussex Express. “The E to G Libraries Tour, which runs from March 17 to March 23, is the latest leg of Simon’s ten-year adventure celebrating UK libraries. Using the alphabet as a compass, his journey celebrates the library as one of the great and necessary institutions. Poet Laureate Simon Armitage said: “I want to celebrate the physical space of libraries and take my work back into places that have given me so much.””
  • Hackney – Protest as Hackney Unison chair amongst those handed compulsory redundancies in libraries shake-up – Hackney Citizen. “Council staff staged a protest outside Hackney Town Hall after several library staff, including Hackney Unison Branch Chair Brian Debus, were handed compulsory redundancy notices.” … “Hackney Unison said it was “registering our disgust that three library workers including Hackney Unison Branch Chair Brian Debus are due to be made compulsorily redundant. This despite there being more than enough posts available in the restructured library service.”” … “The council consulted 99 library staff over the changes which see some roles at higher bands and managers caring for several libraries instead of a manager for each. The move is aimed at saving £250,000 from the budget.”
  • Manchester – Central Library anniversary – Manclibraries Blog. “It’s hard to believe that on Friday 22 March we celebrate the fifth anniversary of the rebirth of Central Library after a closure of 4 years to deliver the £48m transformation programme. The library is one of the most loved and iconic places in the city and the success of the transformation is seen by the numbers of people who use the library. “

Neutrality and Challenges

Editorial

Advertisement

Like many, I have been caught up in the debate about the neutrality of the BBC. Like public libraries that august institution has a duty to neutrality and, like us, comes under pressure from time to time to be less than evenly balanced. And if the BBC sometimes finds this difficult then it’s potentially even harder for something like libraries, which are after all part of a service led by councillors, who are almost all of one political party or another. Ultimately, there’s little that can be done in such instances other than to quote stock policies, national or local, and hope. Unless there’s a well-known television commentator who notices of course.

There’s the usual mixture of good and bad news stories, and continuing rumours of deep cuts coming in some councils, but a story that can always be relied on is the news about the Summer Reading Challenge. This is the biggest promotion that most public library services ever do and has tremendous traction with the public, many of whom remember doing it themselves either as children or as parents. And, of course, the theme this year is sports and games, which ties in well with the Women’s World Cup coming up soon. Hang on, that means we may have tweets from footballers …

Advertisement

Changes by local authority

Ideas

National news

  • Author Joanne Harris calls for more investment in libraries and the arts – Chester Standard. “Ms Harris, author of Chocolat, spoke out after receiving an OBE for services to literature from the Prince of Wales at a Windsor Castle investiture on Tuesday. After the ceremony, she praised William and the Queen Consort for championing causes that promote literacy in the UK, but called on the Government to do more.”
  • LibraryOn Grants programme application guidance – LibraryOn.
  • A love letter to local libraries – The Know. “while visits have increased by 68%, spending on UK libraries has fallen by 17%. This waning investment comes at a time when libraries are more crucial to our communities than ever before. There are very few places left where people can go to access information, meet others and keep warm – without needing to spend anything.”
  • Majority of English councils plan more cuts at same time as maximum tax rises – Guardian. “At least 12 councils are on the edge of “effective bankruptcy”, the survey warns, as they struggle to meet their official obligation to balance their budget while trying to maintain legal minimum levels of core service provision, from adult social care to roads repair, libraries and homelessness.”
  • Nooks take centre stage as libraries level up for the hybrid future – Specification Online. “We’ve really seen take-up of Nooks in libraries lift off, with 25 Nook installations in UK libraries and five new installations in the past month alone.”
  • Open meeting on Sanderson inquiry into public libraries and Campaign AGM – Library Campaign / Eventbrite. “An open discussion on Baroness Sanderson’s inquiry into public libraries will be followed by the Library Campaign AGM” including guest speaker Isobel Hunter (Chief Executive, Libraries Connected)
    with LC’s analysis of the current library landscape. Saturday 25 March, 2 to 4pm. Unison HQ, London. Teams online option available if book online and say you’re planning to use Teams.
  • The Reading Agency partners with Youth Sport Trust for Summer Reading Challenge 2023 – BookSeller. “The Reading Agency has revealed that this year’s Summer Reading Challenge will be “Ready, Set, Read!” The annual challenge encourages children to engage with books during the summer reading “dip”. According to the agency, it reached 723,184 children and families across the UK in 2022, with 608,015 children taking part through their local library service. This year, the agency – in partnership with the Youth Sport Trust – has the dual aim to keep children’s minds and bodies active over the summer break.”
  • Should Public Libraries Double Down on Print Book Collections? – Publishers Weekly / Tim Coates. “The declines are serious and suggest that the library’s reputation as a vital community resource is in peril. How serious? I fear these trends could lead to the disintegration of U.S. public libraries within a generation if allowed to continue. And without strategic changes visible to the public, I believe they will continue. Take the U.K. as a cautionary tale … I believe that if just 6% of the money currently in the staff and management budget was spent instead on books, we would begin to reverse the decline in library usage.”. See this page for more figures from Tim.

International news

Local news by authority

  • Aberdeen – Save our Cornhill Library – Change.org. “This petition asks Aberdeen City Council to reverse their decision to close Cornhill Library. Please share this petition widely as we try to save this vital community resource.”
  • Letter to Aberdeen Council – Sean McNamara / CILIPS. “Aberdeen City already has one of the lowest numbers of branches per population (1.62 per 20,000) and well below the average of 2.04 per 20,000. These changes could leave Aberdeen as having the lowest number of library branches per population in Scotland”
  • Worcestershire – Worcestershire Libraries Cost of Living fairs help over 800 residents – Worcestershire Council. “The events were a huge success, with 835 additional people visiting the libraries during the fairs, equating to a 32% increase in visitors compared to the average number of visitors in January and February. The events were attended by regular library customers and those new to libraries, demonstrating the wide appeal and importance of the information and advice available.”
  • York – Dringhouses library soon to reopen after being closed because of cold – Yahoo News. “bosses decided to temporarily close the library in the middle of last month because average temperatures inside were only 10 degrees. Health and Safety Executive guidance states that the minimum temperature for working indoors in a library-type environment should be at least 16°C.”

Cipfa, cuts and woohoos

Editorial

Advertisement

I’m always a bit bemused by the release of the annual CIPFA figures. For one thing, they tend to be released late (this one about 11 months afterwards). They’ve also lost their comprehensiveness – only 43% of library services responded this time. And then of course they’re impossible to get at, unless you’re a library service or very rich. Finally, there’s the analysis of them. The current one appears not to overly notice the big increase in usage was because libraries were open after Covid again or that income was a bit down because, well, the public wasn’t coming in. But, and it pains me to say it, they’re the best we have. Until library services get it together and produce something themselves or the government starts making reporting compulsory then we have to use the imperfect statistics. We just need to be aware of how bad they area and not rely on them or, actually, use them much.

I’m sorry to see the main cuts reported this week being in Scotland. That nation has had a notable better time of it than England in the previous decade. However, it’s great to see the threat of closure lifted from the Wirral and also that York has gone fines-free (and has even removed reservations charges). Woohoo. A final woohoo goes to the creativity of library services: I’ve been doing this newsletter for way over a decade and I’m still spotting new ideas coming out of the sector. I can’t wait to see more. Hopefully about how to get good statistics …

Changes by local authority

Ideas noted

  • My First Library Card –  specially designed for 0-5, part of My Firsts promotion to inspire young children to visit, join and regularly use their local library (Hertfordshire)
  • Photographic Voter ID help – (Cheshire East)
  • Stimkits – Lendable resources for children with autism (North Yorkshire)
  • Teddy Bear Trail – fundraising for libraries (Jesmond volunteer library)

National news

“Today is world book day. The First Minister is well known as a self-identified avid reader so, as she leaves office, how does she feel about being responsible for closing more public libraries than any of her predecessors?” Stephen Kerr Conservative

“I am proud of the support that the Scottish Government gives to libraries. Many libraries in my constituency and across the country had to close during the pandemic, but I have watched them reopen and become vital parts of local communities. I will continue to support libraries, and I will continue to support everything associated with the wonderful world of books. Perhaps I even look forward to having a bit more time to read books in future.” Nicola Sturgeon Scottish National Party

They Work For You

International news

  • Canada – Toronto libraries are fighting for ‘intellectual freedom’ with new collection of exclusively banned books – CP24. “The collection features 50 adult, teen and children’s books that have been banned, challenged or censored across North America. “
  • USA – As LGBTQ book challenges rise, some Louisiana librarians are scared to go to work – PBS. “Scrutiny of libraries, books, teaching materials and curriculum has become a central issue for conservative politicians around the nation. In Florida, the education department has launched a statewide effort to review reading materials provided to children in schools, following a law that went into effect last summer that can impose harsh penalties on any educators who provide books deemed inappropriate. Librarians in Missouri were forced to remove books from shelves under threat of criminal charges last fall. Virginia established a tip line encouraging parents to report teaching materials about critical race theory, but it quietly shut down the effort last year.”
    • Call to Action for Digital Content – Good E Reader. “a March of Action for libraries. In response to the growing concern about fair access to digital rights, including ebooks, audio books and other digital resources, the coalition is hosting a series of virtual Congressional briefings in March 2023 regarding the future of digital rights for libraries.”
    • From letters to airplane tickets; this librarian has collected over 400 items in books left by visitors – First Post. “Starting from grocery lists, postcards, polaroid photographs, airplane tickets, notes, recipes, concert tickets, and even love letters, Sharon has seen it all and has now turned it into her passion. The woman who works at the Oakland Public Library in California also runs an independent page on the library’s website where all the forgotten mementoes are uploaded for public viewing.”

Local news by authority

Leeds
Northern Ireland
  • Measuring our impact: Independent research into our social value – Suffolk Libraries. “Our latest impact report Suffolk Libraries, An impact analysis of services of Suffolk Libraries January 2023 by independent consultants Moore Kingston Smith estimates that every £1 spent on Suffolk Libraries’ services creates £6 in ‘social value’. This is based on a comprehensive study of the wide range of services and activities Suffolk Libraries provide and further discussion with people who benefit from them. The report also found Suffolk’s libraries generated £41m worth of social value and saves NHS services in Suffolk a whopping £542K per year.”
  • Swindon – Swindon library visitors drop post Covid as e-loans soar – Swindon Advertiser. “In the year ending in March 2020 there were more than half a million personal visits to the five libraries, which lent 532,000 items and there were 16,758 e-loans, of things like digital audio books, e-books and e-magazines. This far in 2022-23, which still has more than a month to run, personal visits have numbered 188,000. That’s well under half the pre-pandemic total, with 224,000 items being borrowed. In the meantime e-loans have multiplied six-fold to 93,471 this year.”
  • West Dunbartonshire Libraries face closure or moving location under West Dunbartonshire Council budget proposals – Glasgow Live. “Dalmuir Library could be moved within Dalmuir community centre under proposals to plug West Dunbartonshire Council’s £21.6 million budget gap. Balloch, Duntocher, Parkhall and Faifley libraries also face being co-located or closed.”
  • Wirral – Wirral Council: Plan to close nine libraries scrapped – BBC. “The local authority, which faces a £32m budget gap, also u-turned on plans to cut back on playgroups, the maintenance of parks, and street cleaning.” … “Greens leader Pat Cleary said: “Promoting an excessively pessimistic budget gap has inevitably led to heightened and unnecessary stress for staff and residents.”
    • York – Residents invited to have their say on Acomb Explore – York Explore. Consultation on new library.
    • York libraries to scrap all fines for overdue books – Yahoo News. “Even library books that have been gathering dust at the back of a shelf at home for years – and which you’ve occasionally felt guilty about not returning – will no longer incur a fine when you bring them back.” … “As well as removing late charges, the library service will also scrap the 25p fee for reserving books. ‘These changes are all part of work to improve the experience for library customers which will also include the launch of an app to make borrowing even easier, and brand-new self-issue machines being installed in all York’s libraries during March,’ Explore says.”
    • Date set for library re-opening – Dringhouses and Woodthorpe Ward. “The library closed on 13th February in response to concerns about the low temperature in the building, caused by a combination of winter weather and ineffective heating. A new boiler is being installed along with new convector heaters and new radiators. It has been confirmed that Listed Building Consent is not needed for these internal improvement works.”

Written out

Editorial

Advertisement

The recent controversy over the rewriting of Roald Dahl’s books to make them more politically correct, which may or may not have been just a publicity stunt, has got me thinking even more about where we should stand on censorship. And it is censorship, pure and simple. Look at the definition of the word if you’re not sure.

My views on this have changed and hardened recently. The thing is I like being politically correct and, as any reader will gather from my editorials, my views are left of centre. But I think we need to be firm on some things. If one starts changing words then it means that written words can be changed. The moral high ground is lost and it’s harder to work out what was actually said or meant. Freedom of speech is taken away from the dead. And, maybe, if we refuse to recognise this as a line in the sand, then there are others lines we may not notice until it is too late.

My first degree was in History, fascinating subject (let me know if you want a chat on Later Roman military formations) but part of the challenge is working out what actually happened. Far from being the preservers of ancient knowledge like many of us were taught in school, the Early Christians destroyed by some estimates over 95% of pagan writing and a surprising amount of what is left is just extracts in Christian texts of the time, often included solely in order to rebut them. That was a historic catastrophe, in at least two different ways. What I am saying is that the writings of authors need to be kept the same in order to accurately judge them. If they fall out of favour of the times then let them. Of course, as librarians our influence is highly limited (profit wins every time) but at the very least we should not welcome such changes. Or we will be judged in the future for it. That is, unless librarians are written out of history when it is politically correct to do so.

Changes by local authority

National news

Advertisement
  • I hate library phone boxes. By Katrina Robinson – The Oldie. “I’m a librarian – so people think I should love it when people put any old books in any old crate and label it ‘Library’. They think I’m blaspheming against mighty Thoth, the Egyptian god of reading, when I tell them how I feel. I feel the way any worth-her-salt GP would feel if she spotted a rusty first-aid box by the side of the road, with ‘Hospital’ emblazoned all over it – while real hospitals were closing or becoming semi-open ‘community hospitals’ staffed by unqualified volunteers.”

Although there have been library closures, an extensive network of libraries remains across England delivering services including digital to local residents. There has been no assessment made of the impact of library closures on trends in the level of digital exclusion. There are over 2,900 libraries across England, and while there have been closures, they continue to be a well used service, providing a trusted network of accessible locations with trained staff and volunteers, free wifi and public PCs, and assisted digital access to a wide range of digital services.

Based on a dataset of information on public libraries in England, published by Arts Council England, we estimated that around 230 static libraries have been permanently closed in the period 1 April 2010 to 31 December 2021 and have not been relocated or replaced.”

Paul Scully, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State, Department of Science Innovation and Technology
  • Improving the online presence of public libraries with a new grants programme – British Library / Living Knowledge. “The first stage of the LibraryOn digital grants programme will kick off on 1 March 2023. From this date we’ll be inviting library services in England to submit an Expression of Interest form outlining their initial ideas for a funded project.”
  • Julia Donaldson ends James Patterson’s reign as UK libraries’ most borrowed author – Guardian. “Patterson had been the most borrowed author for 14 years in the Public Lending Right (PLR) data” … “All of the Top 10 most borrowed titles for the period were fiction, with crime and thriller titles dominating. Osman’s The Thursday Murder Club and its sequel The Man Who Died Twice were in at numbers one and two on the chart, and held the same positions on the most borrowed audiobooks chart.”
  • Libraries Improvement Fund (LIF) Round 3 – Arts Council England. £10.5m. “This fund will enable library services across England to invest in a range of projects to upgrade buildings and technology so they are better placed to respond to the changing ways people are using them.”
  • The old book shop going to auction with hundreds of books inside – Wales Online. Nothing to do with public libraries but oh my gosh the books …
  • Radio 2 Book Club Library Staff Opportunity – BBC Radio 2. “We’re looking for librarians to join the Radio 2 Book Club panel, to help choose the books that will feature on the show.”
  • Shortlist announced for Libraries Connected Awards 2023 – Libraries Connected. “The Awards have six categories which reflect the Universal Library Offers (ULOs) and Promises – the core services and programmes that modern library services provide.”
  • A sociological exploration of the library – Glasgow Guardian. “Cicero once said: “If you have a garden and a library, you have everything you need.” While students may have to replace a garden with a daily walk through Kelvingrove Park, our own private libraries are flourishing. Perhaps at the expense of the public good that public libraries provide.”

International news

  • Czech Republic – Sustainability in Czech Libraries – CILIP. Webinar, March 22 Wednesday 5pm. ” established SDGs in Czech librarianship and empowered dozens of libraries to become pioneers of sustainable development topics in their communities.”
  • South Korea – Exploring the Innovative Community Libraries of Korea – Publishers Weekly. “there is no future for libraries—instead, there are many diverse futures, futures diverse as the communities libraries are designed to serve. And in these futures, librarians shape their libraries around these unique communities, diverse in demographics, needs, capabilities, and locations.” … “Fair warning, these libraries really cannot be replicated. What makes them work is that they are all hand made for their unique communities. “
  • USA – Confronting white nationalism in libraries: a toolkit – Western States Center. “This toolkit is designed to help readers counter multiple forms of organized bigotry. This includes organizing that draws on anti-Blackness, anti-Indigenous bigotry, anti-immigrant bigotry, anti-Muslim bigotry, antisemitism, misogyny, and anti-LGBTQ+ bigotry.”

Local news by authority

The only thing that stays the same

Editorial

Advertisement

Things change and libraries change. I was training a new member of the team this week and went through everything that had changed since I started in public libraries in the same area (not the same council – that’s one of the changes) back in the 1990s. It included library moves, opening hour changes (usually for the better, thankfully), story-times, the Summer Reading Challenge, self-service machines, people’s network computers, cafes, rhyme-times, baby bounce, reading groups, printing and a little thing called the internet. That last has revolutionised everything else, including what books we stock and how to display them, not least changing staffing needs. None of this is bad, and much of it is good, but the key is … imagine if we hadn’t changed? What a dinosaur library service we’d have been, and there’d have been complaints. And rightly. The latest thing I’m enjoying is the powerful combination of online event booking combined with posts linking to them in local facebook groups. Wow. What an impact that has had, including attracting people into the library who would never have thought about visiting before. And this makes think – not changing these days would be the biggest change of all. Change is not even really a choice any more. Lack of change would be very difficult and lead to, ironically, a great change in how we are seen. That’s not to say all change is good. Not change is not bad either. And that’s good, because the only thing that stays the same in this world is that things change.

That was going to be my whole editorial this week but I need to add something else. When I was starting out in the public library blogging hobby back in 2010, there were a few people that really helped me. One of those was Shirley Burnham, a library campaigner from Swindon with wonderfully pro-library and unbending views. She made me look positively lukewarm on libraries by comparison. So it’s with great sadness that I see she passed away at the start of the year. I will miss her and I can’t see that changing for a while.

Changes by local authority

National news

  • Celebrating 125 years of CILIP Chartership – CILIP. “In celebration of the 125th anniversary of our Royal Charter, we are launching The CILIP 125 List, to recognise and honour a new generation of librarians, information and knowledge management professionals who drive positive change, making a difference and having an impact across all sectors.”
  • CILIPS Annual Conference 2023 – CILIPS. “The largest conference in Scotland for library and information professionals, CILIPS23 will bring together colleagues from across the country and beyond to share knowledge, network and engage in professional development. Hosted by CILIPS President Richard Aird and taking place on 5th and 6th June 2023 at the Dundee Apex Hotel, our Annual Conference will feature inspiring keynote speeches, impactful parallel sessions, a range of networking opportunities and much more.”
  • Getting started with open data – Libraries Data Blog. “Last week I was asked how a public library service could get started with publishing open data, and where to look to make it good. There aren’t many library services publishing data (yet!), and it can be a daunting task for a service to get started. For libraries, it’s still leading in innovation rather than jumping on a bandwagon. Firstly …”
  • Libraries Activity Data – Libraries Connected. 23 February, 1pm, webinar. “We are analysing libraries’ activity data on a monthly basis and benchmarking this against broader data from High Streets and other areas. Join us for a discussion on what the data shows, what it means and provide your own insight from the library services to make our analysis a much richer picture.”
  • The Story Detective Will Tour to Libraries Across the UK in 2023 – Broadway World. “An immersive promenade dance performance, The Story Detectives takes children and their families on an imaginative journey through the library to discover different kinds of books, from a detective book to an adventure book, a dictionary to a fairy tale, led by two characters Playful and Particular.”

International news

  • AustraliaPublic Libraries and the public good: How Australian public libraries are a core to local government presence – Medium. “hile the three Rs are essential to the operation of society, the provision of public library services can be seen as critical for local governments in providing a human face to council services and one of the only few spaces where the notion of community is fostered and thrived.”
  • Canada – How the North Bay Public Library is spicing things up – TVO. ” the North Bay Public Library also offers patrons the chance to participate in a special kind of club: anyone with a library card can pick up a free Spice of the Month kit containing a spice portion (like ginger in December, cumin in January, and paprika in February) and a simple recipe — four-ingredient cardamom muffins or ginger-molasses cookies, for example — so they can try the spice at home. NBPL makes around 30 to 40 kits to hand out to library-goers on a first-come, first-serve basis. “
  • Finland – Eventful year in the Iisalmi City Library – NAPLE Sister Libraries. “the project wants to turn the library space into an active forum of public debate and other activities connected to promoting democracy. “
  • USA – Publishers Want to End How Libraries Lend Books Online – Medium. ” “publishers will continue to sue libraries over digital practices that were long considered fair uses in the physical world — even if they are done on a nonprofit basis with no measurable economic harm.””

Local news by authority

  • Birmingham – Libraries ‘won’t face funding cuts’ but may be moved in Birmingham says council leader – Birmingham Mail. “The report said the expected budget gap for the period 2023/24 would be £80 million, rising to as much as £146.5 million in 2026/27. The council is expected to try and save £48 million this year.” … “Ian Ward, leader of Birmingham city council, denied libraries will be cut. Instead, he argued the services will be “reconfigured”.”
  • Brighton and Hove – ‘How can cutting Hove Library opening hours be allowed?’ – Yahoo News / Letters. “Now comes news that the shutting of Hove Library on a Saturday is under consideration. How can this be allowed? Provision of libraries is of course a statuary obligation and to close the doors on a Saturday could be described as discrimination.”
  • Bury – Bury readers can now borrow books across Greater Manchester – Bury Times. “The borough has joined the shared Greater Manchester Library Management System, giving people in Bury the choice to borrow 4m books and other items.”
  • Cardiff – Mass read-in protest against Council’s decision to library cuts – Inter Cardiff. “The council is planning to staff the library with unpaid volunteers and change the library opening times but this is a huge problem during the cost of living crisis, according to Adam Johannes, a representative for Cardiff People’s Assembly.” … “There are currently no libraries that are threatened to close but the campaigners fear that often services are cut and run down and then it leads to less people using them, which then is used as an argument in the future to shut them down. Adam says, “The basis of a true democracy is the library.””
  • Derby – Future looking brighter for Derby libraries as £415,000 is budgeted to keep them open – Derby Telegraph. “Derby’s 10 community-managed libraries are set to remain open – potentially for the next 12 months – while expressions of interest from community groups, charities and other organisations are processed. Initially, the city council cabinet was set to approve a plan which would see them operate with certainty until the end of July but a late addendum has now indicated they will remain open longer at a cost to the council of £415,000.”
  • East Riding – Business Start-Up Day at Bridlington Central Library on 22 February – East Riding Council. “The free event is run by East Riding Libraries with the BIPC Humber Partnership. BIPC centres offer free access to millions of pounds’ worth of business and intellectual property information and provide business events, workshops, one-to-one expertise and the space to research, develop and grow in a trusted and accepting space.”
  • Temporary closure of Goole Library – East Riding Council. “The works involve the redevelopment of the existing library, in order to accommodate Goole Customer Service Centre and Opportunity Goole, part of the Goole Town Deal. The new site will have an improved layout, the addition of two private customer interview rooms and the creation of a Contact Centre facility to answer telephone calls to the council’s main telephone line.”
  • East Sussex – Amnesty held for overdue library books in East Sussex – BBC. “The seven-week amnesty runs from 13 February to 31 March, when all fines will be waived by the library service for any books returned.”
  • Fife – Therapets added to Fife library to help young children read with confidence – Fife Today. “Cuddling in with a Therapet such as Jilli can boost the ability of those who get a little tongue-tied or struggle when asked to read out loud.”
  • Capel Library celebrates its seventh year of Community Cinema – Suffolk Libraries. “The Community Cinema has been organised by the Friends of Capel Library since 2016 and regularly hosts new and popular films in the library each month. The audience are invited to vote for which film they would like to see next at each event.”
    • Lakenheath Library to change opening hours this week – Suffolk Libraries. “The changes will benefit local people by providing longer opening hours on busier days to meet local demand. The library will close earlier on Friday evenings when the library has been quieter and will be open for the same number of hours overall.”
    • Pre-loved clothing sale and fashion show at Chantry Library – Suffolk Libraries. “The event aims to celebrate International Women’s Day and promote sustainable clothing whilst also raising funds for Suffolk Libraries. Chantry Library is also looking for any stallholders interested in hosting a stall to sell pre-loved clothes, new jewellery or cosmetics.”
  • West Northamptonshire – Start Up Day 2023 at Northampton Central Library – West Northamptonshire Council. ” a day of free workshops, motivational talks, networking and mentoring to give you the know-how to turn your business dream into a reality, whilst navigating a post-pandemic world.” Business and IP Centre.
  • Wirral – Plans to close nine libraries, play groups and iconic leisure centre thrown out – Liverpool Echo. “Plans to close nine libraries, playgroups and a leisure centre have been thrown out by councillors after a tense Wirral Council meeting.” … “The proposals will now be debated by all councillors on February 27 and looks likely to pass with support from the Liberal Democrats and the Greens who voted to move the budget forward with Labour.”
  • York – Dringhouses Library – York Explore. “Dringhouses Library will be closed from Monday 13 February until the end of the month. Average temperatures inside the library of only 10 degrees during the cold weather mean it is uncomfortable for staff and volunteers working in the building. We know how important this library is to our local community. We will keep the situation under constant review and aim to have the library back open as soon as it is safe to do so.”

£500 million to a library in the South East of England

Editorial

Two bits of news catch my eye today. The first is the, wow, £500 million going to the British Library in London. That’s more than half what goes into the entire national public library service each year. On the one hand, it’s great to see such a massive investment in libraries and, it’s of course not government money that would otherwise have gone to public libraries. That is, the sector has lost nothing from it and may well gain in some ways. On the other hand, that’s because almost government funding almost never goes to public libraries instead. If I was being hyper-cynical I’d point out that the 100,000 new square foot represents ten square feet for each of the 10,000 public library staff lost over the last decade. But I am of course a massive optimist. Yay. And even though it’s a very handy short walk away from Euston, the three hour journey and £150 return cost (if I’m lucky) will tend to put me off visiting to admire it. So I don’t think it’s going to help Levelling Up North. But, on the whole, well done and best wishes to the British Library. They have been more aware of public libraries recently, what with business centres and webinars and the work on (launch any time now, honest) LibraryOn, the Single Digital Presence. And, after all, library sector beggars can’t be choosers.

The other bit of news is the censoring of a nursery rhyme, Five Little Monkeys, in Scottish Book Bug sessions. It appears to have some “historical racist intent”. I’ve not heard it for years and now I know why I guess. But it brings me on to a thought I’ve been having for a while. And that is, weirdly, the explosion of information on the internet has led to an increase in demands for restricting freedom from all sides and all reasons. We see this most notably in the Land Of The Free, where there are ongoing bans and challenges to pretty much any book your average Christian Extremist or Far Righter does not disagree with. And, on the other side, there are “Woke” challenges to a whole bunch of other stuff. This is going on while in what used to be the Soviet Bloc, Russia is busy getting rid of any Ukrainian books and Ukraine is busy dumping Russian books. Don’t get me wrong, I know which side I’m on in both cases (and it ain’t with the Proud Boys and Vladimir Putin) but in a world where one can be called a groomer for not thinking a drag queen is an automatic paedophile (I think that sums up the argument) it’s great to see Ireland resisting attempts to remove books. Freedom comes with a cost and it’s unfortunately the public library sector that is starting to pay.

Changes by local authority

National news

  • 3 Essential Components Of The Library – Princh. Staff, events/programmes, IT.
  • Alan Hopkinson IFLA Conference Award 2023 – IFLA. “This Award enables a CILIP member in their early career (full criteria below) to experience the IFLA Congress.  The Award covers the whole cost of the IFLA conference fee and £100 towards travel and accommodation.”
  • The British Library doesn’t need £500m – but local libraries do – Guardian / Letters. “Since 2010 almost 800 local libraries have been closed across the UK, with the loss of 10,000 staff, and many surviving libraries are at best part-time. Against this backdrop, it is staggering to read that an investment of £500m has been proposed for the British Library (Green light given for huge British Library extension, 3 February). Communities all over the country are being deprived of free access to not only books and information, but also the internet …” see also British Library extension given green light by Camden Council – Built Environment Networking. 100,000 extra square foot.
  • Community Managed Libraries Map – Community Managed Libraries National Peer Network. Google Map of volunteer libraries. [Not entirely accurate – Ed.]
  • Funding fears: Libraries should be staffed like any other council service – Yahoo News. ” Professor Peter Reid says free access to books remains fundamentally important in a civilised society. The professor of librarianship at Aberdeen’s Robert Gordon University added that while it might be a time of crisis for local government finances, libraries can and do evolve.”
  • GLL-operated libraries battle digital exclusion with free SIM card scheme – GLL (press release). “More than 60 libraries operated by charitable social enterprise GLL, have this week launched a scheme to provide nearly 16,000 free SIM cards to residents on low incomes and those who are struggling with the cost of living. Libraries located in London’s Bromley, Greenwich and Wandsworth, along with those in Dudley and Lincolnshire will be distributing the cards, building on GLL’s existing Warm Spaces initiative – set up to support those struggling to afford sharp rises in utility bills. The ability to offer free SIM cards is the result of a successful application to the Good Things Foundation and courtesy of mobile phone network operators 3, 02 and Vodafone.”
  • Libraries vital for new and growing businesses, briefing reveals – Libraries Connected. “Our new briefing, ‘Supporting Business and Enterprise’, shows that public libraries are central to realising this ambition. Through Business & IP Centres and other localised services, the library network has become one of the country’s most effective and accessible sources of support for new and growing businesses. As the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee recently put it, libraries act as “engines for entrepreneurship, economic growth and job creation””
  • Make Music Day 2023 – Libraries Meet Up – EventBrite. Tuesday 14 March, 4pm, online. “Make Music Day is an annual set of free music events taking place in venues and public spaces – from town squares to libraries, bandstands to school halls and arts centres. It takes place on the longest day of the year – on 21 June.”
  • Nursery rhymes banned in Scottish library events over ‘historical racism’ fears – Telegraph. “Popular “Bookbug” sessions are held for young children across Scotland with the support of the Scottish Book Trust, the Holyrood-backed charity which has told libraries and nurseries hosting these events that certain songs should no longer be sung. Despite having lyrics unrelated to race, Five Little Monkeys has been banned because it has “historical racist intent”.”
  • Public Libraries 2022: Netloan Customer Survey Results – Lorensbergs. “Average footfall has reached nearly 70% of pre-Covid levels, up from around 50% at end of 2021″
  • Public Libraries Project of the Year Grant – National Acquisitions Group. “£5,000 available for a project from a NAG Member library.”
  • Tricky decisions as Scotland’s councils face budget shortfalls – BBC. “Individual local authorities have shortfalls ranging from around £7m in the Scottish Borders to £120m at Glasgow City Council, according to research by the BBC.”

International news

Local news by authority

“The Minister talks about the terrible circumstances in Ukraine and the events of the last year, but he must recognise that the scale of the cuts since 2010 have been devastating for our local authorities, which have had to consider closing libraries, swimming pools, leisure centres and so forth. Can he confirm that it is in fact more of a long-term problem and that we need greater investment in our public services?”

Margaret Greenwood MP Labour, Wirral West
  • Worcestershire – Threat to city’s libraries as ‘lifeline’ funding set to be pulled – Yahoo News. “The future of some of the city’s libraries could be thrown into doubt as part of a plan to cut ‘lifeline’ funding. Worcester City Council pledged to supply £157,000 to Worcestershire County Council every year as part of a deal to keep services running at Warndon and St John’s libraries in 2019. But now city council bosses are discussing pulling the plug on the agreement and leaving the county to fund the service.”
  • York – Dringhouses library faces temporary closure for heating repairs – Press. “Due to issues with the heating system at Dringhouses Library, York Explore Libraries & Archives has notified councillors of plans to temporarily close the library from Monday February 13 until the end of the month. Ward councillors have raised concerns about the impact of the temporary closure on the local community and have asked for an urgent meeting with Explore to discuss possible temporary solutions which would ensure that staff, volunteers and residents can safely access vital services.”